Those that leave the academy must be "sealed" for the sake of the world (since they can't let psychopaths with power run amok on our world, just other worlds), and when they try to do that to him, they might discover something about him and/or Felice that would give away who she is.
The second problem could kind of make sense. Yes, they spent 30,000 years there, but it was just the two of them, so how socially developed he becomes, or how well his thought processes, outside of his training to kill her, become could be quite stunted. He never learned to live in the real...
They showed up right when he got back, gave him his summons, told him showing up was not optional, and immediately left. He wouldn't have been able to avoid some sort of interaction. Even if he claimed not to be, they still would have shown up and tried to make him attend, and that would have...
I did offer some explanation before, that you either missed or glossed over, but here is a more detailed explanation. At the bottom is a list of things he would potentially have to fear, that you seem to fall under the "am I missing anything" category.
Since a person's "Root" is their soul, and...
I do find it interesting that the school has a ton of heroes they already have used, and know the capabilities of, that they can send on missions, and yet the goddess still continue to summon a lot of additional people to turn into new heroes and have them join the school. It makes me wonder if...
Nope, I didn't forget that, because there is nothing to forget. It is never stated in the manga that he was summoned by the Kingdom. If it is, please provide the quote and chapter. In fact, if you look at the beginning of chapter 18, when the rogue hero talks about being summoned, you can...
Usually can have a spread of meanings, from "almost always the case" to "just over half the time", but that doesn't mean that when it is used, you can pick the definition that best fits your argument, and declare that to be the proper meaning for that instance. Context clues matter. So, what are...
I had just posted it, so there was basically no way for you to see it. I was simply making a shorter post to only reply to your question, instead of expecting you to read a long post that wasn't a reply to you, that also had that answer in it.
As I said in my other, lengthy reply, I think the reason the goddesses didn't notice the MC's irregularity is because of how many heroes are summoned and return. So when a hero returns, each goddess probably only takes note of "One (or a group) of my heroes has (or have) returned," or "A hero...
If "conjecture" means "never 100% proven", then both sides of this debate are firmly "conjecture". But some of what you've asserted isn't accurate, based on the manga so far. Until the manga is completed, then anything talked about would be from "incomplete evidence" as something could come up...
I just caught up to this, and haven't read the Light Novels (or every chapter's comments), so I don't know if this has been raised/discussed before, but I started wondering. They say the homonculi lost their reason due to Solomon, their object of affection, disappearing. What if Bel has...
It isn't just the old "nothing can ever happen because bad guy x" when the skill is literally "instant death". It's not the same as saying that some bad guys use swords, so no good guys should ever use swords, or some bad guys use magic, so no good guys should use magic. I'm not even saying the...
Unfortunately, this would probably be a really bad idea, and the reason why would also be a great reason for why they tell everybody it is such a trash skill.
Unless somewhere in the chain there is a skill that provides immunity to instant death skills, then training everybody that gets the...
@comeonnow0 To continue the history, we then have to look at how comeonnow0 tries to frame the narrative, in order to justify the stance that Tina should have been failed. Previously he said to pass Jere's condition was "show me enough skill to make me believe you are capable of joining the...
@comeonnow0 So here we start with a (hopefully) brief history of this discussion, and how it went from a discussion of whether or not it was reasonable to say Jere made the right evaluation and had the wrong response to that right evaluation, to one side abandoning the discussion of merit to...