Imasara desuga, Osananajimi o Suki ni Natteshimaimashita - Ch. 46 - Reunion Through Shine Muscat

[gmkgoat]

No Yami? Yawn. Call me when peak returns

 

[STBB]

Ain't no way we're moving on this fast like nothings happened, da hell

 

[Desertking1]

Agreed. but that's NOT what you claimed. You claimed Yuu did NOTHING wrong. No matter which character in this series people support, this is the sort of claim that's just plain stupid regardless of which character it's about.

And I'm absolutely right. He did nothing wrong. Don't give a shit what you think.

 

[Saybah]

I mean, that's the core idea: that aside from the emo and self-destructive ramblings of Yami and her mother, it's all been a pretty typical teenage drama, even if, like the prudes we are, both we here in the West and the Japanese there, are horrified by the idea of a teenage girl having sex in love hotels with her teenage boyfriend, because that's the only truly "serious" thing that's happened in this whole mess (and what probably led to publishers rejecting the author's project, forcing him to go independent).
Ironically, even Shikimori-san was more really dramatic considering that Kamiya the blue-haired girl (on whom the author based Yami) at least wanted do a real NTR/infidelity arc with her coming between two people who were a happy couple, even if they were just a sweaty hands couple.
PS. For the interested ones, here the planned full chapter 45 who Maruto had to discarded because "it was too explicit for X/Twitter", and it was released in Winter Comiket in December 31th as chapter 45.5: https://mangadex.org/chapter/8042014a-52ad-4237-af61-4ee6386f0860
So, the hiatus has been really from two months, not three. Even if many from you will think this Yami chapter didn´t add much to the story beyond other trip for her remorses and suicidal pulsions.

Yes, I think intended as message for teenagers to not go dramatic or impulsive to the point of suicide. Here Yami think she ruined their both relationship permanently when in reality they both can get back again just fine.

 

[GennArc]

Ok, so went back and looked and that was about dinner. Some indeterminate amount of time ago.

It did show during the family dinner, but obviously the reason for her mood brightening up was Yuu's message about Haru and Yuki.

I don't think it skips anything particularly important.

When something that affects the plot progression happens, I consider it important. Maybe she would've brightened up without that message or maybe she wouldn't have, the important thing is that it did happen and there was a cause for it.
If it was shown in the manga, comments like

i dont even know whats happening anymore

would be less likely to show up.

Meh, it's supposed to be probably full sized going by the pillows/headboard. And also imperfect and hazy cause this is a fantasy.

It being a fantasy isn't a reason for wrong proportions, that's clearly just badly drawn. Just look at the width vs height.

Spoiler

 

[Soliquidsnake]

Readers now a days have no patience. See one fucking chapter and take everything at face value instead of thinking it's building up to something. iPad kids, man...

 

[RezaKingA]

14 FUCKING PAGES AGAIN... GET THIS LAZY BUM OUT OF MY FACE... THIS AUTHOR PMO SO MUCH... 2 MONTHS FOR THIS???

 

[Nuggz]

I'm hoping for the same result because I believe Yuu deserves better. Or at least have Yuu friendzone Hikari for a few years so she learns what it feels like.

This is never happening cuz it was never the idea. She was never gonna break off things with Yuu. Now the only way I can see this happening is they both run into Yami, Yuu sees her in such a shit state and decides it's her over Hikari, which would basically force a permanent break off

 

[story645]

Just look at the width vs height.

The bed ends against the window. Like it's not pitch perfect sure, but my guess it's supposed to be approx 3pt perspective - give or take that the angled lines may need to be more or less sloped but I was basing roughly on the lines I was seeing. ETA?: 3pt w/ these lines centers on Yuu, particularly his face, which makes sense for Aya's headspace.

Spoiler

but obviously the reason for her mood brightening up was Yuu's message about Haru and Yuki.

But that's not necessarily the reason why an indeterminate amount of time later she concedes to her parents make up scheme. If it is, then we will likely find out b/c Maruto tends to repeat stuff like that.

ETA: hell Maruto's tweet indicates that his plan wasn't for Hikari to just make up w/ Yuu but her characterization wouldn't let him. That to me reads as she would have arrived here even w/o Yuu's text.

comments like

i dont even know whats happening anymore

would be less likely to show up.

I think most of those folks aren't being all that serious.

 

[story645]

Yuu sees her in such a shit state and decides it's her over Hikari, which would basically force a permanent break off

Meh, Hikari might be fine with that, might even encourage it honestly. It fits w/ her saving everyone, Hikari still loves and worries for Aya, and it gives Hikari an easy out where she gets to be all benovelont w/o having to work out if she wants to date Yuu after everything.

ETA: Also fits with Hikari saying she'd choose Aya over a romantic ship w/ Yuu back when she first met Aya. Which Maruto may have Hikari wait on resolving the situation w/ Aya before deciding on moving forward romantically w/ Yuu for that reason, given Hikari knows Aya is still in love with Yuu.

 

[silentkill]

chat, I'm scared to read ts, should i read this, chat?

 

[peortega1]

But that's the thing, I don't think it skips anything particularly important

Even if Hikari was going to act the same way anyway, it's still important because it shows Yuu as someone who is capable of taking action and making decisions, and who genuinely cares about Hikari. But of course, "it's not particularly important" if it ruins your agenda, and that of many others, of badmouthing Yuu

It gives Hikari an easy out where she gets to be all benovelont w/o having to work out if she wants to date Yuu after everything.

So, Hikari chooses the coward option, again.

Which Maruto may have Hikari wait on resolving the situation w/ Aya before deciding on moving forward romantically w/ Yuu

This would be more respectable from Hikari´s side, postponing the romantic resolution until a point where Yuu will be able to choose cleanly between Aya and her. And is in this point where the idea of polygamy will go to surface.

Hikari being forgiving doesn't mean she's fine. That's why she's still after the truth even now. And why she's willing to reconcile with him, b/c that's part of her reset to "fine".

It's obvious that Yuu is preparing to tell her the same things he already told Haru. Just like her, you and several other readers don't know about foreplay. It would be stupid of Yuu not to tell Hikari now what he was able to tell Haru, a complete stranger for him, who, to top it all off, will tell Hikari as soon as she asks about it. For Yuu to still try to hide from Hikari what he even told Haru would be too stupid, even for him.
Anyway, Yuu clearly defines what he means by "being okay" on page 8, when he tells Hikari that he's amazed she can talk "normally" with him even after everything that happened.
He's not denying that Hikari isn't hurt; he's saying that Hikari, despite everything, is moving forward instead of sinking into depression like he did after Yami ghosted him, not to mention Yami herself flirting with suicide. The fact that Hikari not only continues with her normal life but also DOESN'T ASK ANYONE FOR HELP proves Yuu is right about that.
If Hikari truly felt she was in trouble, she would directly ask for help from the people she knows love her and can help her.

ETA: legit a not insignificant chunk of Yuu's girl problems is the stereotype of girls saying they're fine when they're not and Yuu taking em at face value.

Your argument would be less hypocritical if it weren't for the fact that this is exactly what Hikari has done throughout the entire series, both with Yami and with Yuu himself, at least since they started high school at different schools. Hikari knew perfectly well that Yuu wasn't fine during the events of chapters 36-38; she clearly heard Yami slap him, she knew perfectly well that it wasn't a happy couple reunion, and yet she dismissed him when he insisted (and lied) he was fine.
That's the thing about Hikari: she'll always think of herself first, and then maybe others. She'll never sacrifice herself for others, and I'm not the one saying that, she said it herself.
Is not any surprise why selfish women like you are Hikari's biggest fangirls.

 

[peortega1]

It fits w/ her saving everyone,

Hikari never saved nobody, except maybe Yuu in their childhood. Nobody more.

I think most of those folks aren't being all that serious.

Between this and you calling by nicknames to the people when you talk about them with third ones, yes, you definitely are so naive childish as Hikari.
Is obvious all those folks are seriously throwing shit to Yuu!

 

[NoAddedWater]

Fluff shounen romcom slop addicts crying in comments will never NOT be funny.

Like, drama when it’s obviously just to forward the plot is bad. This manga has well written drama with a tragic heroine that makes you question your sympathy for her. Surely does not deserve all the one star ratings it has.

 

[GennArc]

The bed ends against the window.

Yeah, and the window is in the wall, and the distance from the bed leg closest to the viewer to the wall is so ridiculously small that it makes the bed look like it's 200 cm l x 20 cm w x 80 cm h (sorry, I can't deal with ft.)

ETA: hell Maruto's tweet indicates that his plan wasn't for Hikari to just make up w/ Yuu but her characterization wouldn't let him. That to me reads as she would have arrived here even w/o Yuu's text.

That's what I said, like, she could've arrived at that point without Yuu's text, but the novel shows that it did brighten her mood up, it did make her going to Yuu's house much easier etc. And who knows, maybe without that text she would still be angry.

 

[story645]

and the window is in the wall

Isn't that where windows are supposed to be?

and the distance from the bed leg closest to the viewer to the wall is so ridiculously small

Aya is explicitly fantasizing about a closet sized apartment. I once lived in a studio that was a converted front parlor so shrugs some spaces come in very small.

but the novel shows that it did brighten her mood up, it did make her going to Yuu's house much easier etc.

It shows it brightened her mood at dinner. There's no nod to the text here when she's thinking of why she's showing up at Yuu's - even w/o it, Hikari's "just come on, Yuu" indicates she's open to what he has to say.

It would have been trivial for Yom to include Hikari seeing the text as the last panel of 44 and my guess is Yom and Maruto have some sort of agreement on what can't be cut.

 

[story645]

Is obvious all those folks are seriously throwing shit to Yuu!

By saying they're not following what's happening in the manga?

Sorry for shortening your name to port, will use your full username from now on.

Is not any surprise why selfish women like you are Hikari's biggest fangirls

That's a whole lotta projection given you don't know me in real life. Like how does my opinion of a fictional character even matter?

 

[GennArc]

Aya is explicitly fantasizing about a closet sized apartment.

It's not about the size of the room, it's about the size of the bed.

It shows it brightened her mood at dinner.

After a week of being constantly in a bad mood, and seeing her like this made her parents feel relieved.

and my guess is Yom and Maruto have some sort of agreement on what can't be cut.

I have no doubts that Yom doesn't just cut content voluntarily. But I think their agreements might also be a product of some compromises, in a "I can't finish a few pages this week, so we either postpone the chapter or release it like this".

 

[Genzerum]

A whole mini hiatus later and we still only dropping 14 pages lmao. Yet again Hikari being leveraged as the one to do things, yet again no context.

Side note: how the fuck did the manga adaptation screw up this chapter so badly, even the novel chapter still kept its tense feeling and had more details.

I'd say Yom doesn't give a f anymore :v

 

[iamsean]

I'd say Yom doesn't give a f anymore :v

Honestly would not be surprised. Monthly releases fell off hard