Biography of Hwiyeong Sword

[MangaDex]

 

[Nixolas_Zinn]

First two chapter spoilers below (ranty)

Spoiler

Look I just always get immediately disintrested when it the non-human character immediately becomes human. Like you have a cover of a fox person and immediately become a different person.... maybe there's some transformation or something but....

I'd honestly prefer a wanderer start than odd reincarnation that involves trying to apply Sin that humans believe in onto a non-human of plane (world?). Yeah that's another thing I'm annoyed about, your people are wanting to kill Yokai, some of whom don't give a flying fart about you, and you attack them unprovoked and yet that ain't sinful.

But yeah not giving it a chance. Just a bunch of things that get on my nerves that just annoyed me too much. But don't use me as a measurement of whether or not to read this, I mean I gave up after finishing chapter 2, it might be a good read, idk.

 

[Gyges]

Interesting premise but kind of ruined by the fact that the whole manhwa is just a series of loosely connected dick-measuring scenes where the protagonist gets to show off how great he is. Every other character is either forgotten and/or just used to underline how great he is. His main character trait being arrogant and little else makes the whole thing so much less tolerable too, which also kind of undermines the whole premise of the story of him having to live as a human because he is so disconnected from other people. If this is just a setup for some character growth arc then it took too long cause im on chapter 40 and above average art isnt gonna carry this.

 

[NicolasSps]

Obra boa, criei conta só para poder comentar sobre ela, a tradução praticamente perfeita, a obra não possui muita enrolação clichê, mesmo a premissa sendo mais do mesmo conseguiu sair do padrão

 

[HepBisforme]

Yall tripping, this is fire. Always love a good murim manhwa

 

[Fluffyponpon]

They shown us cool tiger guy and I thought it will be good action with proper male MC, but they instantly ruined all switching to some crybaby imbecile with pount face. MC kid is super dumb and annoing, maybe for children such reading will be ok, but not for adults.

 

[minsam]

Great story + great art that is unfortunately ruined by MTL translation. Almost peak (lacks tragedy and humor).

 

[ItzaMeZack]

The world building is subpar and the cast of characters are superficial.
Characters are introduced with motivations, i.e. want to do X because of Y; e.g. want to revenge because family was massacred. These motivations are supposed to be the cause and form beliefs and convictions that would permeate a character's decision or action throughout the story. However, the story neither show nor tell these beliefs or convictions, thus completely neglect them. As a result, the characters became as easily forgotten as whatever their backstory are.
The world building is basically whatever convenient for the story. The protag is a son of a well-known merchant association because it is convenient for him to be so. What kind of goods does it trade? What does the average life of a person anywhere in this story is like? It is hard to imagine the existence of the average person when everything in the story only exist to drive the protag's action and progress the story. Thus, the world is not living and existing, but merely a shell that contain the protag.

Good for time-killing, and nothing else. I doubt you will remember this story a week later