MangaDex Forums

Mangamoz
Mangamoz
@Litreara The monkey's pawl curls.
They all end up being political comments of whichever politician people were told to hate by the news that week.
panzerkampfwagyu
panzerkampfwagyu
I mean, it is rather likely that it either keeps getting ignored, as the "long testing, but you can't touch it" period likely will have trained a lot of users to ignore it, but also, historically, removing friction mostly leads to low-effort getting through a lot more.
Personally I don't think I will use it much, despite having access.
The unnecessary downgrades and expected low quality of posts on there kinda make it less interesting.
panzerkampfwagyu
panzerkampfwagyu
Not to mention that the Feed will have a terrible discoverability if it's open and well-used. Posts will just be swept away, instead of slowly appearing on the feed like in the forum
BakedBanana
BakedBanana
@panzerkampfwagyu
The chances of me using it is very low. It's just a watered-down profile post with even more downsides (lower character count, circle pfps, feels like Twitter, etc). Not to mention how we already have seen an old feature that's been available since V3 is now locked behind supporter (ie having pfps that are gifs), no thanks.
panzerkampfwagyu
panzerkampfwagyu
Yeah, it fails the "If you add something new, it should be better than what it replaces" test.
Which is extra stupid, because there are so many things that could be improved from Xenforo(Bad GIF Support, character limits, shit compatibility with main site, etc) and given as premium bonuses, yet they went the route of giving a worse product out.
Mangamoz
Mangamoz
gimme_yuri_plz
gimme_yuri_plz
It's all to keep people on the main site, where the ads are.
@Mangamoz I never thought about that! I guess there's no such thing as a free lunch :fml:
panzerkampfwagyu
panzerkampfwagyu
If they have any, lol.
How long is the banner an ad to please use their advertisement services?
They are still free to change their mind on this old suggestion, btw, which has some statements that seem quite interesting in hindsight
Mangamoz
Mangamoz
@panzerkampfwagyu Most of your recommendations to help the site end up as [REJECTED] , have they ever listened to any of your tips?
panzerkampfwagyu
panzerkampfwagyu
Only 3 of them did, the rest mostly got ignored, I do know in one case that it is worked on
BakedBanana
BakedBanana
To add onto my original post (since I forgot + character count), I just want to point out that I'm not disavowing supporter-only features. I just don't appreciate that they are turning features that were originally free for everyone, into stuff that's exclusive to supporters.
panzerkampfwagyu
panzerkampfwagyu
I personally wonder why they haven't ever tried doing stuff like merch sales of Mangadex original content (Index, Dex-Chan, Fed-Kun)?
Would likely be quite profitable and be less "Make money from stuff that isn't ours".
Other things would be to let supporters feature Mangas directly on the home page, yes, that involves being able to flashbang with the magical manga.
BakedBanana
BakedBanana
I personally wonder why they haven't ever tried doing stuff like merch sales of Mangadex original content (Index, Dex-Chan, Fed-Kun)?
@panzerkampfwagyu
They have. They even had a store in V3, but it was later removed sometime in early V5.
u3uzjijfavj91.jpg
6ch8vq.jpeg
Angry_Panda
Angry_Panda
@panzerkampfwagyu - they actually do let supporters make suggestions for the 'Recommended' list with some regularity (though that hasn't been getting rotated out as often recently).
BakedBanana
BakedBanana
Here's a screenshot of MangaDex in 2022 (when everything was still down except the reader). Look at the bottom left, you can see the merch store.
Iw6FeI8.png
Robinisback
Robinisback
Oh yeah, they removed it somewhere around 2023. Probably didn't make enough money to print more.
panzerkampfwagyu
panzerkampfwagyu
@Angry_Panda I know about that one, it was in the contrib chat and I even suggested like 12 titles there. Was thinking more like the april fools ads, that's a feature I don't think people would mind.
@BakedBanana So they already had that, huh. Probs also could've sold digital content or so.
BakedBanana
BakedBanana
@panzerkampfwagyu - they actually do let supporters make suggestions for the 'Recommended' list with some regularity (though that hasn't been getting rotated out as often recently).
@Angry_Panda
Are they still doing NSFW art of Dex-chan for the supporters? I haven't seen an update since February on their page.
Angry_Panda
Angry_Panda
Mangamoz
Mangamoz
Top