Viruka-san VS
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Contributor
- Joined
- Dec 31, 2019
- Messages
- 17,888
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2018
- Messages
- 116
I wish comics of this type wouldn't make the fantasy world's cuisine so arbitrarily awful. Your Japanese character can impress with their cooking without having to make the fantasy world incompetent at a task so well mastered by pre-modern cultures as baking bread.
@100thlurker
her world is basically medieval tech level, still having food shortages and using slave labor. Makes sense in this case.
her world is basically medieval tech level, still having food shortages and using slave labor. Makes sense in this case.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2018
- Messages
- 2,109
@100thlurker
It kinda goes with our own history, however. If you go back to feudal times - whether in Japan or the west - food shortages and crop failure were common and you often had to eat whatever was edible. It could easily be the case in a world such as hers without some huge authority or power like the Romans making trade possible that they simply don't have much in the way of choosing to eat. And sometimes or often don't have anything. Especially for a slave.
Is it an overused trope? Yes. It is also truth in fiction? Also yes. I just hate it when they pull the "GRORIOUS NIPPON FOOD SUPERIOR! BONZAI!" card which is really fucking tiring to see. (Especially when a lot of the dishes used aren't entirely Japanese in origin sometimes...)
It kinda goes with our own history, however. If you go back to feudal times - whether in Japan or the west - food shortages and crop failure were common and you often had to eat whatever was edible. It could easily be the case in a world such as hers without some huge authority or power like the Romans making trade possible that they simply don't have much in the way of choosing to eat. And sometimes or often don't have anything. Especially for a slave.
Is it an overused trope? Yes. It is also truth in fiction? Also yes. I just hate it when they pull the "GRORIOUS NIPPON FOOD SUPERIOR! BONZAI!" card which is really fucking tiring to see. (Especially when a lot of the dishes used aren't entirely Japanese in origin sometimes...)
@N30N24 Someone did research and found they INTENDED to make it "velka", but the author japanized then romanized it wrong to "vierca" and the publisher romanized it wrong to "viruka"
So really "velka" is what the author wanted to name her. "vierca" is what he actually named her, and "viruka" is what the publisher who couldn't be assed to ask the author named her.
So really "velka" is what the author wanted to name her. "vierca" is what he actually named her, and "viruka" is what the publisher who couldn't be assed to ask the author named her.
@100thlurker
It's to establish power imbalance between characters (ignorant vs knowledgeable) and exploit the dymanics for the story. A horrible take on it would be "civilizing a savage: the story" which is why it irks me to see it sometimes.
Food goes pretty deep though.
It's to establish power imbalance between characters (ignorant vs knowledgeable) and exploit the dymanics for the story. A horrible take on it would be "civilizing a savage: the story" which is why it irks me to see it sometimes.
Food goes pretty deep though.
Every homogeneous country takes pride in their culture and food as an aspect of culture. While most countries promote pride in culture and nationality, the US and a handful of other countries actively play down promoting pride in those things. If you say "American culture" and "national pride" they somehow have a negative connotation. Since food is a part of culture, Americans taking pride in food feels off somehow. There's also the fact that a lot of American foods are bastardized/corporatized versions of some other country's food. I think apple pie and tater tots are American in origin, and maybe at some point in history people took pride in that, but not anymore. We're like, it's just apple pie and tater tots. So since the manga is written for a Japanese audience it actually appeals to their readers that someone in a lower social position would become "cultured" by enjoying Japanese food, and if the person is actually in a high social position then even better. Honestly I don't know how to feel about all that. The first time I saw KFC and Pizza Hut in an anime my mind was screaming a dunkey "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!" But then I was like why wouldn't Japanese enjoy fried chicken and pizza? And speaking of pizza, that one gets strange. It feels like something American, but it originated in Italy, but then the Chinese claim it's a bastardized version of one of their old recipes Marco Polo copied so they're claiming to have originated it. But then it's like couldn't it also be possible that people all over the world who can make bread were like let's bake some non-bread items on this bread and eat it? Similarly, how unique is it to bake apple pie when apples aren't from America? Food rabbit hole is deep.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2018
- Messages
- 6,445
Cute neko loli ^w^
Member
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2019
- Messages
- 506
Plantar wart, also called a verruca
This is what I think of when I read her name.
This is what I think of when I read her name.
