Bokura no Libido - Ch. 6 - Our Scent

Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Dec 31, 2023
Messages
59
That's just a harem
harem is if they all agree to "share" or, as mostly commonly but wrongly used, if they are stuck in status quo limbo

if one love interest(male or female) steals heroine/protagonist(male or female) away, then it is ntr

ntr literally is about taking away a love interest. whether its heroine B taking away protag from heroine A, or some dude taking heroine from protag doesn't matter.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Dec 31, 2023
Messages
59
had to reread chapter 1, since i totally forgot protag is a transfer student.

Damn, is this going to be like Persona 3/4, except social links is about kinks?
If so, wonder how MAX social link event will be like.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 23, 2025
Messages
40
ntr literally is about taking away a love interest. whether its heroine B taking away protag from heroine A, or some dude taking heroine from protag doesn't matter.

This is true but only applies if heroine A is dating the protag and then heroine B swoops in and steals the protag

If no one is dating each other then is just a free for all harem, and if a pair becomes exclusive then everyone else gets BSS'd, not NTR

No serious relationship no NTR
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Dec 31, 2023
Messages
59
This is true but only applies if heroine A is dating the protag and then heroine B swoops in and steals the protag

If no one is dating each other then is just a free for all harem, and if a pair becomes exclusive then everyone else gets BSS'd, not NTR

No serious relationship no NTR
and what even is a "serious relationship"?
and thus, we move from literal to tags etc which abstracts the concept.

The same as your usage of the word "harem". If we are being technical about it, it should only apply in cases where the ML is dating/married multiple heroines(e.g DxD). Not simply multiple heroines pinning for a protag that isn't commited to them, which is pretty much the harem genre's "definition"(the trope chick magnet would be be a better fit perhaps, or some other trope i can't think of at the moment, as magnet implies drawing indiscriminately i imagine)

In this case, while no marriage(that is i believe, the legal standard for a serious relationship), "officially" dating(the social "serious relationship"/trope whatever i think),
it is established that we have a pseudo-couple(In chapter 5, both leads expressed a sentiment of a "(near)future" with each other) by plot and setting.
Yes, they are not a couple, but narratively, it is expressed similarly.

By technicality, this series, assuming the common tropes, is neither a harem nor NTR.
But by "genre"(for lack of better word, as i do not think its the best fit for the point i am making as seen in the following explanations in brackets),
it can be both harem(i imagine it won't be long before the tag is added) AND NTR(whether added tag or not), assuming protag "falls" for new girl, as, again, the pseudo couple ship is established
 

jc9

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 6, 2024
Messages
86
This is true but only applies if heroine A is dating the protag and then heroine B swoops in and steals the protag

If no one is dating each other then is just a free for all harem, and if a pair becomes exclusive then everyone else gets BSS'd, not NTR

No serious relationship no NTR
NTR (as a whole genre) focuses on the act of stealing someone in a relationship (not exclusively romantic one! It can be for example friendship or family relations - so we have stuff like mom x bully ntr), and requires that 3rd (or 1st depending on how you count) person to be, directly or indirectly (even mentioned), in the story. If they are consenting to it, then it's netorase, if they are not, it's netorare.
If there's romantic relationship in place, then cheating or swinging can be also relevant (for netorare and netorase respectively).
You can also have cheating/swinging stories w/o NTR elements (stealing someone's partner/giving away your partner is not a part of the story/it's not relevant enough).
BSS is rather muddy (hard to define clear boundaries for it, same as when it's netori and when it's not), so for me it's when a relationship is rather one sided (senpai not noticing you and going with someone else for example).
And again - NTR needs the taking away part. If MC fucks 2 girls, and they simply share him, it's not NTR.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top