Urakata de Support Shiteta Geinou Ikka wo Tsuihousareta Boku wa, Futsuu no Seishun wo Ouka Shitai - Vol. 1 Ch. 1 - Banished From My Family

[anzuda]

I know entertainment business is a cut throat world, but i didn't think it would be to the point they would cut their own "throat" like that...

 

[anzuda]

Let me be that unwanted mooching uncle at every family party just this once, because yes, I admit I’ve contributed nothing to the manga industry aside from being a filthy scanlation reader. But someone please remind me why Japan is mass-producing already-written stories?

Short answer, cause that's what sells.

A not so long answer, Publisher want something they know would sell, Mangaka was forced either to make copy pasted story by their editor/publisher or their original one that aren't popular enough, budding mangaka saw what's on a lot of shelves and decide to join the wagon, adult/teen reader wants to know what's in the manga even before they read the synopsis or the first page so indirectly they encourage the long ass title, and the young teen reader wants fantasy like this (i remember the day where i almost exclusively read harem manga like Mahou Sensei Negima, Kami nomi zo shiru sekai, Sekirei, Sora no Otoshimono, etc. And yes, it's all harem ecchi action manga that basically have pretty similar plot though the case back then aren't as bad as the copy paste plot of today)

Only the talented story writer/manga artist that free from this current cycle.

 

[SupremeDoc]

I swear the isekai trend makes anyone's brain wired into thinking banishment is reserved to isekai/fantasy stories. Given that it is in the modern world, I wonder if they will be lost without him or lose so much money in hiring so many people to do the job he easily did? Also if they hate men, how the hell did the mom pump out 8 kids without losing her mind. This has a follow for me because hearing that it is trending in Japan can be either a hit or a miss. Thanks for the translations.

if they end up worse without him, this is literally the fantasy trope where the party kicks out the "useless" member who is actually competent and was keeping the whole party running.

(Reads first chapter) sooo he won't be banging his sisters. So hey, there's something!

i see some potential with the sister that didnt openly shit on him. gotta be a reason for that

I just can't stand the bootlicking protagonists in stories like this. They're always portrayed as "kind," but it just comes off as pathetic naivety to me. His family literally laughs in his face, treating him like he's subhuman, and his reaction is:

Thank them for what? Dude could get kicked in the balls and still lick their shoes clean for daring to sully them with his filthy self. This is just too Japanese for my taste. He's the type of person who'd overwork himself to death for a shitty company, and then thank them for the privilege.

thought the same thing. when he started begging to stay after all the shit they said to him, I was like bro take the hint and leave already. ig since hes still young and it all happened so fast, he acts like this. but for them to be comically evil and all he do is bow his head is frustrating

Kind of interesting, right up until the last page. Straight up murdered any and all interest.

bro immediately gets saved by a harem, you can't make this shit up

 

[AICyberCogGenAI]

Men are filthy pigs doesn't sound right when you have 8 kids

 

[fucknvampire]

You're the trash, you flat chested virmin. I will take great pleasure in watching you bitches realize you're barely third rate without him.

 

[Rhodes_Islander]

Hmmm...

grab a barrel of gasoline, wooden planks, and nails

Who wants to help me barbecue some bitches?

I'm in.

 

[betetta]

Let me be that unwanted mooching uncle at every family party just this once, because yes, I admit I’ve contributed nothing to the manga industry aside from being a filthy scanlation reader. But someone please remind me why Japan is mass-producing already-written stories?

I swear, there has to be a template system in some manga factory where they just tweak the parameters. Fucking adjust the eye color, change the party class from healer to blacksmith, add one talking slime mascot and boom, a new series that looks like effort was made. Somewhere, there is an office full of professionals overseeing a manga and an actual editor approving the 18,381,738th iteration of “banished from the hero’s party”.

Realistically, I get it. They’re churning these out to meet demand, to keep the pages filled between their real hotshot titles. Maybe it’s something in between easy to sell, cheap to produce, passable for the mass market. But I can’t help but feel sorry for the artists. Some of these mangaka have talent, and it’s being wasted on this rinse-repeat cycle of cliché slop.

Is there ever that one sane person?? Anyone who’ll just say, “Guys, this sht is stale. No one’s finishing these stories because the ending writes itself.” At this point, reading one of these is like watching Detective Conan except instead of a murder mystery, the thrill is guessing which trope gets checked off next. The betrayal? The overpowered MC humblebragging about skills he didn’t know he had? The shocked ex-party member eating dirt?

I know, I’m ranting from an ignorant high horse. I don’t really understand the domestic manga scene. For all I know, people in Japan do enjoy conveyor belt sushi stories served with slightly different sauces. I’m also ignoring the reality that formulas work, and this one sells. So riding the wave might be smart, not lazy.

I get that. I do.

But still enough is enough, nothing personal against this series specifically but it just so happens to attract me on clicking because I absolutely loved the cover art.

I am crashing out. I’m the ingrate mooch getting fed the same porridge with different toppings by the feeding foundation, and now I have the audacity to complain. I want something fresh. Something meaningful. No isekai. No villainess. No “betrayed by the party and now I’m OP” revenge trip. I don’t want to be baited by the cover art again and get feed junk food.

Don’t get me started with the titles too. At this point, they might as well just write the first five dialogue lines of the manga as the title and make the whole thing a picture book.

Please, for the love of storytelling
Give me something new.

Two easy points to clear some of your doubts:

All these stories start as web novels... raw text, if you used a mysterious short title that told you nothing about the plot like "dandadan" nobody would read them, so yeah... The title is a short synopsis because of it, you can pull that in Manga but not in Japanese novels.

Regarding the repetitive subgenre, it's just an appeal to the power fantasy and escapism, meant for those who feel banished on their lives or socal circles that dream of starting over in a different world that doesn't suck, that's the appeal for both readers and writers, cause yeah... A lot of the writers of these stories are even teens that read somebody else's novel and gives them a shot, these are basically watt pad fanfics with the difference that the good ones get published and adapted to Manga and Anime.

There are a lot of "new stuff" for you every season, you don't need to complain about something very obviously not targeted to you.

 

[betetta]

Is there any further spoiler about what happened with the youtuber sister after that?

Spoiler: Here you go

youtuber sister and music composer sister left their home and are living with their bro right now, for reference they're the two youngest and the ones that weren't aggressive to him, the others are crashing down hard. Also another refreshing thing is that so far there's no incest brocon themes anywhere, we only have the regular two girls that like Mc, the sisters aren't into any romantic harem shenanigans so far.