It had a 0% chance of success but just think of the fallout if Sirius had been killed here - You piss off the Elves, some of the strongest Warriors in the world who respect and/or have learned from him, multiple Royal Families that he has helped, not to mention Hokuto would go absolutely apeshit. And all this over him being selected as Mary's tutor(which I'm sure will be revealed was an opportunity they were gonna use to poison her again).