Hachinan tte, Sore wa Nai deshou! - Ch. 115 - The Royal Court's Proposed Ruling and the Envoy's Cross-Examination

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 15, 2024
Messages
526
If the representative has had no authority to negotiate, why has he even been humored at all so far. its nice to see him get humbled a bit but the fact this ever reached a negotiation table without someone with any sort of authority at all is silly if youre going to just admit that "oh yeah, even if you for sign anything its not valid". Draining resources from both sides by the day for no reason, i could see why the losing side would want to do it, cant see why the winning side would humor this when they could fully just continue to easily subdue any resistance until an actual representative would appear.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 20, 2025
Messages
11,148
This manga is starting to feel like the recent seasons of the Tensei Shitara Slime Datta Ken anime, just endless meetings after meetings :aquadrink:

tom-and-jerry-bedtime.gif


thank you for translation
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 19, 2020
Messages
1,102
Such is nobility, or politics in general, the fools would rather find a way to scheme and get a leg up on the competition than fix their own shit.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 18, 2018
Messages
493
If the representative has had no authority to negotiate, why has he even been humored at all so far. its nice to see him get humbled a bit but the fact this ever reached a negotiation table without someone with any sort of authority at all is silly if youre going to just admit that "oh yeah, even if you for sign anything its not valid". Draining resources from both sides by the day for no reason, i could see why the losing side would want to do it, cant see why the winning side would humor this when they could fully just continue to easily subdue any resistance until an actual representative would appear.
Yes, i was wondering about this ever since that whole thing started.

What do you mean you have no authority, but still sitting at negotiation table? Just tell to that bloke to leave premises immediately, and sue Blois for the "contempt of court" for such disregard of authority of kingdom.

It's not my favorite, but I still generally enjoy political machinations bits in manga from time to time. But that situation makes no sense whatsoever, and the fact that this arc is so long makes it even worse.
 
Contributor
Joined
Feb 4, 2019
Messages
9,908
If the representative has had no authority to negotiate, why has he even been humored at all so far. its nice to see him get humbled a bit but the fact this ever reached a negotiation table without someone with any sort of authority at all is silly if you're going to just admit that "oh yeah, even if you for sign anything its not valid". Draining resources from both sides by the day for no reason, i could see why the losing side would want to do it, cant see why the winning side would humor this when they could fully just continue to easily subdue any resistance until an actual representative would appear.

They didn't have proof until just now, when the Royal representative demanded it. Now that they've confirmed that the country basically started a war without approval and customary notification to the opposing side, the Royal family could strip the Margrave of his title due to he inability to control his own men and/or his indecisiveness to select a successor.

The Royal family are also justified in ordering the death of all the retainers as they've basically admitted to committing a rebellion using the two powerless sons as figureheads. The representative knows he fucked up badly on all fronts, and will be less likely to fight back on the negotiations now.
 
Supporter
Joined
Apr 1, 2023
Messages
337
How was this not brought up day 1?! How did it take so long?
It actually WAS brought up on Day 1.
Chapter 113, they even bring up the fact that Godwin has no real authority because he's just an "Acting" Commander, and the suggestion of having Carla be the representative of House Blois was brought up but shot down because a woman doesn't have that kind of authority (to which MC responded "better an actual daughter than a SQUIRE").
And yes, MC did ask if there's any point to such negotiations, and the Margrave admitted that the negotiations are pointless but they must be done.

In fact, since the Margrave said that, and then an official Envoy from the Royal Court came in a few days, I think the Margrave had been banking on the Royal Court sending the Envoy. Because as the MC noted, a truly neutral negotiator from the Royal Court would give the Margrave and MC side good terms because they are the wronged side (victim of a surprise attack), going along with the Royal Court's decision would earn them brownie points with the King, and on top of that, the Envoy would have the authority to demand a proper representative from the Blois side and explanation for why they've been fucking around with some Chief Squire instead of a direct member of House Blois (Carla).
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 4, 2023
Messages
429
This manga is starting to feel like the recent seasons of the Tensei Shitara Slime Datta Ken anime, just endless meetings after meetings :aquadrink:

tom-and-jerry-bedtime.gif


thank you for translation
Tensura is isekai civ development and politics with sprinkle of battle actually. Battle is just a conflict in building a kingdom.

this manga is isekai harem adventure with sprinkle of development and politics.

i don't know why people crying about too many meeting in Tensura because in essence, it is isekai development like ascendance of bookworm. both myne and rimuru wanted to build a place where they can enjoy what they want from previous life.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 7, 2019
Messages
12,405
It actually WAS brought up on Day 1.
Chapter 113, they even bring up the fact that Godwin has no real authority because he's just an "Acting" Commander, and the suggestion of having Carla be the representative of House Blois was brought up but shot down because a woman doesn't have that kind of authority (to which MC responded "better an actual daughter than a SQUIRE").
And yes, MC did ask if there's any point to such negotiations, and the Margrave admitted that the negotiations are pointless but they must be done.

In fact, since the Margrave said that, and then an official Envoy from the Royal Court came in a few days, I think the Margrave had been banking on the Royal Court sending the Envoy. Because as the MC noted, a truly neutral negotiator from the Royal Court would give the Margrave and MC side good terms because they are the wronged side (victim of a surprise attack), going along with the Royal Court's decision would earn them brownie points with the King, and on top of that, the Envoy would have the authority to demand a proper representative from the Blois side and explanation for why they've been fucking around with some Chief Squire instead of a direct member of House Blois (Carla).
Well, true. Poor choice of words, or really, thoughts on that matter from my side. However, why continue the negotiation in that case? In my mind MC's side could threaten to continue the fighting if the losing side doesn't bring in someone with real authority. Which they kinda did, but not quite. They even called out how it's a complete waste of time several times. And there was also no concerns about just refusing negotiations under these conditions. If I didn't miss anything from a quick scim through, that is.
So I just don't see why the author wanted MC's side to even humor this absurd situation.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 2, 2018
Messages
14,606
Tensura is isekai civ development and politics with sprinkle of battle actually. Battle is just a conflict in building a kingdom.

this manga is isekai harem adventure with sprinkle of development and politics.

i don't know why people crying about too many meeting in Tensura because in essence, it is isekai development like ascendance of bookworm. both myne and rimuru wanted to build a place where they can enjoy what they want from previous life.
IMO ppl got used to the more common isekai adventurer stories, and are therefore completely caught off guard when an isekai development story with some action pops in because they’re expecting Rimuru to be more in the field than in the meeting room, as per the earlier bits of tensura when Rimuru hasn’t become a legit demon lord yet.
It actually WAS brought up on Day 1.
Chapter 113, they even bring up the fact that Godwin has no real authority because he's just an "Acting" Commander, and the suggestion of having Carla be the representative of House Blois was brought up but shot down because a woman doesn't have that kind of authority (to which MC responded "better an actual daughter than a SQUIRE").
And yes, MC did ask if there's any point to such negotiations, and the Margrave admitted that the negotiations are pointless but they must be done.

In fact, since the Margrave said that, and then an official Envoy from the Royal Court came in a few days, I think the Margrave had been banking on the Royal Court sending the Envoy. Because as the MC noted, a truly neutral negotiator from the Royal Court would give the Margrave and MC side good terms because they are the wronged side (victim of a surprise attack), going along with the Royal Court's decision would earn them brownie points with the King, and on top of that, the Envoy would have the authority to demand a proper representative from the Blois side and explanation for why they've been fucking around with some Chief Squire instead of a direct member of House Blois (Carla).
it does nail it home, doesn’t it, when the neutral arbitration 3rd party is also saying what a dumb cunt you’ve been by stretching out the negotiations without proper authorization, at your own expense since now the ransom cost from losing the war will now be jacked up by basically interest.
 
Supporter
Joined
Apr 1, 2023
Messages
337
Well, true. Poor choice of words, or really, thoughts on that matter from my side. However, why continue the negotiation in that case? In my mind MC's side could threaten to continue the fighting if the losing side doesn't bring in someone with real authority. Which they kinda did, but not quite. They even called out how it's a complete waste of time several times. And there was also no concerns about just refusing negotiations under these conditions. If I didn't miss anything from a quick scim through, that is.
So I just don't see why the author wanted MC's side to even humor this absurd situation.
Why continue?
Like I said, Margrave Breithilde wanted to continue the negotiations until the Royal Court's Envoy puts forward the Royal Court's proposal, which the MC noted will be in Breithilde's favor because they are the aggrieved party AND they hold the military advantage. On top of that, the longer things go, the higher the ransom has to be paid to Breithilde.

The Margrave did tell the MC that they can't just refuse negotiations, no matter if they're pointless.
Most likely because agreeing to negotiate and spending at least several days attempting to come to a compromise is something that is expected of proper nobles, instead of immediately resorting to military force and violence like some uncultured barbarian.
Just as there are traditions that nobles are expected to follow, such as to issue a declaration of war first before attacking, and to not instigate an insurrection in a neighbor's lands, things the Margrave Blois side ignored.

There is every reason to drag out the negotiations until the Royal Court puts forward their proposal, because the Margrave is sure to get a good deal from the Royal Court's proposal, get a higher ransom, score points with the King, and look like a principled and reasonable negotiator to other nobles because he did accept a lower settlement once it was offered by a neutral party.

Considering what the MC was thinking (that this entire negotiation was tiresome and pointless), Godwin probably wanted him to restart the fight, so that he can complain to the Royal Court that the Blois side was being reasonable to negotiate but it was Margrave Breithilde's side who broke off negotiations unilaterally.
But that fell apart because the Envoy was asked for the Royal Court's proposed settlement.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 15, 2019
Messages
3,954
I'm still of the opinion that Wend should have just popped over the the main house, or the brothers little hidiholes, subdued any resistance, captured both brothers, and deposited them onto the negotiation tent floor.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 27, 2023
Messages
1,275
Thank you for the translation!

Finally an authority that can kick the talks in to gear. Or dismantle them all together.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Messages
1,340
bruh we're all getting PTSD from this talk-no-jutsu
Talk no Jutsu is pointless talking in the middle of a battle.
This is actual negoiations that take place after the battle has concluded and one side hasn't completely conquered the other.

If you're getting PTSD it's because you're thinking on the level of a foot soldier being dragged into the meetings after the fighting bits are done. This is usually reserved for those who can think on a commander level or higher. It's the part of war that usually gets left out because it's not glamourous.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
948
This manga is starting to feel like the recent seasons of the Tensei Shitara Slime Datta Ken anime, just endless meetings after meetings :aquadrink:

tom-and-jerry-bedtime.gif


thank you for translation
We are starting to get the manager experience
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top