Bunkou no Hito-tachi

[DANDAN_THE_DANDAN]

@Lymus well said

 

[KuroDubZero]

Looking at the guidelines for this site, I guess this would fall into a porn category because of the uncensored penis and plot. Though it makes me wonder how many other series are labeled porn on here when in reality they're supposed to be considered regular manga.

Edit: I don't disagree with the decision, just adding my 2cents.

 

[Dysisa]

I don't really like the hentai labeling decision, but I do understand it more than well, so I'm not going to somehow try to fight against it. Glad this place has good staff like Lymus who takes the time to explain things like this.

 

[Zacchino]

There's something deeply unsettling about this piece, can't quite put my finger on what exactly that is though.

 

[Acarphinus]

So far (chapt 1-6) there's almost nothing in this manga but sex. But I clearly can tell why many folks don't think this is porn or hentai. It really doesn't seem like the author is trying to turn on the reader. If she is, she's totally failing.
It's like we are watching fish mate. The characters are so distant from each other, and from the reader, that the story seems like an anthropology paper.
I'm kind of interested in the idea of a school with two students, so i'd like them to keep their clothes on for a bit and move on with the story.

 

[ThePaulBunyanTrophy]

This is classic Yamamoto Naoki.

Honestly, if you think Yamamoto crossed the line with this manga, you haven't read the last chapter of vol. 1 of Fragments.

 

[Exzerox]

So i need to know is this like one of the rarest manga in japan or something? I have been to like 10 different stores in akiharbara, been to all the stores in osaka, checked it kyoto and found nothing. I have asked the staff in each store to check the data base for it, and it doesnt exist. If anyone knows of a store in japan with it please let me know

Ok update: I found it and bought it (Vol 3) It's great. Go buy it everyone who read this and loved it.

 

[bitfarb]

Horny, bored kids experimenting in an almost deadpan, matter-of-fact way..it's weird how nice this is.
They just need to get hold of some condoms and find a more private room now.

 

[TwilightFaze]

@Exzerox: A physical copy may not even exist. Some manga are internet only, like on Twitter or Pixiv or something. If you can't find it in all these stores, your best bet is to try the internet stores. If you can find it there, they'll be able to tell you if a physical copy exists or not.

 

[nolyta09]

i cant open manga raw ...

 

[pratomoastan]

Its cool

 

[Lettosk]

Spoiler

Mixed feelings with the last chapter of the main series.

Really author, why did you have to mix in the teacher with Dobashi?

Though I couldn't understand what they were talking about, the three kids were all right between them: a little of jealousy of Dobashi around here, a little of lewdness with Kobayashi around there, but fine between them. So then you put the teacher telling Dobashi that he saw her fucking with the mc and then, well obvious what happened.

Althought after "that" the three of them keep together, that still piss me off.

 

[ShiroVn]

@Lettosk Thanks, now I know what to avoid reading forward

 

[Nighthawlc]

@ShiroVn

Spoiler

It doesn't happen until C30 out of 32 so you can keep reading until then if it bothers you.

 

[CheerTheDead]

@Lymus
If it is the case, you can create a bilayers censorship.

The first layer is to block ERO manga which is not published as a hentai manga but have scenes that goes against your standard.
The second layer is to block HENTAI manga.

Both layers will be blocked by default and only opened for readers with certain ages or readers that want to bypass.

As a manga reading site, i believe we should be more aligned with the globally general consensus. For that reason, a manga should only be

Labeled "H" if it is a Hentai manga.
Otherwise, just put a "E" for ERO and warn the users.

 

[OverlordSaiki]

@CheerTheDead Ecchi ones are already marked tho.
They are not banned so there's no need to hide them like hentai.
It's not porn but it's also not safe. So smut, sexual violence, ecchi, gore are already caution tags.
There's no need for more censorship than there already is. Tags are enough warning.

 

[CheerTheDead]

@OverlordSaiki

I find your comment and mine have no connection.

 

[hyoretsu]

@CheerTheDead this manga doesn't have that much story though, it's basically a Hentai. Heck, half of it happened in less than a day between the multiple sex scenes. Also Aki-Sora, for example has lots of sex scenes, but they don't depict genitals and have an actual story they follow, so it's tagged as Ecchi and Smut but not Hentai, and not blocked.
If someone doesn't want to read ecchi he can just avoid those tags, but the same can't be said for Hentai because of its ban on some countries, which affects MangaDex (and the users who live there) as a whole.

 

[CheerTheDead]

@hyoretsu

I believe i have never used the word Ecchi in my entire comment.

ECCHI
ERO
and HENTAI

are different.

 

[hyoretsu]

@CheerTheDead And I definitely have no idea what Ero manga even is, nor does Google lol. Only thing that comes up is Eromanga-sensei.
There is ecchi, borderline hentai and hentai, and Aki-Sora is borderline hentai.