It would have been interesting if they had it so that the MC was still a self absorbed A-hole villainous character, who just so happens to try to do the right thing, while Cain could be a goody two-shoes who keeps screwing up so significantly with his 'good-boy' behaviour that it's significantly detrimental to everyone.
With the story playing out like this, what point was there in not having the original story play out as it would have? All the characters and scenarios are essentially the same, just that we have the MC going
'b-b-but Cain was supposed to be the good guy here!?'