Shokubutsu Monster Musume Nikki ~Seijo datta Watashi ga Uragireta Hate ni Aruraune ni Tensei Shite Shimatta node, kore kara wa Kougousei wo Shinagara…

Supporter
Joined
Aug 20, 2018
Messages
436
image0.jpg

You're a plant, shouldn't you need carbon dioxide?
The web novel mixes up oxygen and carbon dioxide in this scene too (chapter 61 in WN).
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 5, 2018
Messages
408
I was not expecting the mc to get fingered by a loli to produce nectar, even if it was important for her to heal the witch. There are so many lewd ways to describe it that I can't even think of ways to describe it that aren't lewd. The first line there was close to my minimum lewd, and my hands refuse to type maximum lewd. Honestly there are so many things in this chapter that can be described super lewdly I feel overloaded.

Also to everyone talking about oxygen and carbon dioxide being mixed up. Even though they are a net producer plants do in fact need oxygen the same way animals do. They use carbon dioxide to produce sugar, but to get chemical energy from that sugar they use oxygen the same as animals. Plants in the dark consume oxygen because they aren't producing any, and release carbon dioxide do to not having a use for it in the dark. Besides that, if they were to spend more energy than they produce they would have to use oxygen for that as well. The mc probably isn't a net consumer of oxygen, but she clearly uses more energy than a normal plant.
 
Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2023
Messages
6
Also to everyone talking about oxygen and carbon dioxide being mixed up. Even though they are a net producer plants do in fact need oxygen the same way animals do. They use carbon dioxide to produce sugar, but to get chemical energy from that sugar they use oxygen the same as animals. Plants in the dark consume oxygen because they aren't producing any, and release carbon dioxide do to not having a use for it in the dark. Besides that, if they were to spend more energy than they produce they would have to use oxygen for that as well. The mc probably isn't a net consumer of oxygen, but she clearly uses more energy than a normal plant.
Spot on explanation. If it weren't a fantasy setting she'd definitely be a net consumer of oxygen based on her low surface area to volume ratio for photosynthesis and the fact that she's pretty mobile.

I'd say that having a brain would make that even more of an issue, but given the magic consciousness transfer shenanigans she might not even have one?

Edit: Thought about it more and I realized how stupid that was since she's clearly using the human half's sensory organs. I might find the idea of her head being a bunch of non-differentiated plant matter entertaining, but it's super unlikely. orz
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 11, 2018
Messages
282
1. Plants need fixed nitrogen in the soil. Nitrogen in the air means very little to them.

2. She reincarnated from earth, so even if she doesn't identify with that life anymore she should still know that.
yup n2 in the air really stable making it useless for anything at all. those bacteria in the plant root is using magic turn it into something usable.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Messages
949
1. Plants need fixed nitrogen in the soil. Nitrogen in the air means very little to them.

2. She reincarnated from earth, so even if she doesn't identify with that life anymore she should still know that.
Also, one of the few tidbits we've gotten about her first life was that she was into plants.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 9, 2023
Messages
498
Why is she not talking things out properly with the witch?
"don't eat my nectar [but I won't mention the why]" "stingy! I'm gonna anyway!" etc.
If they communicate properly, they stop being useless, and then their lesbian cred is in jeopardy. We're under romcom rules now.
Also, feels like feeding the witch should be easy enough. Since she can kill any of those monsters that witch "saved" her from this chapter (using her poisons). And if she finds a fruit, she should be able to grow fruits for her.
A temporary solution at best. Woman cannot live on fruit alone. Even throwing in some cucumber and eggplant won't suffice.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Sep 18, 2019
Messages
36
I just discovered this manga and binged it in one night. Birds already chirping when I finished it. I want moooaaaar. Thanks for the TL.

How popular is the source material? Anyone knows?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 5, 2023
Messages
112
Why is she not talking things out properly with the witch?
"don't eat my nectar [but I won't mention the why]" "stingy! I'm gonna anyway!" etc.
Iris seems to have difficulty speaking in general - if you pay attention to which lines are actually being spoken and which ones are just her own internal thoughts, the former are limited to very short, simple statements, and even those are broken up into multiple speech bubbles in a way that suggests that they're coming out in a halting manner ("What a big... pond!" "I can use... this water!") which suggests that it takes a lot of effort to put them together and actually speak them. It seems like regressing back to a little baby toddler body has severely impacted her ability to properly communicate with others.
Also to everyone talking about oxygen and carbon dioxide being mixed up. Even though they are a net producer plants do in fact need oxygen the same way animals do. They use carbon dioxide to produce sugar, but to get chemical energy from that sugar they use oxygen the same as animals. Plants in the dark consume oxygen because they aren't producing any, and release carbon dioxide do to not having a use for it in the dark. Besides that, if they were to spend more energy than they produce they would have to use oxygen for that as well. The mc probably isn't a net consumer of oxygen, but she clearly uses more energy than a normal plant.
I was just about to say this, but also, even if she was a botanist and should "know better", it's not unreasonable that you wouldn't be thinking too hard about which gasses your biology specifically needs when you're fucking drowning and being attacked by crocodiles. The fact that she's even thinking about "oxygen" in a situation like this and not just "air" already makes her kind of a nerd.
 
Aggregator gang
Joined
Oct 10, 2024
Messages
138
It's gonna be for a very looong time until they meet the assholey prince and his bitchy bitch, right?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 14, 2023
Messages
236
Iris seems to have difficulty speaking in general - if you pay attention to which lines are actually being spoken and which ones are just her own internal thoughts, the former are limited to very short, simple statements, and even those are broken up into multiple speech bubbles in a way that suggests that they're coming out in a halting manner ("What a big... pond!" "I can use... this water!") which suggests that it takes a lot of effort to put them together and actually speak them. It seems like regressing back to a little baby toddler body has severely impacted her ability to properly communicate with others.
She's had trouble speaking ever since she became an alraune. She ate that one plant that let her vocalize, but mimicking human speech with any degree of accuracy is still quite difficult for her.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 2, 2019
Messages
4,938
Iris seems to have difficulty speaking in general - if you pay attention to which lines are actually being spoken and which ones are just her own internal thoughts, the former are limited to very short, simple statements, and even those are broken up into multiple speech bubbles in a way that suggests that they're coming out in a halting manner ("What a big... pond!" "I can use... this water!") which suggests that it takes a lot of effort to put them together and actually speak them. It seems like regressing back to a little baby toddler body has severely impacted her ability to properly communicate with others.

I was just about to say this, but also, even if she was a botanist and should "know better", it's not unreasonable that you wouldn't be thinking too hard about which gasses your biology specifically needs when you're fucking drowning and being attacked by crocodiles. The fact that she's even thinking about "oxygen" in a situation like this and not just "air" already makes her kind of a nerd.
She's had trouble speaking ever since she became an alraune. She ate that one plant that let her vocalize, but mimicking human speech with any degree of accuracy is still quite difficult for her.
My point is that she can vocalize. So even if it takes some effort and is split into multiple bubbles, then that is exactly what she can do. Or, yknow, she could simply use a single word that explains everything even standalone: "addictive narcotics"
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top