Okay that's your point, English is not my first language. If you're going to be that picky about wording, I can change ‘date' to 'in a relationship'. However, even if I don't change my wording, the relationship between Yuu and Yami remains the same.
If you keep ignoring the facts, I have nothing more to say. I don't even understand what kind of relationship you think Yuu and Yami had. From my perspective, you're just trying to justify certain things he did by turning a blind eye to his other actions.
If you date someone, then you are in love with them. Simple and easy. Can you date someone while still loving someone else? Technically, you can, but if you do so then you are not innocent.
Okay, if you want to play
That's him, Yuu, who said 'I've always loved you', not me. If he wanted to confess, he could have just said 'I like you, can we date?' No, he didn't. He chose to use 'I've always loved you since childhood' to add weight to his feelings. (However, he was even crying...
Based on the fact that he dated Yami, plus what he said during his confession, either he was lying to Hikari about always loving her, or he never loved Yami and just used her for sex. Or maybe you could say he loved them both at the same time lol. Either way, he's not innocent.
That's him, Yuu, who said 'I've always loved you', not me. If he wanted to confess, he could have just said 'I like you, can we date?' No, he didn't. He chose to use 'I've always loved you since childhood' to add weight to his feelings. (However, he was even crying over his ex-girlfriend just an...
You really don't understand or you don't want to understand? He said he's always loved Hikari since childhood. No, obviously not. He dated Yami for half a year - how can he claim he's always loved Hikari since childhood? How can you say this isn't a lie? If Hikari hadn't seen what happened in...
If he wanted to confess and said something like 'I've always loved you' during the confession, then that's not prerogative. It's simply a lie, and unfortunately for him, Hikari called him out on it directly.
That's exactly what Hikari did -- she told Yami many things about Yuu and vice versa, confronted Yami to talk about the whole thing instead of just accepting the confession and kissing him. Which Yami and Yuu should've done at the school festival but they didn't