Old Man was harsh but right, some people are scumbags who well anyone who read Goblin Slayer remembers "Goblin Lord" Right?
The Goblin who ONLY got to Lord status largely cause he TOOK ADVANTAGE OF KOWTOWING and low life tactics to get ahead (even had a Flame Sword because a foolish adventurer FELL) basically a full representative of WHY Goblin Slayer shut down ALL of Priestess attempts when they first met to "spare the baby goblins" so when he met his end by her doing EXACTLY WHAT HE DOES BEST. It shows how far Priestess has grown, the old her had she survived and NOT mentored under Goblin Slayer WOULD have likely been "just like the REST of his past victims"
When you spare these types, you're partially responsible for ANYTHING they do in the future! If they do better fine, but the odds of that are VERY LOW, and it's usually sometimes EASY TO TELL WHO IS UNREPENTANT AND WILL JUST GO BACK TO THEIR EVIL WAYS (Not always though) just by watching their actions prior (ESPECIALLY do NOT spare fools who were doing vile shit and laughing about it, their QUICKNESS to beg for mercy is obvious they want you to spare them, and they'll go RIGHT BACK, You saw the scumbag MC cut down as he moved to stab him to "scare him" the man was scum of the highest order, a bottom feeder that goes for the Weak......which makes it ALWAYS FUN as shown when MC took his arm when they discover the Weak, aren't so weak after all and it's too late to beg for their lives LOL) sometimes their not that GOOD at lying either if their desperate to get mercy. They just need to FAKE IT and hope you're a bleeding heart (this is a case where that insult DOES have MEAT TO IT) to fall for it.
They will not change, they will not grow, and it WILL be your fault they harmed someone who WASN'T you in the future (that is "not able to fight them off or worse COULD but their "experience" with you made them MORE cautious and sneaky then if they HADN'T met and been spared by you where their NEW VICTIM might have been able to get them, and unlike past you, WASN'T foolish to spare them!) People really need to get not every criminal is some desperate down on their luck individual who is trying to survive. Odds are low of them being THAT and more likely just scumbag doing it because they CAN and "Like" horribly torturing, hurting or WORSE (in the case of women need I say any more) and cause they CAN!
As what happened in the Carriage, the scum made it CLEAR they are the type to NEVER LEARN, get WORSE and have no remorse, good he killed the POS before he wasted everyone's patience trying to cry and beg for his life hoping ANOTHER sucker will let him continue being a plague! This time he met the WRONG DOG and got his throat ripped out and the world is 0.1 better with him gone! Especially knowing what he and the rest of his group have done and were planning on continuing to do (An example must be made so copy cats or well POTENTIAL copy cats will get a NASTY surprise that "this will be your FATE if you play stupid games like this again, these assholes survived long and had many victims because they got LUCKY, but that luck at the expense of their victims FINALLY ran out and they were NOT FANS of the retribution they so rightfully deserved!