Taida na Akujoku Kizoku ni Tensei Shita Ore, Scenario wo Bukkowa Shitara Kikaku-gai no Maryoku de Saikyou ni Natta - Ch. 15 - Paradise on the Water

[Nivek]

Did Carta get her harem ticket punched?

Seems so

Thanks for the translation, caught the raw

 

[Yaderx]

People lose fights and lose a random amount of points, it either doesnt matter or immediately gets them expelled
Theres no set rules or shown values to tie any of it together

I do agree that there is a critisism to be made about the points, but I don't think "inconsistency" is the correct term in this case. If someone point reaches 0, they get expelled, if they still have points left they don't, that's it. I do think is bad how we rarely see how much points anyone has, but again, I wouldn't call how it works inconcistency and I don't think it really matters for nameless characters like those 2 girls.

 

[Taikhi]

I like the story, but not the school system where, if your points decrease or aren’t enough during battles, you have to leave the school. I feel like the story and the school system don’t match well. In your opinion, how many students are actually inside the school building for so many of them to be expelled before even a year passes?

 

[dezzot]

The joke is already getting old. He has not once done something deserving of these savage beatings and it’s boring and a waste of panels at this point.

Brother, don’t you like Bludgeoning Angel Dokuro-chan?

Pipiru piru piru pipiru pi!

 

[timcal2136]

Literally hadn't happened since Chapter 2. This is Chapter 15. Of a monthly manga.

Went and skimmed over this manga to check if that was actually true, and it’s not. Happened in chapters 1, 2, 3, 5 (partially counts because it was technically a duel but Milk goes overboard), 14, and 15 (this chapter).

Regardless, the issue isn’t with how often it happens in the grand scheme of the story, it’s more an issue of the fact it happens damn near every time Milk is a main part of the story. Hell, even in the only times they really show Milk during MC’s time at the school before she starts guest instructing, she’s on her bullshit with randoms

 

[dcdfvr]

Wish the story showed Weiss at least putting up a decent fight against Milk. Show his progress and that this beating will end soon.

She isn't an S rank for nothing. While Weiss is stronger and better than her in terms of magic capabilities Milk-Sensei has yet to go all out in a fight

 

[amaidolce]

Must be tough to have a woman whose expression of love is Physical Violence and Torture.

 

[PraetorDragoon]

Its annoying, as I feel like I am losing interest in this series and I can't pinpoint why.

---
Thanks for the translation

 

[Bangchix22]

i want her so badd 😭 milk sensei's such a baddie.

 

[Kaarme]

The joke is already getting old. He has not once done something deserving of these savage beatings and it’s boring and a waste of panels at this point.

Milk wants Weiss to grow so strong he can beat her. That's why she's pushing him so hard and unreasonably. Either it will break him or it will give him the extra motivation (might as well call it desire for revenge) to indeed get so strong that she can't do it anymore. Her tragedy is loving fighting but being so strong there are too few opponents. The Eva Evryl girl, the strongest student, is the same. Originally she should have quit the school on her own, despite being the top ranking student, because the school offered her no challenge and got boring. But she, too, saw potential in Weiss and decided to stick around for a little longer.

At least this is how I see it. But who knows.

 

[karmsand]

Damn, I got hyped up by comments in other chapters talking about Carta big watermelons but we saw nothing

 

[orangerain7734]

Milk wants Weiss to grow so strong he can beat her. That's why she's pushing him so hard and unreasonably. Either it will break him or it will give him the extra motivation (might as well call it desire for revenge) to indeed get so strong that she can't do it anymore. Her tragedy is loving fighting but being so strong there are too few opponents. The Eva Evryl girl, the strongest student, is the same. Originally she should have quit the school on her own, despite being the top ranking student, because the school offered her no challenge and got boring. But she, too, saw potential in Weiss and decided to stick around for a little longer.

At least this is how I see it. But who knows.

So in other words, aside from Allen (the 'protagonist'), battle junkies are Weiss' biggest threats/annoyances. Legit.

 

[MrTurtleMan]

Literally hadn't happened since Chapter 2. This is Chapter 15. Of a monthly manga.

Literally happened last chapter such as in here, here, and here

yes I would say wasting 10+ panels in 29 pages of manga on the same fucking joke is over using the joke

Also it's a fortnightly manga

 

[Kampfarsch]

I do agree that there is a critisism to be made about the points, but I don't think "inconsistency" is the correct term in this case. If someone point reaches 0, they get expelled, if they still have points left they don't, that's it. I do think is bad how we rarely see how much points anyone has, but again, I wouldn't call how it works inconcistency and I don't think it really matters for nameless characters like those 2 girls.

You speak in circles, im not gonna repeat myself again figure it out yourself

 

[alto129]

it still weirds me out, how Cynthia forgive weiss from his past mistake (which is actually good and works for the story), to then be on full support of bullying the f*ck outta the hero in battle.

the in-universe logic is that every character has trope, and Cynthia is "easy" as in choroi or something

 

[phorx]

Think he deserved this one TBH.

He deserved to be hospitalized by the instructor for participating in the activities she designed and in the clothing she chose? What the hell kind of school do you go to?

 

[phorx]

Milk wants Weiss to grow so strong he can beat her. That's why she's pushing him so hard and unreasonably. Either it will break him or it will give him the extra motivation (might as well call it desire for revenge) to indeed get so strong that she can't do it anymore. Her tragedy is loving fighting but being so strong there are too few opponents. The Eva Evryl girl, the strongest student, is the same. Originally she should have quit the school on her own, despite being the top ranking student, because the school offered her no challenge and got boring. But she, too, saw potential in Weiss and decided to stick around for a little longer.

At least this is how I see it. But who knows.

Or is it just that she wants him to be strong enough to be her husband? Either way, what’s the point of putting him in the hospital? It’s not like he’s too stupid to only be able to understand her point this way. She’s just a meathead with a nice rack, but this isn’t exactly Shakespeare I guess.

 

[Skydaz]

There is a hierarchy, Weiss is at the bottom and Milk is at the very top

 

[GutsMansAss]

I don't get why people don't like the Milk joke. Personally I think it's funny that even in one of these isekai stories where the protag gets super strong and can basically smoke anyone, there's one teacher that's worlds above him. It's a good punchline, and it hasn't been repeated enough to be annoying (despite what Weiss says)

 

[Strigxx]

The joke is already getting old. He has not once done something deserving of these savage beatings and it’s boring and a waste of panels at this point.

He's the only one capable to holding against his teacher