no he would not lol he would have had bouts of depression like anyone but he could have gotten over everything in a much healthy way said charm legit only made things worst and gave him very dangerous level of mental instability making him unable to cope with said feelings to the point he lost...
she is littreally the main cause of his mental instability so yes she did very much hurt him the fact you tried to excuse it has not much compared to the others is laughable when it has done quite ablit of damage to him and the fact he was not able to naturally move on when needed
Few of yall missing the point lol even she knew waiting a 100 years was more or less never going to happen it was just a silly hope for her. The issue is the fuck boy littreally moved on after a year which even by our own standards if someone made a promise like that and did was dude did he get...