The boys you knew during childhood were girls the entire time - Oneshot

[MangaDex]

 

[Remocracy]

This version is a bit more readable but still equally confusing

 

[Atifus]

Don't worry the Reddit Discussion Thread is just as confused..

 

[feha]

Don't worry the Reddit Discussion Thread is just as confused..

Seems they figured out that it's alternating POV's (though I am unsure how accurate that idea is):

• Mc met 6 boys she befriended
• 6 boys each (individually) met mc during a festival (so not at same time), but while they didn't remember her, she remembered them. MC wants harem and asks them to marry her when she grows up to be prettier
• mc (after growing up and becoming boyish) meets 6 girls who reveal to have been the boys she befriended and proposed to back then
• 6 girls has mc, the best friend character, say (in third person) that he will take care of them (in the marriage way, not the assassination one).

But it feels a bit off to me, feels like it's meant to be 1 mc 7 girls, where mc chooses seventh, and mangaka forgot that all side-characters don't share memory, so accidentally made all separate girls remember that "promise" as if they are the ones who made it.

 

[Atifus]

Seems they figured out that it's alternating POV's (though I am unsure how accurate that idea is):

• Mc met 6 boys she befriended
• 6 boys each (individually) met mc during a festival (so not at same time), but while they didn't remember her, she remembered them. MC wants harem and asks them to marry her when she grows up to be prettier
• mc (after growing up and becoming boyish) meets 6 girls who reveal to have been the boys she befriended and proposed to back then
• 6 girls has mc, the best friend character, say (in third person) that he will take care of them (in the marriage way, not the assassination one).

But it feels a bit off to me, feels like it's meant to be 1 mc 7 girls, where mc chooses seventh, and mangaka forgot that all side-characters don't share memory, so accidentally made all separate girls remember that "promise" as if they are the ones who made it.

At the festival part, it's pretty clear that he(?) made a promise with a girl.
Didn't remember that the main character was a girl as well?

How do you know the MC became boyish xd? this might just be a yuri fest..

The best friend is clearly a girl as well tho, I think the best friend, takahashi-sama, page is suppose to be the main character herself, in which it is revealed that the MC was a girl all along with the school name reveal (an all girls school, check the other tl) and the skirt, and her saying she'll take care of them/her(?) (one of the 6 girls or all of them) makes sense, also quite fitting the actual title of the manga "お前、女だったのか…!?" which tls to "Are you a girl...!?"

The FMC is prolly a playgirl and made a promise with all of them xd

also forgot to put this here, but the reddit SL Request thread has some good discussion as well...

 

[HolyOrdos]

Is that Nisekoi all over again? 🤣🤣🤣

 

[guyinachair]

Seems they figured out that it's alternating POV's (though I am unsure how accurate that idea is):

• Mc met 6 boys she befriended
• 6 boys each (individually) met mc during a festival (so not at same time), but while they didn't remember her, she remembered them. MC wants harem and asks them to marry her when she grows up to be prettier
• mc (after growing up and becoming boyish) meets 6 girls who reveal to have been the boys she befriended and proposed to back then
• 6 girls has mc, the best friend character, say (in third person) that he will take care of them (in the marriage way, not the assassination one).

But it feels a bit off to me, feels like it's meant to be 1 mc 7 girls, where mc chooses seventh, and mangaka forgot that all side-characters don't share memory, so accidentally made all separate girls remember that "promise" as if they are the ones who made it.

Doesn't seem that complicated to me. We're the point of view of the guy who met the 6 girls. One of them made a promise at the festival while dressed as a girl, so we can't tell which one. Then 10 years later, they all turn out to be girls but we don't know which one made the promise at the festival. The title splashes in the centers and bottom corner make things simpler. 4th page is just an unrelated side story of a friend route.

 

[Fuhgeddaboudit]

A friend is fine too.