Kumo Desu ga, Nani ka? - Ch. 74.1

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 28, 2018
Messages
2,206
Yeah thats my point man, she now has these godly abilities that she can "unlock" freely now. Again, whats stopping the author to say "yeah she can warp reality even more now lol, she unlocked it beacuse shes a badass god now". This is like shigaraki problem again. "oh, yeah I actually have absorbed a quirk like 5 months ago that can specifically counter your quirk, sorry man". Or the heian era sukuna problem. Theres no limitation now and the author can lazily let her unlock abilities instead of being bound by the limitation of the system. The system was a really cool way of limiting her, now shes just another isekai power fantasy character.
the difference, is that we already know what abilities she can have, because she used them before she became a god, she could teleport before already
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
May 3, 2018
Messages
821
And here I thought the people moaning about her having no powers was bad.

The story is still about Kumoko being put against the wall and must always suffer under various circumstances, not specifically a super powered spider that had magic. I've probably said this a dozen times in previous chapters, but people reading for the wrong reasons should probably take a hike rather than take it out on the series.

The current part of the story is fairly mild compared to before and after this point. But this was supposed to be:
  • Suffer as a spider that needs to speedrun the game or get squished.
  • Suffer as a new God who doesn't have her cheat codes anymore and has no idea how to be a God.
  • Suffer as a God who now has to deal with world-ending problems Gods can't solve and hopeless people she can't fix.
  • Suffer as [redacted].

I hope certain people can see the common theme here.
It's way less of "Suffering as" and more of "Doesn't know how to enjoy life" kind of story. Her whole thing is about a spider who craves for attention and joy but has absolutely no idea how to get them
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2023
Messages
7,689
Oni looks mean.

Such a change when she can't even use Appraisal-sama by herself.

Shiro is envious of Envy.

Teleport is OP.

"I have the 'Pride'..."
I forgot how it was, but does that count even if she's outside the system now?

only 5km? those are rookie numbers
Eh, she can just do it again if need be.
 
Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Dec 14, 2023
Messages
24
Every time Kumoko/Shiro/White has called herself OP and unbeatable, the narrative has found a way to humble her.

Escaped from the Laberinth as a Legendary tier monster? Now Mother is after her.

Finally managed to outmaneuvered Mother? Ariel casually vaporizes her.

Manages to get a countermeasure against Ariel? Potimas and his anti-magic terminators almost kills her.

She is OP until the moment a bigger fish is introduced in the story, and there is always a bigger fish.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 29, 2018
Messages
441
Yeah thats my point man, she now has these godly abilities that she can "unlock" freely now. Again, whats stopping the author to say "yeah she can warp reality even more now lol, she unlocked it beacuse shes a badass god now". This is like shigaraki problem again. "oh, yeah I actually have absorbed a quirk like 5 months ago that can specifically counter your quirk, sorry man". Or the heian era sukuna problem. Theres no limitation now and the author can lazily let her unlock abilities instead of being bound by the limitation of the system. The system was a really cool way of limiting her, now shes just another isekai power fantasy character.
Pray tell me which godly abilities she can "unlock freely"? There's no a catalogue of fancy god power that she can browse and learn at will. There's also no textbook "HOW TO BE GOD 101" to instruct her what to do, nor a mentor figure who teaches her the way. So far she only replicated the old skills she had before, because she already experienced how they work. Crafting an entirely new skill with zero reference is still far beyond her ability now.

The "cool" system that you're praising is literally the laziest shit an author can come up with. Need more skill? Check the skill catalogue and buy it. Planning evolution route? Read catalogue again. The only limit is whether she had enough skill point/EXP or not, which can be solved by massacre everything on her way.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 18, 2018
Messages
197
Pray tell me which godly abilities she can "unlock freely"? There's no a catalogue of fancy god power that she can browse and learn at will. There's also no textbook "HOW TO BE GOD 101" to instruct her what to do, nor a mentor figure who teaches her the way. So far she only replicated the old skills she had before, because she already experienced how they work. Crafting an entirely new skill with zero reference is still far beyond her ability now.

The "cool" system that you're praising is literally the laziest shit an author can come up with. Need more skill? Check the skill catalogue and buy it. Planning evolution route? Read catalogue again. The only limit is whether she had enough skill point/EXP or not, which can be solved by massacre everything on her way.
She literally teleported her enemy to the fucking stratosphere this chapter??? No foreshadowing, no training, mo anything. The author just put an arbitrary limit on her of "unlocking a portion of her power" Just fucking say "yeah she unlocked everything. She didn't even theorycraft it, she just did it
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 10, 2023
Messages
1,044
She literally teleported her enemy to the fucking stratosphere this chapter??? No foreshadowing, no training, mo anything. The author just put an arbitrary limit on her of "unlocking a portion of her power" Just fucking say "yeah she unlocked everything. She didn't even theorycraft it, she just did it
Mate, she's been able to teleport for awhile now. What in hells are you on about!? She literally teleported HERSELF across the damn world to the dungeon she started just one chapter ago. And even THAT was something she could already do when she was just a spider. Why the hell is her teleporting someone straight up blowing your mind!?

Foreshadowing: It's a spell she already knew! And her goal is to regain the use of those abilities and spells. Are you fucking serious!?
Training: She's learning how to manually do what she could automatically do. It's more of a puzzle she has to piece together than some skill she has to discover and unlock.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 9, 2020
Messages
382
Mate, she's been able to teleport for awhile now. What in hells are you on about!? She literally teleported HERSELF across the damn world to the dungeon she started just one chapter ago. And even THAT was something she could already do when she was just a spider. Why the hell is her teleporting someone straight up blowing your mind!?

Foreshadowing: It's a spell she already knew! And her goal is to regain the use of those abilities and spells. Are you fucking serious!?
Training: She's learning how to manually do what she could automatically do. It's more of a puzzle she has to piece together than some skill she has to discover and unlock.
I don't think the criticism is a lack of foreshadowing. I think the criticism is that it's going to undermine tension in unsatisfying ways. Yes, she could always make threads, but suddenly pulling out her old powers as the plot needs them to instantly resolve whatever conflict is happening at the time feels like cheap writing, especially if it happens repeatedly. It makes her victories feel unearned.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jul 8, 2018
Messages
850
5 km is enough for people to think about what they have done on the way down lol
Some are overcome by a whirlwind of thoughts: "What's happening?", "Who am I?", "Why am I here?", "What's my purpose in life?"
while others have just a singular peculiar train of thought.
Most notably a bowl of petunias, as it fell, once thought "Oh no, not again!"
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top