Kamigami no Kago de Seisan Kakumei ~Isekai no Katasumi de Mattari Slow Life Shi Tetara, Naze ka Tasaina Jinzai ga Atsumatte Saikyō Kokka ga Dekitemas…
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2018
- Messages
- 814
Now that he is king of the elves, and the new kingdom, he needs a queen to make heirs. Now where is he going to find a queen of all things?
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Mar 9, 2019
- Messages
- 686
Hmm.. I can't put a finger on it but it feels this manga is bit more forceful than - Isekai Nonbiri -.
The girls is too eager to surrender themselves to MC. For a place dubbed "Hell", there is only 1 bad monster so far.
MC seems clever and bit dumb at the same time. If he can grow trees, why not make a bigger house first instead of living in tent and let the carpenter renovate later?
They put too much emphasis / dependency on blessing that it makes the world feels dumb if they didn't have it.
There are barely localized world building too. How is the geography on the surrounding? Is there a need to put up walls or fences? Do they make drains to bring in the water or they completely rely on MC and his magic bag?
If they are on the run, shouldn't they also setup defences before procreating? Especially when all of them are females.
It's not a big deal overall but seems like the manga got the order all over the place. There aren't many farming isekai I just want to read something nice.
The girls is too eager to surrender themselves to MC. For a place dubbed "Hell", there is only 1 bad monster so far.
MC seems clever and bit dumb at the same time. If he can grow trees, why not make a bigger house first instead of living in tent and let the carpenter renovate later?
They put too much emphasis / dependency on blessing that it makes the world feels dumb if they didn't have it.
There are barely localized world building too. How is the geography on the surrounding? Is there a need to put up walls or fences? Do they make drains to bring in the water or they completely rely on MC and his magic bag?
If they are on the run, shouldn't they also setup defences before procreating? Especially when all of them are females.
It's not a big deal overall but seems like the manga got the order all over the place. There aren't many farming isekai I just want to read something nice.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2019
- Messages
- 890
No I think that's quite a big deal instead. I can't help but compare it to the isekai nonbiri nouka and I feel like the author like tries to use the same formula to achieve the same results, but he's so forceful in execution of it that he forgets the purpose of it.
Isekai nonbiri nouka is first of all 'nonbiri nouka' which means a relaxed life if I'm not wrong. Here we have each chapter the need of urgency, the speed of execution of things is fast and it' like it's a matter of time before somebody comes and threthens his peace. I wonder how things will go when the demon lord or the duchy notices this island but man. The pacing is weird.
Even if I'm stupid to expect it to be 'nonbiri nouka', the dude himself dreams of slow life in the countryside. It doesn't say he wants to be a harem king in the countryside.
Isekai nonbiri nouka is good at this with the slow pacing, here author rushes to achieve what Isekai Nonbiri Nouka is overnight.
He spends time alone. He gets the dogs, the dogs have children, he spends with them and then thw first girl appears. (I don't really remember it all perfectly).
Here the MC is never alone. The gods leave, instantly he gets a dog, he goes to the beach, instantly a ship passes by and harem appears. They spend the night, he becomes the king.
You can never achieve a dream of slow life like thus, it's just another power fantasy, but does he have power to keep it together? What if the soldiers invade? The threat is just keeping you anxious and it never feels relaxing, it just forces you to read not for the slow life, but anxiety of what's next to come.
Also why touch upon heavy topics like slavery? Isekai Nonbiri Nouka just glosses over things like this and it feels a lot more normal.
I get if you compare the two, Isekai Nonbiri Nouka at the core is the same power fantasy, but it's way less packed, the story is more thought out. And even if for a moment it changes into a quick action scene, it's soon back to normal pacing. I really liked that.
Here I just read because I force myself to see if it ever creares the enviroment for the slow life MC was talking about in page 1 of chapter 1.
Why do they need to overexplain things? I already feel like skipping those speach bubbles and just go ahead to see things done.
Tl;dr:
The story promises a slow life farming of MC's dreams as Isekai Nonbiri Nouka does, but instead you get rushed power fantasy where the MC is able to solve all the issues of the harem he was just delivered with so much explanation to make it feel all justified and normal.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Oct 3, 2019
- Messages
- 2,395
The MC is so Japanese that he gets uncomfortable and freaked out by a human missing an arm.
I figured it out, though:
This MC is all of the... "aji" (the "leaves a bad taste" thing) character traits that so many people in Japan can demonstrate, and I think the author is calling them out.
The Elf Queen is actually the MC, and the subject of the isekai is just a walking, talking Deus ex Machina
And, I gotta say, the MC did a great job convincing the roaming idiot (Tadashi) to become "king" and help her save her people!
She's awesome!
I figured it out, though:
This MC is all of the... "aji" (the "leaves a bad taste" thing) character traits that so many people in Japan can demonstrate, and I think the author is calling them out.
The Elf Queen is actually the MC, and the subject of the isekai is just a walking, talking Deus ex Machina
And, I gotta say, the MC did a great job convincing the roaming idiot (Tadashi) to become "king" and help her save her people!
She's awesome!
Last edited:
Similar threads
