While I do agree with you that these type of chapters can be preachy and annoying, I feel like discounting his views just because he was living in Australia at the time is a bit harsh, especially since we're only one chapter in and haven't gotten the full extent of his take yet. Again, I'm not disagreeing that his screeds can be kinda obnoxious, I'm just saying that him living outside of Japan at the time of writing doesn't automatically invalidate whatever commentary he's trying to make.After knowing the author actually lives in Australia, my scepticism about these kinda chapters just increase. Like, this would've required a lot of research in the local area, which you can't really do properly from abroad even with modern technology.
I'm sure the guy could fly to Japan every once in a while, but does he stay for long enough to do proper research or is he just doing keyboard warrior activism?
I think the most positive thing I can say about Kariya in this situation is "it's the thought that counts."While I do agree with you that these type of chapters can be preachy and annoying, I feel like discounting his views just because he was living in Australia at the time is a bit harsh, especially since we're only one chapter in and haven't gotten the full extent of his take yet. Again, I'm not disagreeing that his screeds can be kinda obnoxious, I'm just saying that him living outside of Japan at the time of writing doesn't automatically invalidate whatever commentary he's trying to make.
And I totally get that! I just don't want to automatically discount the take just because of him living in Australia. Let's wait to see what the rest of the take is, and then we can discount it (or not) based on the merits of the storytelling surrounding it, if that makes sense. (Not saying that you're doing that, just elaborating on my perspective. 😅)I think the most positive thing I can say about Kariya in this situation is "it's the thought that counts."
Sure, it's probably the most cliché take you can have for a guy who's more often than not just being preachy at times, but considering that I do like some of his takes (especially during the Korean Cuisine Match Arc), I think that's probably the most positive thing I can say about him, regardless of where he was living at that time.
My guy, what did you read and what did you think I was saying? Where did I say his views are not valid?While I do agree with you that these type of chapters can be preachy and annoying, I feel like discounting his views just because he was living in Australia at the time is a bit harsh, especially since we're only one chapter in and haven't gotten the full extent of his take yet. Again, I'm not disagreeing that his screeds can be kinda obnoxious, I'm just saying that him living outside of Japan at the time of writing doesn't automatically invalidate whatever commentary he's trying to make.
I absolutely apologize for misunderstanding the intent of your post, but at the same time, I don’t think my commentary was critical enough to warrant this intense and at times vitriolic defense. I misread your post, and I’m sorry for that. But the ferocity here feels a bit much.My guy, what did you read and what did you think I was saying? Where did I say his views are not valid?
You do realise "scepticism" just means "I have doubts"? Having doubts is not invalidating anything. And what I have doubts about is whether Kariya spent enough time in Japan to actually do proper research for his chapters. Especially for chapters that actually mention very specific locations. He can't do that kind of research from Australia.
Like I don't have a problem with his "Blah blah conserve nature!!" message in general, it's not a wrong sentiment to have. I have even defended him a few times when I find that he did get oddly specific things actually correct. It's just that if he gets the facts wrong, whatever he says is going to be inherently flawed. We know he's got a lot of the data wrong before. Whale arc horrors, remember?
Even if the info is wrong, I want him to have at least tried. When it comes to nature, there are many situations where you kind of need to actually be there to see it and talk to people on-location to get a proper grasp of things. That was why I had issues with him being in Australia. It makes research trips so much harder. It's hard enough even if he just lives in Tokyo, much more so if he's in another country thousands of miles away.
Edit: This is a weekly series, so I get that there's time constraints too, so it can't be helped that he can't always fly back and forth to research. It's still an irresponsible attitude to assume to know so much if he didn't put in the leg work. Emphasis on IF. I don't know, that's why my original comment is a question.
Hey man, if my reply sounded harsh or aggressive, for that I also apologise. But I don't think I was being vitriolic. I did not call you bad names or use abusive language.I absolutely apologize for misunderstanding the intent of your post, but at the same time, I don’t think my commentary was critical enough to warrant this intense and at times vitriolic defense. I misread your post, and I’m sorry for that. But the ferocity here feels a bit much.
I appreciate the apology! And you're right, you were not being vitriolic; that was a poor choice of words on my part. I absolutely respect your position, and I in no way meant to impugn anything negative about your character, just like I'm sure you didn't mean to do the same to me. Just a communication mishap!Hey man, if my reply sounded harsh or aggressive, for that I also apologise. But I don't think I was being vitriolic. I did not call you bad names or use abusive language.
I actually didn't intend most of it to be directed at you, the rant is more towards Kariya. I've always said that it was obnoxious that he always acts like such a know it all. It's just even more frustrating if it turns out he was just playing keyboard activist from across the ocean.
Like, before I had thought he was living in Japan and he really was doing all the trips around Japan just like Yamaoka was doing in the chapters. But him being in Australia would make that kind of on-location research difficult to do, which increases my doubts about his fact-finding process.
In his defence, I do know for a fact that manga editors don't actually care about accuracy like that. They often don't care if there's total bullshit claims in the story, as long as the story sells and make money. But Kariya is actually trying to be an activist so it's on him himself to get the facts straight.