Shimotsuki-san wa Mobu ga Suki ~Hitomishiri na Kanojo wa Ore ni Dake Dere Amai~ - Vol. 3 Ch. 19

[Siddri]

My brain cannot process anything lol I got lost halfway through the story

 

[ysil69]

Honestly, from what I read of the spoilers this a better story. The OG gets like... weird and supernatural with actual protag powers and shit.

This was nice and simple.

 

[Shibanova]

Huh!?!? You're kidding right!?!? that's it really? That's it 19 chapters

Fucking Executioner-kun has given this the axe

Tho despite of that this was a nice ending to this wish there were more in between leading up to marriage but hey you get what you get

 

[Hadski]

Fucken promotional

 

[ShionVaynex]

So, what happened with the other harem member? There is no story about them at all. Much worse than Friends A and B.

I only read the second vol.

Spoiler: Spoilers.

next arc. A new girl, joins the frey.

 

[Airzpool]

that mean you must read light novel

Wait!? We have the light novel for this? Thanks. Will try to search and read

 

[BulbaCPG]

Oh. Axed... dnag...

 

[Grye]

wtf it just ends here?

 

[Aryanraj444]

We got axed in beautiful stories
But not in some rent a girlfriend 😕

 

[RakshaJaeger]

LN add, another one huh Well, from the spoiler I read in previous chapter’s comments, the best section has been adapted so maybe it’s for the best ?
From what I remember:

Spoiler: About the other 2 girls

the gal stays in love with the harem protagonist and kinda antagonizes our mc. Even after realizing that she was drawn to him because of his protagonists power. For the cf it’s different, in fact her relationship with mc was kinda awkward, even before the harem protagonist came in. They were not that close (also because mc was awkward himself, meek and all). They kinda reconciled but she doesn’t become a love interest.
About the imouto, at some point she fall in love with the harem protagonist again, and mc tries to help her with it… overall mc won’t evolve much, the rest of the story is basically him being insulted by the girls in love with the harem protagonist, some fluffy moments with fmc and that’s pretty much it

That’s all I can remember from the spoilers I read, maybe i remember wrong tho. Would love to have more spoilers if someone read it

 

[betetta]

Ok, a few details...

First this looks like it was the plan from the get go to just do 1 volume, you know? It fits nice and easy in 3 Manga volumes like many other LN promotional Manga I've read before that end in what a coincidence... 19 chapters.

Then, the wedding chapter has a few references to the future, one of them confirms that this follows LN Canon instead of WN canon (Yep, they're different) and a few cute details like in page 19 where Azusa calls shiho onee chan, that was a years long feud between them that started once they became best friends in vol 2.

Spoiler: Now spoilers for what didn't made the cut

VOL 2:

-new girl appears, her objective is to give ryuzaki the suffering he deserves.
- she seduces him and undermines the crushes the other girls had on him, the plan is once he had no girl to bounce back to, she would dump him and humiliate him.
-she tries to give MC back his whole harem plus shiho cause it would be fun mostly, MC thwarted her plans by having a face of with gyuaru/former library friend where he pretend to be a villain until she slaps him.
-shiho then faces new girl and says Mc is only hers (she would only allow Azusa because she is actually MC's sister but no one else, this was the first yandere-ish episode she had so far during the novel)
-in the end new girl gets defeated becuase from this supernatural charm, in the end she couldn't dump ryuzaki, she had fallen for him too.
-volume ends with gyaru girl getting part of her old identity back and moving on, even watching Mc and Shiho together and thinking she could have been there too if she wasn't so stupid before.

VOL 3:

-we get to know why MC is so passive, basically his mother's fault, we also get a lot of fluff with shiho's parents, sometimes they all feel like a big family with shiho and both nakayama siblings.
-ryuzaki loses his Mojo almost completely, then we understand how much his "protagonist" luck is based on his self confidence, we see a lot of his "outer harem" that includes like a dozen girls from upper classes and even the school nurse, fall out of love with him like flicking a switch, like it was an actual spell.
-the drama starts with an arranged marriage between the childhood friend and MC apparently it was settled years ago, but since both MC and the childhood friend have such passive personalities, she looks resigned to it, Mc decides he need to give ryuzaki back his confidence to make him go fight for her
-stuff happens, ryuzaki appears to try and break the engagement finally confessing to Yuzuki (mc's childhood friend) and... Gets rejected, but at least she also React enough to also reject the marriage.
-both gyaru and childhood friend meet with ryuzaki and decide to confess that they both still love him, now with more honest feeling, he decides to actually acknowledge them and asks for time to make a choice.

VOL 4: (light novel version, web novel version sucks)
-new girl appears, she was another childhood friend of MC but he thought she was a boy.
-she becomes a somewhat contender for the love of MC she is more direct and they begin spending more time together becuase of reasons. (note - until this point shiho and MC aren't a real couple yet, and you could say they've stagnated since he dotes too much on her almost like she was another little sister like Azusa)
-we get many flashbacks that basically reveal that new girl's grandpa is also shiho's grandpa, they're cousins, also Mc's mom had worked for grandpa or had some previous link, that's how they actually knew each other first than anyone else (remember the photo of both of them as babies in the Manga, that's the reference) so it was destiny.
-even after some botched confessions, there's no drama, triangle or NTR, not really, they just gain a cousin and good friend with new girl, ironically MC has three girls around him again, only different ones except for the sister who is the only one remaining from before.
-this volume also has a lot of slice of life sidechapters like onsen, sleepovers, etc.

VOL 5:

- it's basically a long epilogue, slice of life fluff, shiho ad MC finally become a couple for real and they go directly to engagement.
-there's a beach trip for MC and the three girls, it's supposed to be private but somehow there's a lot of people
-the crazy girl from second volume who now is a maid (don't ask) was the one trying to stir back some drama on the story, like triggering usual romantic comedy events to spice up things, even bringing ryuzaki and the other two former friends to maybe stir old feelings between everyone involved
-in the end MC and most of everyone else decide to leave the romantic comedy behind and simply go live a boring nice life, crazy girl cries and goes away, shiho and ryuzaki get their first honest talk ever, on the way home they stop to see the sky and then we get the 10 year timeskip to the wedding.
-Most characters attend, including Mc's distant parents and a cool young aunt he has, even ryuzaki and his two girls attend, actually right until the end it never gets confirmed if he ever picks one or even is in a relationship with any of them or both.

STUFF FROM THE WEB NOVEL:

-stuff that got changed for the light novel it was mostly for the better, to name an example, in the beginning Mc was constantly moping about the girls that left him, in the LN he's more detached... It is what it is.
-read the specials like Christmas or Halloween chapters, also there's a couple AU short stories like what if Mc and Shiho never met in high school that are nice, the best ones are the 19 years later chapters that come days or weeks before the wedding, those are amazing, specially one called "the last siblings fight"
-the WN is also dropping from time to time a few chapters about shiho and MCs life in college together

RELATIONSHIPS IN THE END:

MC obviously got his sister back, there are a lot of very cute moments between them during the story, I think they're better written tmeven than shiho and MC sometimes, with gyaru girl they become friends again but not close like before, shiho is scared of her for some reason, with the last girl, Mc and her basically come to the conclusion that they don't really like each other anymore.
Azusa moves on from ryuzaki, their was a small moment where she could have relapsed but she handled everything like a boss, new pink haired girl solved her brief crush with MC and simply stayed in a supporting role
MC and ryuzaki became constant "frenemies" sometimes even going to punches (at least once) and even having an honestly funny moment when he finally found out that all his girls had been MCs "hand me downs" (his words since he was in a very self loathing mood) but the guy actually had a lot of character growth even if he still was a jerk.

 

[Takane-Da]

Japan and axed. Name a better duo other than Japanese and Truck-kun.

 

[betetta]

LN add, another one huh Well, from the spoiler I read in previous chapter’s comments, the best section has been adapted so maybe it’s for the best ?
From what I remember:

Spoiler: About the other 2 girls

the gal stays in love with the harem protagonist and kinda antagonizes our mc. Even after realizing that she was drawn to him because of his protagonists power. For the cf it’s different, in fact her relationship with mc was kinda awkward, even before the harem protagonist came in. They were not that close (also because mc was awkward himself, meek and all). They kinda reconciled but she doesn’t become a love interest.
About the imouto, at some point she fall in love with the harem protagonist again, and mc tries to help her with it… overall mc won’t evolve much, the rest of the story is basically him being insulted by the girls in love with the harem protagonist, some fluffy moments with fmc and that’s pretty much it

That’s all I can remember from the spoilers I read, maybe i remember wrong tho. Would love to have more spoilers if someone read it

Spoiler: Not to be a jerk, just to refresh your memory

the gal and Mc have a fight because mc became a jerk to make her go back to her senses, they actually end in very good terms to the point ryuzaki gets a bit jealous of mc, the cf and Mc become acquaintances at best, because they represent the personality traits they hate the most from themselves, ironically shiho loves her because she reminds her of Mc.
Imouto almost falls again for ryuzaki but it was mc's fault, she asks her bro "should I try to go for him again? I'm not sure but I trust your judgement" and he says to go for him if that's what she wants, then at valentines they see esch other by chance and he approaches, she has chocolate to give but stops herself and tells him to stop confusing her, she feels spiritual support from Mc like he's stopping her hand from giving the chocolate and then she gets her final closure to that story, to his credit, ryuzaki let's her go too to not hurt her anymore.

 

[Bearman851]

Axe went down HARD on this one.

 

[Ash6702]

Honestly from the spoilers ive seen of the LN i think i prefer this

 

[Lunkli]

Sudden ending, but oh well, I guess. I'll just imagine all the hijinks these characters get up to as they rise to take their place among the pantheon, become the Heroes of Mangakoku they were always meant to be, and save the world from its imminent destruction by Nintendo DMCA'ing because it was actually a mod of Mario Galaxy all along. Godspeed, Heroes!

 

[colorlesseatstomboys]

Tbh I'm glad it was just an LN ad.
While reading the spoilers, it looks ok, but yeah reading the whole book and going through the frustrating parts 🫠

 

[blablablub]

Abrupt ending. But hey, ending with a wedding is much better than those that read like more is coming but there's no "to be continued" at the end.

 

[marzial09]

Ok, a few details...

First this looks like it was the plan from the get go to just do 1 volume, you know? It fits nice and easy in 3 Manga volumes like many other LN promotional Manga I've read before that end in what a coincidence... 19 chapters.

Then, the wedding chapter has a few references to the future, one of them confirms that this follows LN Canon instead of WN canon (Yep, they're different) and a few cute details like in page 19 where Azusa calls shiho onee chan, that was a years long feud between them that started once they became best friends in vol 2.

Spoiler: Now spoilers for what didn't made the cut

VOL 2:

-new girl appears, her objective is to give ryuzaki the suffering he deserves.
- she seduces him and undermines the crushes the other girls had on him, the plan is once he had no girl to bounce back to, she would dump him and humiliate him.
-she tries to give MC back his whole harem plus shiho cause it would be fun mostly, MC thwarted her plans by having a face of with gyuaru/former library friend where he pretend to be a villain until she slaps him.
-shiho then faces new girl and says Mc is only hers (she would only allow Azusa because she is actually MC's sister but no one else, this was the first yandere-ish episode she had so far during the novel)
-in the end new girl gets defeated becuase from this supernatural charm, in the end she couldn't dump ryuzaki, she had fallen for him too.
-volume ends with gyaru girl getting part of her old identity back and moving on, even watching Mc and Shiho together and thinking she could have been there too if she wasn't so stupid before.

VOL 3:

-we get to know why MC is so passive, basically his mother's fault, we also get a lot of fluff with shiho's parents, sometimes they all feel like a big family with shiho and both nakayama siblings.
-ryuzaki loses his Mojo almost completely, then we understand how much his "protagonist" luck is based on his self confidence, we see a lot of his "outer harem" that includes like a dozen girls from upper classes and even the school nurse, fall out of love with him like flicking a switch, like it was an actual spell.
-the drama starts with an arranged marriage between the childhood friend and MC apparently it was settled years ago, but since both MC and the childhood friend have such passive personalities, she looks resigned to it, Mc decides he need to give ryuzaki back his confidence to make him go fight for her
-stuff happens, ryuzaki appears to try and break the engagement finally confessing to Yuzuki (mc's childhood friend) and... Gets rejected, but at least she also React enough to also reject the marriage.
-both gyaru and childhood friend meet with ryuzaki and decide to confess that they both still love him, now with more honest feeling, he decides to actually acknowledge them and asks for time to make a choice.

VOL 4: (light novel version, web novel version sucks)
-new girl appears, she was another childhood friend of MC but he thought she was a boy.
-she becomes a somewhat contender for the love of MC she is more direct and they begin spending more time together becuase of reasons. (note - until this point shiho and MC aren't a real couple yet, and you could say they've stagnated since he dotes too much on her almost like she was another little sister like Azusa)
-we get many flashbacks that basically reveal that new girl's grandpa is also shiho's grandpa, they're cousins, also Mc's mom had worked for grandpa or had some previous link, that's how they actually knew each other first than anyone else (remember the photo of both of them as babies in the Manga, that's the reference) so it was destiny.
-even after some botched confessions, there's no drama, triangle or NTR, not really, they just gain a cousin and good friend with new girl, ironically MC has three girls around him again, only different ones except for the sister who is the only one remaining from before.
-this volume also has a lot of slice of life sidechapters like onsen, sleepovers, etc.

VOL 5:

- it's basically a long epilogue, slice of life fluff, shiho ad MC finally become a couple for real and they go directly to engagement.
-there's a beach trip for MC and the three girls, it's supposed to be private but somehow there's a lot of people
-the crazy girl from second volume who now is a maid (don't ask) was the one trying to stir back some drama on the story, like triggering usual romantic comedy events to spice up things, even bringing ryuzaki and the other two former friends to maybe stir old feelings between everyone involved
-in the end MC and most of everyone else decide to leave the romantic comedy behind and simply go live a boring nice life, crazy girl cries and goes away, shiho and ryuzaki get their first honest talk ever, on the way home they stop to see the sky and then we get the 10 year timeskip to the wedding.
-Most characters attend, including Mc's distant parents and a cool young aunt he has, even ryuzaki and his two girls attend, actually right until the end it never gets confirmed if he ever picks one or even is in a relationship with any of them or both.

STUFF FROM THE WEB NOVEL:

-stuff that got changed for the light novel it was mostly for the better, to name an example, in the beginning Mc was constantly moping about the girls that left him, in the LN he's more detached... It is what it is.
-read the specials like Christmas or Halloween chapters, also there's a couple AU short stories like what if Mc and Shiho never met in high school that are nice, the best ones are the 19 years later chapters that come days or weeks before the wedding, those are amazing, specially one called "the last siblings fight"
-the WN is also dropping from time to time a few chapters about shiho and MCs life in college together

RELATIONSHIPS IN THE END:

MC obviously got his sister back, there are a lot of very cute moments between them during the story, I think they're better written tmeven than shiho and MC sometimes, with gyaru girl they become friends again but not close like before, shiho is scared of her for some reason, with the last girl, Mc and her basically come to the conclusion that they don't really like each other anymore.
Azusa moves on from ryuzaki, their was a small moment where she could have relapsed but she handled everything like a boss, new pink haired girl solved her brief crush with MC and simply stayed in a supporting role
MC and ryuzaki became constant "frenemies" sometimes even going to punches (at least once) and even having an honestly funny moment when he finally found out that all his girls had been MCs "hand me downs" (his words since he was in a very self loathing mood) but the guy actually had a lot of character growth even if he still was a jerk.

That is some convulated BS that sounds a lot more like a drag

 

[FloorRoof]

That's a great ending, every axed manga should end like this. Imagine starting a new manga, reading a few chapters, nervous MC's about to offer his new friend to walk home together, then you turn the page to get jumpscared by a 'I pronounce you husband and wife', credits roll. Was this parent character even introduced before?