Ama ama Cinderella - Ch. 25 - Iroha and Minori

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 18, 2023
Messages
493
That was nice.
Did this manga get axed for being to good ? Like i cannot fathom the problem here

I just kind of....walk away from this. It wasn't horrible but there was also nothing that was making me want to keep reading.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Dec 19, 2020
Messages
523
This is fine harem mangas with open endings like this are ok no need to drag them out for 100+ chpters with still no conclusions

cough to love-ru and love-ru darkness cough
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Feb 8, 2024
Messages
48
Did this manga get axed for being to good ? Like i cannot fathom the problem here
While subjective, I feel that this manga didn’t bring anything unique to the readers. It’s your typical romcom harem where every female (except the teacher) falls in love with MC, but MC is too awkward and oblivious to that fact.

I liked the drawing and artstyle, but the story didn’t stand out at all. It lacked depth, and every female protag only got sbout 2-3 chapters of individual arcs before falling for the MC.

I personally wouldn’t have minded for a longer continuation, but I can see why readers would lose interest in this one.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 5, 2023
Messages
239
While subjective, I feel that this manga didn’t bring anything unique to the readers. It’s your typical romcom harem where every female (except the teacher) falls in love with MC, but MC is too awkward and oblivious to that fact.

I liked the drawing and artstyle, but the story didn’t stand out at all. It lacked depth, and every female protag only got sbout 2-3 chapters of individual arcs before falling for the MC.

I personally wouldn’t have minded for a longer continuation, but I can see why readers would lose interest in this one.
It wasn’t unique. Very generic. But that’s what I liked about it. It’s a manga I could read without much thought. What’s not to love about thicc girls baking sweets? Oh well. Probably won’t even end with him choosing one of the girls. Sad
 
Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2023
Messages
1,596
While subjective, I feel that this manga didn’t bring anything unique to the readers. It’s your typical romcom harem where every female (except the teacher) falls in love with MC, but MC is too awkward and oblivious to that fact.

I liked the drawing and artstyle, but the story didn’t stand out at all. It lacked depth, and every female protag only got sbout 2-3 chapters of individual arcs before falling for the MC.

I personally wouldn’t have minded for a longer continuation, but I can see why readers would lose interest in this one.
It brought something extremely unique to me, an MC that isn't useless
The rest is already on every single romcom, on going or completed, 300 chapters or 60
So like i said, i cannot see the problem here
 
Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2023
Messages
1,596
While subjective, I feel that this manga didn’t bring anything unique to the readers. It’s your typical romcom harem where every female (except the teacher) falls in love with MC, but MC is too awkward and oblivious to that fact.

I liked the drawing and artstyle, but the story didn’t stand out at all. It lacked depth, and every female protag only got sbout 2-3 chapters of individual arcs before falling for the MC.

I personally wouldn’t have minded for a longer continuation, but I can see why readers would lose interest in this one.
Also your critique over "2-3 chapters before falling" is unfair, because the author was def aware the manga would end with the current Vol, so they tried to wrap up at least the basics
 
Member
Joined
Feb 29, 2024
Messages
60
Bro might need to convert to Muslim so he can marry those four 💀
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top