This is honestly really interesting, because if you re-read the start of chapter 1 Pye doesn't even cry when her original Little Star Witch dies, and Rylie's shock implies that it might have been either her or Pye that drowned her. There's a lot going on in those dynamics (and with Pye in general) that has yet to be revealed, and I can't wait for it to happen. Super great series! Thanks for the update!