Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2018
- Messages
- 327
For the record, I am enjoying this. The complaints I've been reading are sort of weird to me? There are legitimate storytelling critiques of this series, as there are with any story.
But Kinoko's qualities aren't really one of them?
So, in terms of actual knowledge about /anything/, she might not even have an urban child's knowledge base. It's not necessarily the case that she is dumb. While you were absorbing knowledge watching TV, Kinoko was learning how to punch 100,000 times in a sec. So, what does she know about jobs? Nothing. Chapter 1 Page 10, Panel 5. That's her knowledge level for a job. That qualifies as Negative Knowledge to me. Chapter 4 page 19, not buying an entrance ticket is a crime.
Based on compatibility, one can assume the Stranger blood, has a similar nature/scent to human blood. Even if you assume it doesn't, you have the giant bleeding Orochi Corpse just stinking up that entire arena. Are you going to notice 6 liters of human blood over the barrels of monster blood? And Kinoko has probably literally swum in their blood before. I would be surprised if she notices it at all at this point. And as I said previously in this thread. There is 0 danger for Kinoko in this situation. She's not on edge, she doesn't recognize any of this as a danger to her or anyone else.
So, Kinoko has average intelligence, negative common sense, let's say inadequate/inappropriate basic knowledge, and believes her strength isn't significantly more than anyone else. She's now in a situation where her basic knowledge is completely wrong. And she doesn't recognize/identify any of this as a danger. So in the final page, she finally acknowledges the truth. That this isn't a job. And that is a completely logical and normal conclusion for her to make.
And as far as being #1, Chapter 3, page 9, pretty much puts the kibosh on her ever admitting it. Her anxiety levels won't ever allow her to admit it to anyone.
@MostlyHumanTLs I think the Usoyama mouth gag criticism is misplaced? Page 6, she thought Kinoko is on the order of ~2 times stronger than Ippe. And she believes this Stranger Plant is a real problem. Simply yelling at Kinoko to get involved without a plan could be problematic/dangerous for both of them. But she only now realizes the danger level for Kinoko is 0. Not simply is she capable of saving the day, but that she could do it and not understand there was a day to save.
But Kinoko's qualities aren't really one of them?
As @MostlyHumanTLs pointed out, the Stranger plant absorbed that corpse. So there's unlikely much of anything left of him to detect. And as I've mentioned before, Kinoko has been living literally beyond the boondocks. As far as the reader knows, they were the only family still in Gunma.Nah man, Kino is just so fucking stupid and oblivious that it actually destroys suspension of disbelief.
It's jarring as fuck that the most powerful being in the world has the situational awareness and survival instinct of a newborn bird.
Even if she was literally blind, a man got exsanguinated in that room, and blood smells.
Based on how the writing has been for this, my hunch is that if Usoyama had in fact told Kino the truth, Kino would have willfully misinterpreted what she said just to keep this farce going.
So, in terms of actual knowledge about /anything/, she might not even have an urban child's knowledge base. It's not necessarily the case that she is dumb. While you were absorbing knowledge watching TV, Kinoko was learning how to punch 100,000 times in a sec. So, what does she know about jobs? Nothing. Chapter 1 Page 10, Panel 5. That's her knowledge level for a job. That qualifies as Negative Knowledge to me. Chapter 4 page 19, not buying an entrance ticket is a crime.
Based on compatibility, one can assume the Stranger blood, has a similar nature/scent to human blood. Even if you assume it doesn't, you have the giant bleeding Orochi Corpse just stinking up that entire arena. Are you going to notice 6 liters of human blood over the barrels of monster blood? And Kinoko has probably literally swum in their blood before. I would be surprised if she notices it at all at this point. And as I said previously in this thread. There is 0 danger for Kinoko in this situation. She's not on edge, she doesn't recognize any of this as a danger to her or anyone else.
So, Kinoko has average intelligence, negative common sense, let's say inadequate/inappropriate basic knowledge, and believes her strength isn't significantly more than anyone else. She's now in a situation where her basic knowledge is completely wrong. And she doesn't recognize/identify any of this as a danger. So in the final page, she finally acknowledges the truth. That this isn't a job. And that is a completely logical and normal conclusion for her to make.
And as far as being #1, Chapter 3, page 9, pretty much puts the kibosh on her ever admitting it. Her anxiety levels won't ever allow her to admit it to anyone.
@MostlyHumanTLs I think the Usoyama mouth gag criticism is misplaced? Page 6, she thought Kinoko is on the order of ~2 times stronger than Ippe. And she believes this Stranger Plant is a real problem. Simply yelling at Kinoko to get involved without a plan could be problematic/dangerous for both of them. But she only now realizes the danger level for Kinoko is 0. Not simply is she capable of saving the day, but that she could do it and not understand there was a day to save.
