Mii-chan to Yamada-san - Vol. 7 Ch. 37.5 - Until We Meet Again

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 12, 2019
Messages
190
Just like the person above said, I also now understand why people didn't like the anime announcement. Because, yes, I can see some people will be sympathetic, but some will also see that they can take advantage of people with disabilities.

It's so sad that Yamada and Mii-chan indirectly killed each other. Yamada by telling her to go back to her hometown and making her meet bad people, and Mii-chan by haunting Yamada so that she couldn't have any other thoughts beside drawing. I wonder if it would be better if they never met. I hope they captured the real killers.

I also wonder why the grandma could produce two children with disabilities, though. If only she stopped thinking about what other people would think and agree with the teacher.
For the grandma, likely is narcissism and pride.

Pride in constantly concluding that her thoughts are correct. Evident when she divorced her husband when divorce was still a scandalous thing at the time, and she never found the hypocrisy in it, compared to how she felt shame for having disabled family and did nothing to resolve it, pridefully thinking that not saying or doing anything is better.

Narcissism in denial of the reality in front of her, thinking that everything is fine just by keeping things quiet and not doing anything and just sitting in her own bubble, hoping the problem will pass.

Evident when Mii-chan told them they could come to the farmer potluck, which was a good chance to meet the townsfolk and interact with them, which she herself rejected, reflecting how she preferred to stay in her bubble and do nothing about the problems around here, not even trying to integrate and get the townsfolks to accept her family and sought help from them. Adding on to when Mii-chan told her grandma that all the nearby stores and shops banned Mii-chan and her mum from even entry due to their troublemaking nature and reputation. This should have made anyone, even her, realise that as much as you try to hide or ignore the problem, people will still know about it when it is obvious enough, especially when you pretty much left your elementary school aged grandchild to fend for herself, not ensuring that she is in school and wandering off in town, letting her rummage through trash for food, and terrorising kindergarteners.

Also genetic, with how she could birth two children with disabilities.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 12, 2019
Messages
190
at least mii's childhood friend turned out fine
Yeah, at least she has a mom that loves her, and she seems to be integrating into the community properly thanks to her mum putting in the effort to make her look and behave respectably.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 6, 2019
Messages
131
The manga is an interesting contradiction.

It's unflinching in depicting how intellectually disabled people can fall through the cracks and get exploited (i.e no support systems, challenging behaviours which isolate them from others, lack of intervention and no one desiring to intervene) . The intellectually disabled are also human, but we grow frustrated if they behave like anything other than an angel.

The mangaka's contempt for disabled people and guilt for feeling contemptuous towards intellectually disabled people is also obvious. I think this struggle is what contributes to the misery porn feeling. They feel guilty for feeling the same way as all the people who exploit Mii-chan feel but they rush to justify why they shouldn't feel guilty.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Oct 17, 2023
Messages
38
The manga is an interesting contradiction.

It's unflinching in depicting how intellectually disabled people can fall through the cracks and get exploited (i.e no support systems, challenging behaviours which isolate them from others, lack of intervention and no one desiring to intervene) . The intellectually disabled are also human, but we grow frustrated if they behave like anything other than an angel.

The mangaka's contempt for disabled people and guilt for feeling contemptuous towards intellectually disabled people is also obvious. I think this struggle is what contributes to the misery porn feeling. They feel guilty for feeling the same way as all the people who exploit Mii-chan feel but they rush to justify why they shouldn't feel guilty.
this is an interesting way to put it, thank you. I was struggling to word it myself...

there's definitely this.. odd feeling to everything. all throughout, like, never really acknowledging how Yamada just quietly sits by and watches Mao abuse Mii-chan, for example.. she seems concerned about her, but she doesn't appear scared or angry at how he's treating her, nor does she try to intervene, just watching and going "isn't that a bit much..?" as he's blasting her in the face with insecticide and hitting her. yet she simultaneously confronts him occasionally, like with the whole "I'm telling her to call the police next time you hit her" thing. There's this.. sort of bizarre contrast going on that makes it hard to place how we're supposed to feel, I guess.

It does feel kind of like a work the author made to work through their own personal ordeals than a "narrative," which makes me feel kind of odd reading it. Almost voyeuristic, I guess.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top