Yumenashi-sensei no Shinroshidou

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 30, 2023
Messages
1,169
Okay, all and every jokes aside, I was skimming through the first 3 chapters (the only ones out) and this actually seems really good. I'm legitimately going to come back to actually read this in a different mindset so I can take everything in.
 
Joined
Sep 3, 2023
Messages
1
Currently I have read up to the fifth chapter and it's really great. While some part may seems dark and sad in truth it end up being used for a good reason and great story telling. The drawing is great and the characters are interesting albeit of short presence (other than the main character, they stay for two to three chapters)
 
Joined
Jun 11, 2024
Messages
4
learning from it, very good artwork and story it just hits too raw with some of the situations, great manga
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 15, 2021
Messages
1,497
I think this stuff is creepy...
This guy's career advice led her to sell her body to make ends meet to pursue her dream, this is just rendering the word "dream" cursed for me and making the guy look bad for trying to help her, when she made the decisions anyway.
Did you really have to link career failure to selling your body to your superiors ? She didn't even fail before doing that, she had time to change things around, but I guess author just wanted to talk about broken people ?
I don't mind that, I'm just not in the targeted demografic and I honestly personnaly don't know much people that are part of it.

I felt quite unconfortable, I trust author is going to give me a bandaid later on to make me feel better just to give me another dose of irritation like this and as I don't read because I enjoy being uncomfortable, I won't continue further.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jun 17, 2024
Messages
5
I think this stuff is creepy...
This guy's career advice led her to sell her body to make ends meet to pursue her dream, this is just rendering the word "dream" cursed for me and making the guy look bad for trying to help her, when she made the decisions anyway.
Did you really have to link career failure to selling your body to your superiors ? She didn't even fail before doing that, she had time to change things around, but I guess author just wanted to talk about broken people ?
I don't mind that, I'm just not in the targeted demografic and I honestly personnaly don't know much people that are part of it.

I felt quite unconfortable, I trust author is going to give me a bandaid later on to make me feel better just to give me another dose of irritation like this and as I don't read because I enjoy being uncomfortable, I won't continue further.
Tbh, i failed to understand how you came to the conclusion that "This guy's career advice led her to sell her body to make ends meet to pursue her dream".
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 15, 2021
Messages
1,497
Tbh, i failed to understand how you came to the conclusion that "This guy's career advice led her to sell her body to make ends meet to pursue her dream".
I put this into spoilers to not spoil, but anyway
In the same sentence you quoted, I also said this :
making the guy look bad for trying to help her, when she made the decisions anyway.

Writing this story by placing the teacher's counseling just before the girl's failed carrer choice leads me to think he should have done a better job, even though he did all he could.
Except him, parents could have helped the girl, but we don't see them do that except when they congratulated her on her success, so the blame falls on teacher alone even though it's not his fault.

I can't blame the child for what she did, I could only blame the lack of support she recieved while studying, working, and since only teacher procured advice, the blame falls on him when it shouldn't, like I said.
Author chose to write that way and it feels fabricated and not like a real story, although this could happen irl, I can't relate to it.

On the other hand, the girl resorting to selling her body when she wasn't in debt and didn't need a big amount of money to survive and do a retraining makes absolutely no sense to me, I won't even blame her or any character but will blame author's writing skills for this.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top