Sukiru "banbutsu Shihae" Ni Mezameta Ossan Wa, Dungeon De Seikei Wo Tateru Koto Ni Shimashita ~mushoku Kara Hajimeru Shihaisha Musou~ - Ch. 3

[MangaDex]

 

[razorshaleh]

powerfull ojisan, time grooming high school student ? looks like suitable to be your future wife

thank you for translating

 

[Solipsist]

So, teammates act as experience multiplier in this world?
Seems absurdly busted. Did I miss something, or is it the weird thing that nobody else does 100-man parties?
P.S: the mango was not very specific about the diff between slimes sharing xp, and teammates sharing em'.

 

[Varpie]

The math doesn't math up here. If he defeats a monster alone, like the goblins from previous chapter, he gets 100xp to share, but the others that haven't touched it wouldn't get that 100xp to share, right? So how does he end up with 400xp, and not just 100xp per monster? Even if we consider that all the slimes may gang up on one while he's busy with others, that's 300xp and they would be slower.

 

[Chebron]

This just gets more and more average with each chapter.
And of course we've got the dime a dozen, low self-esteem Japanese male mc who doesn't know much of anything despite being a grown ass middle aged man.

 

[JackdawMinuet]

Any of you would’ve yeeted tf out if she wasn’t a cute shoujo. I know I would’ve.

 

[074769]

Its not reckless, but naive... no idea why you people avoid this word so much.

 

[thelordofsticks]

The math doesn't math up here. If he defeats a monster alone, like the goblins from previous chapter, he gets 100xp to share, but the others that haven't touched it wouldn't get that 100xp to share, right? So how does he end up with 400xp, and not just 100xp per monster? Even if we consider that all the slimes may gang up on one while he's busy with others, that's 300xp and they would be slower.

The party acts like a pool of exp. Each goblin gives say 100 exp to every member of the party, each member adds that 100 to the parties pool. So a solo adventurer gets 100, a party of 2 gets 200 and so on. The MC is in a party with his slimes totalling 4 members, so thats 400 exp per goblin. Its also stated so long as your in the party you get full exp from the fight.

 

[Grikath]

Damsel-in-Dist(d?)ress with Tragic Heroine syndrome.... How....droll.....

 

[Jon]

The troll didn't even move lol what does she mean 'if only it stopped moving'
Bruh was just standing there relaxing after going for the grab.

 

[PLaci1982]

This lame edgy writing... How old is the author? 12??
And the mangaka follows up with this lame [every monster stands still and wait while somebody speaks] along with [the nameless NPCs instead of fleeing for they life, they monologue about how unbelievable the monster is, while standing still]...

I hate the author, nothing he writes can make me hate he more...

AT THIS AGE, I JUST GET EMOTIONAL EASILY...

...

 

[Varpie]

The party acts like a pool of exp. Each goblin gives say 100 exp to every member of the party, each member adds that 100 to the parties pool. So a solo adventurer gets 100, a party of 2 gets 200 and so on. The MC is in a party with his slimes totalling 4 members, so thats 400 exp per goblin. Its also stated so long as your in the party you get full exp from the fight.

But then the remote party guy getting 100xp doesn't make sense, if it's a party of 2 they should both get 200xp no matter who is active in the fight according to your explanation...

 

[SilentDan]

I think its supposed to be shared. Say 2 people kill a goblin. The exp goes is split up, with a party bonus.
But since all the slimes fight and the slimes are part of mc. Then he's getting more.
So instead of a beast master getting 100 split between his pets. Its 100 per pet, funneled back into the trainer, but then there's a high chance the pet will die so you'd have to start them again often. A smaller stat growth in exchange for a larger exp pool.

Could be wrong but that's how I see it.

 

[NeverAnother]

What the fuck is this exp system. It does not make sense. If you get exp per monster then that just means everyone involved gets the same exp. 100 by a monster means everyone gets 100. Why do the tamed monsters act as containers for exp? They should only be getting 100 because they are members of the party, or even as pets they get 100 because it’s not like the monster grants more exp. BUT on top of that now somehow the tamed monsters are acting as containers for exp AND sharing their contained exp with the other members of the party even though those members don’t own the tamed monsters? Even in this situation the other members of the party should be only getting 100 exp because that is what was established. For that matter how are the slimes leveling as well? Are they getting 4 times as much xp? That doubly makes no sense because if they are leveling they should only be getting the 100 already mentioned. If the manga goes into saying, “The slimes aren’t leveling up and are instead GIVING their exp to you” that might be ok but it still doesn’t help the ‘party wide’ effect unless they have something like ’sub-skill effects’ or some shit. Plus if that was the case then a bunch of level 1 slimes would still be weak as ever against other monsters and probably die off fast.

Yet in the first chapter we know they already understand the skill domination to only be controlling weak monsters, and it’s called a bad skill. So has literally NO ONE EVER TAMED 10 SLIMES AND LEVELED UP 10 TIMES AS FAST?!??! What the fuck happened to all the other adventurers who had this skill?!?!

 

[Kurovah]

The problem with a lot of these "useless skill is actually secretly busted" type dealos is that the way they are busted is usually in a way that is easily accessible to everyone else who has the skill. The only time this works is if:
A) The user has knowledge that others won't have (or metaknowledge in the case of Isekai and Reincarnation stories)
B) It's a skill that hasn't been seen before/ documented properly
C) The path to that build requires work so gruelling that most people won't bother

 

[Seinvolf]

Thank u always for ur great work...
^^...

The pacing seems weird...
(OωO`)...
The exp system seems working differently with his party...
(OωO`)...

 

[CountryMage]

Yet in the first chapter we know they already understand the skill domination to only be controlling weak monsters, and it’s called a bad skill. So has literally NO ONE EVER TAMED 10 SLIMES AND LEVELED UP 10 TIMES AS FAST?!??! What the fuck happened to all the other adventurers who had this skill?!?!

Domination is a low level skill, that has a low success rate against low level mobs; the MC has Domination of All Things, a unique skill as far as we know.

 

[ScryedParadox]

Why isn't the entire guild not just one singular gigantic party?
That way everyone in the guild constantly levels up, and all the adventurers inside the same dungeon acts as a positive experience modifier that also acts as a positive experience modifier to the adventurers not in the dungeon?
How is everyone not already max level just by casually joining the adventurer guild and upon doing so suddenly leveling up every other second?
Some critical limitation needs to be put into place immediately, such as party size limits that nobody was able to break until our MC with his skill suddenly came in.

 

[NeverAnother]

Domination is a low level skill, that has a low success rate against low level mobs; the MC has Domination of All Things, a unique skill as far as we know.

This does not change the fact of the exp sharing that is the major issue here. Why hasn’t someone tamed 10 slimes and leveled 10 times as fast? The writing on this either has to dig into or justify the depth of the skill or sufficiently leave room for worldbuilding that allows justification later. If there is a concept of skills that is available to be read off with its limits then why was the receptionist not able to read off what the MC’s skill was and see the difference? Do the skills have levels within themselves? As of right now nothing is supported or supporting itself.

 

[CountryMage]

This does not change the fact of the exp sharing that is the major issue here. Why hasn’t someone tamed 10 slimes and leveled 10 times as fast? The writing on this either has to dig into or justify the depth of the skill or sufficiently leave room for worldbuilding that allows justification later. If there is a concept of skills that is available to be read off with its limits then why was the receptionist not able to read off what the MC’s skill was and see the difference? Do the skills have levels within themselves? As of right now nothing is supported or supporting itself.

Low Success Rate
The skill they know about doesn't even work on slimes most of the time, MC's skill works on people, and probably even boss monsters. The receptionist wrote that skill off, thinking it was the common version of Domination.

Edit: If I had to guess, it will turn out that regular taming skills make the tamed monsters into equipment, so it just counts as the tamer making those kills, but the MC is Dominating his slimes, and probably those thugs from before, so they just give him their exp, and then as he get's stronger they get stronger.