Jitsu wa Imouto deshita. ~Saikin Dekita Giri no Otouto no Kyorikan ga Yatara Chikai Wake~ - Vol. 10 Ch. 49

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 5, 2024
Messages
152
I still wish they got punished somehow
Whether they "meant to" be or not, they were abusers. And what abusers want more than anything is control.

If he forgave them, he'd be allowing them to live with what they did. The greatest revenge he could give is to walk away. In fact, now they need to live their lives both regretting the son they abandoned, and knowing he's the only reason their daughter is alive today.

He's removed their control over him. They now they can only live with what they've done.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Feb 20, 2026
Messages
26
We have a term for things like this: Unreliable Narrator. We only had the few viewpoints of the people we've had all this time with no interactions or views from the mom's side. Primarily it's been from a person's memories of a traumatic moment as a child. It's not a retcon because things the character, and us the readers, didn't know is revealed later. We could also just call it Situational Irony if you don't want to agree to UN.

If I've misunderstood your point, then I apologize.
I understand your point, but an unreliable narrator only works if either things are clarified later on, or if you're given another perspective that contradicts the previous narrator. In this case, the clarifications makes far less sense than the MC's original interpretation. It's not like we're just getting his parents' side, and it can be taken with a grain of salt: it's being treated as irrefutable fact. The MC is just expected to take what they say at face value.

I get that the MC was a child, but all of these developments trying to paint his parents in a more positive light, as well as the reveal that Akira's dad was actually the one to meet him at a deserted playground and give him his MO to live by just seem incredibly contrived.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 13, 2023
Messages
120
I kind of hate this. Like, who the fuck would say no to helping a little girl that calls you her big brother (regardless of her actually being his sister on top of it) just because you have a grudge against her parents???
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Mar 20, 2018
Messages
30
At first I thought they were heading toward something semi-defensible, like she lied because they weren't going to be financially stable and it would be better for him to stay with his dad. But no, just straight up cowardly trash. :facepalm:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
271
Disagree with the Husband, hes been written to be way too sympathetic to the point that hes just a nothing burger asshole. If he was just straight up uncaring about anything besides his daughter, i would have liked him more and he would have been more realistic. The wife being regretful is fine but shes still an evil bitch that is portrayed as way too sympathetic, none of these two are relatable to me because I would never do anything like what they did so trying to play that angle just makes them even worse and more unlikable if instead they were written as cold but honest.
Totally evil or good characters are just quirky, this is more realistic and that is why I think that they can be more relatable. But don't get me wrong, I dislike them, I think they are assholes and I never would do something like that.

Average people can do crazy things.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
1,087
Totally evil or good characters are just quirky, this is more realistic and that is why I think that they can be more relatable. But don't get me wrong, I dislike them, I think they are assholes and I never would do something like that.

Average people can do crazy things.
its not "totally evil" to be uncaring for a love child who you have no relationship with. The realistic version of him would be someone whose trying desperately to save his daughter but not having any actual emotional attachment to his "son" than the fact he is able to save his daughter who he actually love, like I’m not saying he would want to actively harm him or hate him but he would see him as a cure for his daughter but besides that a stranger.
If anything portraying him as someone who actually does care is so unrealistic he becomes unrelatable. The whore wife I can understand, she gave birth to him and didn't keep him because he didn't want her so her having lingering attachment makes sense.
 
Joined
Nov 17, 2026
Messages
1
Absolute peak chapter! Love it when a Manga properly incorporates meaningful family dynamics, especially making the parents central to the plot. Half of the time when I watch Anime, the question is always: "Where the fuck are the parents? Where are the adults?".

On a more controversial note, I find the current discussion here to be quite polarized; many people absolutely hate the bio parents and would love to see MC to get "revange". I think a lot of nuances are lost when the focus is solely on the (despicable) fact that MC was abandoned.

I'm sure we all read the same chapter, but this is how I interpret the following points:

* Bio mum had a shaky period in her relationship with Taichi the non-bio dad, so she slipped up once and had an affair. Still, absolutely despicable.

* Bio mum did not have confidence that child MC would prefer to follow her after the divorce since she was the unfaithful one. She didn't deserve him. The shame that she felt made her withdraw from MC's life. Self-pity and self-sabotage is very real in depressed people, they might truly think that they no longer deserve happiness in life. Still, at the end of the day, it was a true coward move, and it really fucked up MC growing up.

* Bio mum never stopped watching over and cheering for MC from the shadows as shown in the basketball game. This really messed up MC because he thought that he was abandoned. That fueled his hate growing up, and to discover a contradiction would mean that he had the wrong idea about the situation. For the longest time, he decided to turn a blind eye to it. "After all, there is no way that his mum always kept on caring about him after all the pain she has inflicted on him, right?". But in this latest chapter, he acknowledges that his bio mum still cares about him despite all the harm she has done to him. This has been a major roadblock that he has been having difficulties accepting. But now, he finally accepts the "apparent contradiction" and moves on. Yes, your mum abandoned you. Also yes, your mum still loves you. Crazy, I know.

* Bio dad is a home wrecker that ruined a family by participating in the affair. Upon learning that MC is his bio son, it makes sense that he would love to connect with MC. But bio dad was literally half of the reason MC's family was ruined. What right does he even have to step into child MC's life after so many years? He too must have felt too ashamed to "claim back" his bio son. He knows that he doesn't deserve it. Realistically speaking, what else could he have done except for staying out of MC's life?

Due to all of these points above, I think the author is able to plant a seed of doubt in the readers. Maybe it's not as black and white as we initially thought after all. Bio mum and bio dad made some really bad choices. No one can nor will forgive them, but at least the author makes a good job of painting up the full picture and circumstances that lead to a series of poor choices and mistakes, that culminated into a rather sad outcome.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top