Lucky☆Star: Konata's Thirties - Ch. 3

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 13, 2018
Messages
912
Just discovered this from mangaupdates

Kinda bizarre that this was approved as an official continuation with a different artist. Art style aside (it's very different but it's fine), does this idiot (author, not insulting the scanlation at all) really not realize that high school girls are pretty much done growing height-wise in early high school?

Girls typically stop growing by age 15--sometimes even earlier. Konata is 17 at the START of the manga. Middle of her 2nd year in a standard 3-year Japanese high school. She turns 18 during the anime, but I can't remember if that was a canon occurrence during the manga.

Apparently Konata grew SIX INCHES in the 13-14 years since the original manga, according to the Lucky Star wiki? That makes no sense. Literally none at all. She went from a tiny girl at age 17 to a completely average-height Japanese woman. That doesn't happen.

I wouldn't give a fuck if she grew in other ways--I don't need Konata to be a "legal loli" the way her dad was canonically into, the way they gave her a modest (instead of totally flat) chest is fine, the hips are fine, these things do happen. But the way she grew in physical height makes ZERO SENSE.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 24, 2019
Messages
57
Just discovered this from mangaupdates

Kinda bizarre that this was approved as an official continuation with a different artist. Art style aside (it's very different but it's fine), does this idiot (author, not insulting the scanlation at all) really not realize that high school girls are pretty much done growing height-wise in early high school?

Girls typically stop growing by age 15--sometimes even earlier. Konata is 17 at the START of the manga. Middle of her 2nd year in a standard 3-year Japanese high school. She turns 18 during the anime, but I can't remember if that was a canon occurrence during the manga.

Apparently Konata grew SIX INCHES in the 13-14 years since the original manga, according to the Lucky Star wiki? That makes no sense. Literally none at all. She went from a tiny girl at age 17 to a completely average-height Japanese woman. That doesn't happen.

I wouldn't give a fuck if she grew in other ways--I don't need Konata to be a "legal loli" the way her dad was canonically into, the way they gave her a modest (instead of totally flat) chest is fine, the hips are fine, these things do happen. But the way she grew in physical height makes ZERO SENSE.
Calm down, it's just a manga.
I'm pretty sure it's just cuz it's a different artstyle anyway
 
Group Leader
Joined
Jan 22, 2023
Messages
2,250
thats such a nice surprise. I can't wait to see what this story will show!!!!

what gachas Konata play I wonder =x
 
Active member
Joined
Aug 22, 2019
Messages
25
Just discovered this from mangaupdates

Kinda bizarre that this was approved as an official continuation with a different artist. Art style aside (it's very different but it's fine), does this idiot (author, not insulting the scanlation at all) really not realize that high school girls are pretty much done growing height-wise in early high school?

Girls typically stop growing by age 15--sometimes even earlier. Konata is 17 at the START of the manga. Middle of her 2nd year in a standard 3-year Japanese high school. She turns 18 during the anime, but I can't remember if that was a canon occurrence during the manga.

Apparently Konata grew SIX INCHES in the 13-14 years since the original manga, according to the Lucky Star wiki? That makes no sense. Literally none at all. She went from a tiny girl at age 17 to a completely average-height Japanese woman. That doesn't happen.

I wouldn't give a fuck if she grew in other ways--I don't need Konata to be a "legal loli" the way her dad was canonically into, the way they gave her a modest (instead of totally flat) chest is fine, the hips are fine, these things do happen. But the way she grew in physical height makes ZERO SENSE.
You can just say this is your second manga.
You didn't have to type all that stuff.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top