An "ingot" sounds like one of the lamest awards you can get for such an event.
I've read a manga about a shop owned by a guy like that.
That's a very specific order. "A ton of weapons." That's sure to give them exactly what they want.
That's a classy horse. It's not a donkey. The ears are too short. The face looks more like a cow than either, but probably closer to a horse than a donkey.
What's wrong with saying someone's great and supernatural? Those are decent enough compliments that you don't have to question whether they're compliments.