Hyouketsu Reijou-sama wo Follow Shitara, Mechamecha Dekiai Sareteshimatta Ken - Ch. 6

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 12, 2023
Messages
2,241
its quite a weird way to end the chapter but oh well.
thank you for the chapter!
Why does this feel incomplete
48 pages [though typical for chapter 1 to be much longer] -> 31 -> 30 -> 22 -> 20 -> 15

It certainly is a pretty quick drop-off in page count.
I personally think that the pages have been chopped in strange ways and that instead of six chapters,we should be at four chapters,even three.

Something's up with the raws and the scanlator hasn't noticed.

Yeah,four and five MOST CERTAINLY are supposed to be one chapter.

Six here is actually the first half of five,seven being the next half.

This is beyond just calling the .1,.2,etc. nonsense that publishers do to stratch their pennies stupid,this has outright destroyed the comic in a weird way.

Dear Scanlator,please combine the chapters as they should be,it's fairly obvious how they should be stitched back together.

And absolutely do NOT simply change them to .1,.2,etc.,that nonsense was finally being dealt with before the massacre(which now stands at 1867 identified corpses[apparently 7000+ titles were stabbed])and it should no longer be tolerated at this point due to MangaDexs' own outdated rules that didn't help at all.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 12, 2023
Messages
2,241
Rule 3.2.1 - Do not arbitrarily combine several chapters into a single release.
And this rule has already been stated as a suggestion after it's been pointed out that chapters had been split into .1,.2,and so on by publishers(and not the intended reading temp set by the actual author n' artist),plenty of scanlators recognise the short coming of said ruling and have returned chapters to how they should be.

That was before MangaDex failed to uphold the very statement they made about being the go between piracy and pathetic official sites that only allowed what scanlators uploaded directly.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 6, 2018
Messages
6,448
Oh dear. She was made their bitch.

Farah is quite adorable too. I'm curious how the makeover will go.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Nov 28, 2020
Messages
23
Something's up with the raws and the scanlator hasn't noticed.

Dear Scanlator,please combine the chapters as they should be,it's fairly obvious how they should be stitched back together.

And absolutely do NOT simply change them to .1,.2,etc.,that nonsense was finally being dealt with before the massacre(which now stands at 1867 identified corpses[apparently 7000+ titles were stabbed])and it should no longer be tolerated at this point due to MangaDexs' own outdated rules that didn't help at all.
Hi,

I did notice, the chapters have been split in half after ch.3. But on the raw website, the split parts aren’t labeled as .1 or .2 like other series, they’re called ch.4 (=4.1) and ch.5 (=4.2). So I thought I’d do the same to avoid any confusion regarding the numbering.

That’s why I uploaded ch.4 and 5 at the same time. I thought I’d do the same with ch.6 and 7 (=ch. 5.1 and 5.2), but then I thought it’s been two months, and I don’t know when the next part will come out, so I went and uploaded it.

Though I can switch back to double releases (=one whole chapter) if you guys want.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 14, 2018
Messages
1,349
Hi,

I did notice, the chapters have been split in half after ch.3. But on the raw website, the split parts aren’t labeled as .1 or .2 like other series, they’re called ch.4 (=4.1) and ch.5 (=4.2). So I thought I’d do the same to avoid any confusion regarding the numbering.

That’s why I uploaded ch.4 and 5 at the same time. I thought I’d do the same with ch.6 and 7 (=ch. 5.1 and 5.2), but then I thought it’s been two months, and I don’t know when the next part will come out, so I went and uploaded it.

Though I can switch back to double releases (=one whole chapter) if you guys want.
Tbh, this is one of those cases where both numbering are correct, because the publisher doesn't post them as splits but you know they are once the volume release if you were to get it (doesn't really help that none of the pages have a chapter number in them lol), so to make sure what is the correct one, you can check the volume releases, Volume 1 go up to chapter 5, and by counting page differences for chapter 4 and 5, yes they are really off compared to how the publisher did them in the website (and the Volume may or not have the missing split for the actual chapter 5 lol), at the end of the day publisher website and volume releases always gonna be off, so the order depend on what you want follow

Another case of this, is the continuation of I Shall Survive using Potions, where the publisher do them as short 10-15 page chapters in the website and you can see them as individual chapters, but once volume release, all those are merged and you end up with a 70+ pages chapter

And this rule has already been stated as a suggestion after it's been pointed out that chapters had been split into .1,.2,and so on by publishers(and not the intended reading temp set by the actual author n' artist),plenty of scanlators recognise the short coming of said ruling and have returned chapters to how they should be.

That was before MangaDex failed to uphold the very statement they made about being the go between piracy and pathetic official sites that only allowed what scanlators uploaded directly.
That rule is there in the rare case someone go and merge chapters without them being actual splits (for example, merging chapter 1 to 3 of one piece as a single chapter), the case of this serie is that the chapters aren't really published as splits, but they actually are if you check the volume, so while both numbers are correct at the end of the day depend on the scanlator, because publisher and volume numbers gonna be off
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 29, 2019
Messages
1,227
kinda weird that the other noble girl went on like this, was last chapter a red herring...? it's probably won't be that deep thinking that she got ulterior motive
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
686
The chapter ends like as if it's 6.1 and waiting the 6.2, wth no way that's the whole chapter
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 12, 2023
Messages
2,241
Hi,

I did notice, the chapters have been split in half after ch.3. But on the raw website, the split parts aren’t labeled as .1 or .2 like other series, they’re called ch.4 (=4.1) and ch.5 (=4.2). So I thought I’d do the same to avoid any confusion regarding the numbering.

That’s why I uploaded ch.4 and 5 at the same time. I thought I’d do the same with ch.6 and 7 (=ch. 5.1 and 5.2), but then I thought it’s been two months, and I don’t know when the next part will come out, so I went and uploaded it.

Though I can switch back to double releases (=one whole chapter) if you guys want.
It'd be better if you just combined them as they should,for it's obvious for the people with brains that this is not an intended spliting of the chapters,no author/artist would ever do it so badly,regardless what nonsense the publisher has done with the raws.

If the obvious half is missing its' other,then wait for the other to come out and combine as they should be.
That rule is there in the rare case someone go and merge chapters without them being actual splits (for example, merging chapter 1 to 3 of one piece as a single chapter), the case of this serie is that the chapters aren't really published as splits, but they actually are if you check the volume, so while both numbers are correct at the end of the day depend on the scanlator, because publisher and volume numbers gonna be off
The rule is also outdated due to not stating that obvious splits should be combined and quite a few scanlators state as much.

Again,though,can't comply with a rule when the ones who have it can't keep their own end of the business.

So if a scanlator,and this observant scanlator included,notices,they should do the do diligence and one up the publishers,even if it means waiting for the next half,since a more whole chapter is far better and easier to remember.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top