I agree completely. But, in retrospect, it makes sense, and that makes it doubly refreshing: after all, they have established that the children were specifically chosen because they were brighter than their peers, along with other excellent qualities. It's sometimes a little easy to forget...
I don't recall ever seeing a flashback to Rosemary's backstory, now that you mention it.
I think you might be right, maybe she is simply that docile. In some ways, the little shadow-nymphs seem to pick up on and exaggerate certain aspects of their "living doll's" personality, and in other...
Edward has been presented as the story's villain from the first chapters, and certainly he's done some bad things, BUT... really, when you step back from a distance and look back over the story, has he really been THAT wrong?
For example, the characters he seemed to be the most unfair to and...
Same here, I saw the anime first and maybe that makes a difference, but it seemed pretty obvious to me after a couple viewings that she probably survived, and that the real surprise would be how and when she came back and what she was doing in the mean time, not "if" she came back.
And if I had...