Haite Kudasai, Takamine-san - Ch. 68.2 - Become My New Closet (Part 2)

[SrNevik]

Talking down to people who engage with media differently from you because you think they're "wrong" is certainly a choice.

It's great that you can take a series unseriously, but I fail to see the value in badmouthing the way others choose to view it.

Methinks you're taking other peoples' criticism of elements of this story too seriously, if you feel the need to revisit each chapter with the same "holier-than-thou" attitude in the comments like this.

Just enjoy the manga for what it is. You don't have to be a jerk to others for their opinions.

If you think that's being a jerk we'll have to agree to disagree. I can criticize opinions I disagree with and yes we can disagree with how a story is read and it's intents.

I do think it's silly to treat this girl like she's in a drama rather than a slapstick, nonsense rom com that's more akin to edgy comedy about a girl literally changing time with her panties. After all these chapters, I think that's missing the point. There's narrative and relationship progress but it's all comedy. Also, I've left two short comments. Let's not exaggerate.

 

[Schernobyl]

If you think that's being a jerk we'll have to agree to disagree. I can criticize opinions I disagree with and yes we can disagree with how a story is read and it's intents.

I do think it's silly to treat this girl like she's in a drama rather than a slapstick, nonsense rom com that's more akin to edgy comedy about a girl literally changing time with her panties. After all these chapters, I think that's missing the point. There's narrative and relationship progress but it's all comedy. Also, I've left two short comments. Let's not exaggerate.

To be fair this is tagged with drama and slice of life. So expecting some sort of coherent story, character progression and plot progression isnt wrong. I'd also argue that ecchi comedic rom com's manga don't have to be this non-sense, many still manage to have good writing.

 

[SrNevik]

To be fair this is tagged with drama and slice of life. So expecting some sort of coherent story, character progression and plot progression isnt wrong. I'd also argue that ecchi comedic rom com's manga don't have to be this non-sense, many still manage to have good writing.

This does have character and plot progression but it is mostly focused on its absurd comedy and sexual framing. Also, it's chapter 68. I'd have no issue with some of these comments if this were chapter 8 instead. This has been what it is for 68 chapters and a couple years, yet comments act like they're still surprised. The tags don't mean anything at this point and they are self tagged. The series is a romcom. Good writing is also subjective. This series does what it sets out to do. It's not trying to be more than itself.

 

[lectorhip]

All comments are from sociologists and cinema critics or something wut. Yeah and master roshi should be in jail goku is a villain not throwing him to hell.

 

[EnderWin]

I sure wish we get to see more of her expressiveness 🙏