Wasn't noticed in the original what state of Sakura was that day.
Maybe because wasn't aware about that world as a whole. How deep the darkness is. Give me back my childhood.
I can sort of see the appeal of certain girl failures (NSFW warning) but I could never be with one long-term, it's what makes Sumire so frustrating because I can see the potential in her, she does take after her mother a fair bit (in a good way).
Because girlfailures have that "she's like me fr fr" charm for the people who read manga except they're also hawt. Girlfailures, perverted womem, and yanderes are by far the best waifu archetypes.