In Another World, I'm Called: the Black Healer - Vol. 5 Ch. 36
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 31, 2018
- Messages
- 1,143
It started as an interesting isekai, but right now all I can see is forced drama, forced plot, pretty much everything is showed down and it doesn't feel natural or cohesic at all.
Supporter
- Joined
- May 7, 2018
- Messages
- 1,317
Finally, this awful arc ended. This manga would have been so much better without the daemon lord and god.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- May 31, 2018
- Messages
- 1,143
@Sparrow75 What romance part? The "you can go home, but your puppy dies, so just live out 400 years here, but actually you should just fall in love with this guy right now, and spend thousands of years with him"? Yeah, best romantic story ever 
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2018
- Messages
- 154
@Istvan90623 still a better lovestory than twilight
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2018
- Messages
- 344
@WhimsiCat I'm glad someone here is not too busy criticizing the story to appreciate that panel. XD
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Apr 4, 2018
- Messages
- 7,399
ignorance is bliss...
they don't know how close they were to annihilation
they don't know how close they were to annihilation
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2018
- Messages
- 3,542
Well, the isekai part felt really short the last few chapters. But now she has a quest and a shiny new power to protect her from ... was it forced contracts? That should prove interesting when facing the church. Go and add that shota to your harem girl. And there is also that raping prince guy, she has to take down. In a brutal way. Plenty of isekaish storylines.
Member
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2018
- Messages
- 14
What rubs me the wrong way, is how little agency Reene has in this whole matter. She is pretty much treated like an object. And instead of presenting how irritating and humiliating this all is, even the author just rolls with it.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2018
- Messages
- 21,807
Noche has got his priorities right. Being the king of the most powerful race in the world obviously is nothing compared to being Reene's boyfriend.
@Asturaetus If you bring the author into this, then obviously nothing matters, but if we keep it to the world of the story itself, it's at least half Reene's own fault. She's all the time hanging around people who are used to giving orders all day long, that is, princes, kings, nobles, knights, officers, you name it. If she doesn't push back, she's going to be pushed nonstop. That's why lots of people, myself included, have been saying since the beginning that she should have made it a priority to gain personal offensive and defensive power. If you don't need protection but most offenders would instead be afraid, it immediately changes how you are treated. Lots of other characters we see are immensely martial, so they would automatically respect power. In Noche's case obviously little would change since the dude is in power only second to Gaia, but the very reason why Reene is in that world was to meet Noche and deal with him, so I don't think it's, per se, a problem. She already has some ways to manage his weird personality and she will develop more, no doubt.
@Asturaetus If you bring the author into this, then obviously nothing matters, but if we keep it to the world of the story itself, it's at least half Reene's own fault. She's all the time hanging around people who are used to giving orders all day long, that is, princes, kings, nobles, knights, officers, you name it. If she doesn't push back, she's going to be pushed nonstop. That's why lots of people, myself included, have been saying since the beginning that she should have made it a priority to gain personal offensive and defensive power. If you don't need protection but most offenders would instead be afraid, it immediately changes how you are treated. Lots of other characters we see are immensely martial, so they would automatically respect power. In Noche's case obviously little would change since the dude is in power only second to Gaia, but the very reason why Reene is in that world was to meet Noche and deal with him, so I don't think it's, per se, a problem. She already has some ways to manage his weird personality and she will develop more, no doubt.
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Jun 5, 2018
- Messages
- 924
Damn guys I freaking loved the demon king and god arc. Is obvious since the beggining (the dreams) that there would be sone kind of plot related to that. I love this kind of thing. It was very well planned, in my opinion.
I didn't like the fact that she can end her lifespan there and then go back to her life in earth. Like... No. Too easy.
I didn't like the fact that she can end her lifespan there and then go back to her life in earth. Like... No. Too easy.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2018
- Messages
- 2,454
Honestly, the yandere Demon King cracks me up hahaha, but I'll be waiting to see how the story unfolds from now on
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2018
- Messages
- 382
Igreed with @blueoddog.
The premise for this arc was there since the very beggining. The dreams were foreshadow of what was coming too.
The way this arc was excecuted was not the best it could go, but it worked out as planned. It was average.
I got no bad feelings for this arc, if not only for the part were it's just too easy for her to go back to her world after she dies, mangaka could have build way more tension and delivered a better climax to that FREAKING IMPORTANT LIFE CHANGING DECISION.
And there's lenty of stuff to work on, The Crazy Prince, The Other human with programing skills that Gaia talked about, wars, Gaia Children of the Church, the relationship with the Demon Lord Itself. There's plenty to work on.
The premise for this arc was there since the very beggining. The dreams were foreshadow of what was coming too.
The way this arc was excecuted was not the best it could go, but it worked out as planned. It was average.
I got no bad feelings for this arc, if not only for the part were it's just too easy for her to go back to her world after she dies, mangaka could have build way more tension and delivered a better climax to that FREAKING IMPORTANT LIFE CHANGING DECISION.
And there's lenty of stuff to work on, The Crazy Prince, The Other human with programing skills that Gaia talked about, wars, Gaia Children of the Church, the relationship with the Demon Lord Itself. There's plenty to work on.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2018
- Messages
- 1,519
So after 400 or 7000 years she gets to automatically reset herself back on earth, but will she even remember what life on earth was like after 7000 years. Sure after 400 years you might still have some vague recollection, but after 7000? Seems like a pretty big plot hole. The alternate option of wiping her memory is also a bad option since it will mean that everything that occurs in this manga is completely meaningless in the long run.
Sure you stopped society from being reset for a bit, but God doesn't allow you to bring progress to their world. In fact he actively prevents progress from occurring, so the only thing you can really do is sit around with your harem of bishonen for 7000 years in a world that won't progress or change. Then, after all of that waiting, the big reset happens at which point you are placed back in your own world where you forget about everything that occurred with your one true love/fated person. You also have the bonus of not being able to fall in love with anyone for the rest of your life on earth no matter which option you chose. If you remember you've lost your 7000 year companion. If you forget, your personal feelings were already manipulated by the God of another world so that you'll only truly love your fated person. Seems like a fucked up situation. Then the cherry on the crap sundae is that if you remember you've lost all of your healing abilities. Over the course of 400~7000 years there has to be several medical advances that you will learn that you could apply back in the real world, but ultimately you won't be able to do any of them since you won't have your magic any longer. Leading to situations where you'll have someone die in a medical situation (since I'm assuming she would become a doctor) that you know you could save if you could use your true powers. Of course, once again none of this matters if you memory is wiped. It all seems like a big waste of time and effort where the only end goal is to entertain a bored God.
On the bright side, at least she now has a harem house with member #1 Kumon at her disposal right now. Maybe her big brother that was mentioned in chapter 30 will get thrown into the story as well at some point. Who knows.
Sure you stopped society from being reset for a bit, but God doesn't allow you to bring progress to their world. In fact he actively prevents progress from occurring, so the only thing you can really do is sit around with your harem of bishonen for 7000 years in a world that won't progress or change. Then, after all of that waiting, the big reset happens at which point you are placed back in your own world where you forget about everything that occurred with your one true love/fated person. You also have the bonus of not being able to fall in love with anyone for the rest of your life on earth no matter which option you chose. If you remember you've lost your 7000 year companion. If you forget, your personal feelings were already manipulated by the God of another world so that you'll only truly love your fated person. Seems like a fucked up situation. Then the cherry on the crap sundae is that if you remember you've lost all of your healing abilities. Over the course of 400~7000 years there has to be several medical advances that you will learn that you could apply back in the real world, but ultimately you won't be able to do any of them since you won't have your magic any longer. Leading to situations where you'll have someone die in a medical situation (since I'm assuming she would become a doctor) that you know you could save if you could use your true powers. Of course, once again none of this matters if you memory is wiped. It all seems like a big waste of time and effort where the only end goal is to entertain a bored God.
On the bright side, at least she now has a harem house with member #1 Kumon at her disposal right now. Maybe her big brother that was mentioned in chapter 30 will get thrown into the story as well at some point. Who knows.
Similar threads
