Ore no Imouto ga Saikou no Okazudatta - Vol. 1 Ch. 8

Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 1, 2018
Messages
2,610
I mean this manga is pretty much a hard promo for the LN (they called it an All-Ages version too), so they weren't going to go super depth into it, this work have 9 LN volumes, the LN have alot of extra stuff compared to the WN

Publisher pretty much picked some of the LN they are publishing and decided to do a short and quick adaptation for each work (list of adaptations)
Are you sure that's correct? The light novel is 1 volume and complete, the webnovel is 9 volumes and ongoing, at least as listed on novelupdates. And a cursory check on syosetu confirms the webnovel is still ongoing there, while the light novel can't even be found on the platforms anymore(bookwalker etc).
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Jan 20, 2023
Messages
567
still curious even mc XDD its true his sister friend prevert
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
2,150
I swear Yuka has it way worse in the WN.. :aquadrink:
She's supposed to be restrained and blindfolded by Miyu to be used as fap material in person for MC. Then once he cums, Miyu force feeds Yuka his semen as 'medicine that makes you smarter'. (WN source) Way later in the story, Miyu makes MC full on rape her. (WN source) It's absolutely insane.

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥✍️
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 27, 2023
Messages
69
Are you sure that's correct? The light novel is 1 volume and complete, the webnovel is 9 volumes and ongoing, at least as listed on novelupdates. And a cursory check on syosetu confirms the webnovel is still ongoing there, while the light novel can't even be found on the platforms anymore(bookwalker etc).
You should be correct. The Light Novel seems more rushed with additional stuff that's missing in both the WN and manga and feels pretty much finished with the final chapter of the first volume.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 3, 2023
Messages
551
Are you sure that's correct? The light novel is 1 volume and complete, the webnovel is 9 volumes and ongoing, at least as listed on novelupdates. And a cursory check on syosetu confirms the webnovel is still ongoing there, while the light novel can't even be found on the platforms anymore(bookwalker etc).
You should be correct. The Light Novel seems more rushed with additional stuff that's missing in both the WN and manga and feels pretty much finished with the final chapter of the first volume.
Did you both even bother clicking the link provided to the LN before commenting?, no you didn't lmao, even the WN page tells you that there is 9 LN Volumes on sale currently and give you links to it, with 9th released on Nov 10th

And never guide yourself with novelupdates, in the first place is user edited, 2nd, reason why is marked as "completed" is because the entry with translated chapters and linked here in MD page, is for the rewritten standalone story, that was done for Bishoujo Bunko (you can check that by seeing the colored illustrations nsfw), and the other entry is for both the main WN and LN, which is why there is 9 volumes, yes thats how it is, so the NU link listed here goes to the wrong place

Here more links
https://book.dmm.co.jp/product/4130440/volumes/
https://www.amazon.co.jp/kindle-dbs/product/B0CLKXCPLL
https://www.cmoa.jp/title/1101327237/?page=1&order=down#buyarea
https://ebookjapan.yahoo.co.jp/books/666007/

Oh and, reason you can't find it in bookwalker, is because Adult rated works are blocked outside Japan, thats the message you get, not that they don't exist anymore, you didn't even bother
 
Last edited:
Member
Joined
Feb 13, 2023
Messages
11
I swear Yuka has it way worse in the WN.. :aquadrink:
She's supposed to be restrained and blindfolded by Miyu to be used as fap material in person for MC. Then once he cums, Miyu force feeds Yuka his semen as 'medicine that makes you smarter'. (WN source) Way later in the story, Miyu makes MC full on rape her. (WN source) It's absolutely insane.

iirc this was supposed to happen after our current manga timeline. even though the manga is ending(?) she's theoretically still due for those punishments in the future. yuka is an M i think, so she...
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2023
Messages
3,114
Gotta read the WN someday
It's better, but it meanders. Lots of mystery is loaded up right at the start, and the author doesn't really seem to be in any rush to answer questions. There's a whole character and arc that could have been deleted and we'd lose nothing of value; The whole thing almost literally ends with a "Yeah, never mind". If anything, the story would be streamlined by quite a bit, if it were gone.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 27, 2023
Messages
69
Did you both even bother clicking the link provided to the LN before commenting?, no you didn't lmao, even the WN page tells you that there is 9 LN Volumes on sale currently and give you links to it, with 9th released on Nov 10th

And never guide yourself with novelupdates, in the first place is user edited, 2nd, reason why is marked as "completed" is because the entry with translated chapters and linked here in MD page, is for the rewritten standalone story, that was done for Bishoujo Bunko (you can check that by seeing the colored illustrations nsfw), and the other entry is for both the main WN and LN, which is why there is 9 volumes, yes thats how it is, so the NU link listed here goes to the wrong place

Here more links
https://book.dmm.co.jp/product/4130440/volumes/
https://www.amazon.co.jp/kindle-dbs/product/B0CLKXCPLL
https://www.cmoa.jp/title/1101327237/?page=1&order=down#buyarea
https://ebookjapan.yahoo.co.jp/books/666007/

Oh and, reason you can't find it in bookwalker, is because Adult rated works are blocked outside Japan, thats the message you get, not that they don't exist anymore, you didn't even bother
Yeah I messed up. Thanks for the clarification. This actually clears up a lot of confusion and it seems like I read the Bishoujo Bunko version a while ago.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 28, 2019
Messages
2,607
I've read the novel before, mostly because I'm a degenerate. Uhh it didn't have a resolution when I read it, the story was just a weird porn world where Mc would bang his sister then do whatever she told him to.
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2023
Messages
3,114
I've read the novel before, mostly because I'm a degenerate. Uhh it didn't have a resolution when I read it, the story was just a weird porn world where Mc would bang his sister then do whatever she told him to.
I've reached the reveal for the "trips" in chapter 44, and I'm deeply unsatisfied by the answer. If you've read the whole thing, you mind saving me the trouble and letting me know if they ever actually address the other things? Like why she guzzles cum, why this stupid "secret" is even a big deal in the first place, and the album?

Please. Help a brother out.

EDIT: So it's just an explanation conga line after 44, I see. I feel I can rest easy in the knowledge that the album will be addressed at some point, then. And if not, I got my fill anyway. Wouldn't be the first story to end with loose ends.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Apr 10, 2023
Messages
3,114
It's better, but it meanders. Lots of mystery is loaded up right at the start, and the author doesn't really seem to be in any rush to answer questions. There's a whole character and arc that could have been deleted and we'd lose nothing of value; The whole thing almost literally ends with a "Yeah, never mind". If anything, the story would be streamlined by quite a bit, if it were gone.
Update: Halfway through, and I can confidently say that Haruka is a cancer on this story. She's less a character, and more a convenient source of mysteries, misunderstandings, and the usual "Can't spit it out" we get in these. Far too much is dedicated to feeding the big secret surrounding her, all for a pitiful reveal. Sure, at some point, expectations become unrealistic, but if you're not even going to try and deliver, then you don't spend 37 (very long) chapters building it up.

(Yes, this story has upset me, and I'm posting obsessively about it now)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 27, 2023
Messages
339
I don't remember either my junior high school or senior high school has that type of conversation, except for much smaller circle, yet compare to this more tame.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 12, 2023
Messages
1,148
I swear Yuka has it way worse in the WN.. :aquadrink:
She's supposed to be restrained and blindfolded by Miyu to be used as fap material in person for MC. Then once he cums, Miyu force feeds Yuka his semen as 'medicine that makes you smarter'. (WN source) Way later in the story, Miyu makes MC full on rape her. (WN source) It's absolutely insane.
Damn. That was quite a lot more hardcore than this title.
 
Double-page supporter
Joined
Feb 3, 2019
Messages
129
I swear Yuka has it way worse in the WN.. :aquadrink:
She's supposed to be restrained and blindfolded by Miyu to be used as fap material in person for MC. Then once he cums, Miyu force feeds Yuka his semen as 'medicine that makes you smarter'. (WN source) Way later in the story, Miyu makes MC full on rape her. (WN source) It's absolutely insane.
great story, 10/10
 
Contributor
Joined
Jan 21, 2018
Messages
5,308
I mean this manga is pretty much a hard promo for the LN (they called it an All-Ages version too), so they weren't going to go super depth into it, this work have 9 LN volumes, the LN have alot of extra stuff compared to the WN

Publisher pretty much picked some of the LN they are publishing and decided to do a short and quick adaptation for each work (list of adaptations)
It's quite unfortunate that every title on your link with the La France Comics label is just a short and quick adaptation. Following the precedent set by this manga, that likely means these other adaptations are also just novel promos:
These other works seem to be every bit as comically unhinged and degenerate as this one based on the title and synopsis for each, maybe some of them could even be entertaining dumpster fires.

But considering how this manga is just a watered-down novel ad, if these other works follow the pattern then I think it's now unlikely a group will pick any of these up since they're all likely doomed to end the way this manga does next chapter.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top