This game is such bullshit. Not only how the people reacted, but also that there is some obvious ambiguity from her throwing away her cards that didn't exist beforehand. If there is an inherent order before, it will also exist some inherent order after. And if it didn't after, then there never would have been one before.
Besides, why would the supposed smart mc decide to ask such an ordered question, instead of something like "what is written on one of the face-down cards for player X?" or even "What are the secrets on X's remaining cards?" (that's not multiple questions).
Looks like it's getting fun. Anyone please continue this, It's just quite interesting enough to get me want to read more.
I agree that it feels like the "completed" tag seems incorrect