Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 24, 2018
- Messages
- 4,109
@mahtan:
>if the human generate the mana itself there is no reason it can't use magic
Human generate carbon dioxide, it doesn't mean they can use it. See how your logic is flawed here?
>But here it is one entity, God, managing all types of mana
7 major Gods and their kins (12 for each major God iirc), split into generally 7 'colors' and each God also have certain things they govern. i.e. you don't ask the God governing 'speed' to 'healing'.
They don't manage mana, they just reply to prayers.
> using accidental magic when it happens
except in-universe it was said that didn't even count as magic, and also harmful to others (assuming you mean the pressure wave)
heck, if anything your idea of 'only' elements count for magic is already flawed given how many series have handled magic that isn't element based (Mahouka even have element-based magic be a relic of the past)
you seem to think all magic have to follow the same logic/law you believe exist, but the thing is, it's MAGIC, it doesn't have to follow shit.
there's worlds where you think and magic happen
there's worlds where you speak keywords and magic happen
there's worlds where there's no 'magic', just some other supernatural power (alchemy from FMA, etc)
none of them have to follow some universal law of magic, ever
so tl;dr is my issue with you is that you seem to be having issue against a FANTASY setting by your own arbitrary rule and not something in-universe
>if the human generate the mana itself there is no reason it can't use magic
Human generate carbon dioxide, it doesn't mean they can use it. See how your logic is flawed here?
>But here it is one entity, God, managing all types of mana
7 major Gods and their kins (12 for each major God iirc), split into generally 7 'colors' and each God also have certain things they govern. i.e. you don't ask the God governing 'speed' to 'healing'.
They don't manage mana, they just reply to prayers.
> using accidental magic when it happens
except in-universe it was said that didn't even count as magic, and also harmful to others (assuming you mean the pressure wave)
heck, if anything your idea of 'only' elements count for magic is already flawed given how many series have handled magic that isn't element based (Mahouka even have element-based magic be a relic of the past)
you seem to think all magic have to follow the same logic/law you believe exist, but the thing is, it's MAGIC, it doesn't have to follow shit.
there's worlds where you think and magic happen
there's worlds where you speak keywords and magic happen
there's worlds where there's no 'magic', just some other supernatural power (alchemy from FMA, etc)
none of them have to follow some universal law of magic, ever
so tl;dr is my issue with you is that you seem to be having issue against a FANTASY setting by your own arbitrary rule and not something in-universe