Isekai ni Kita Mitai dakedo Dou Sureba Yoi no Darou: Shachiku SE no My Pace Boukenki - Vol. 4 Ch. 21

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 23, 2024
Messages
933
While I agree with most of your thoughts, I'm not as sure the leadership of the village would believe they are truely warranted. As stated previously there are only a few hundred goblins that attack at a specific time of year. And until now the yearly attacks have been adequately handled.

Most right thinking individuals from our world would have made effort to put up barriers and create choke points. But this culture is more passive by divine mandate. So there in lies the reasoning. The losses incurred during a once a year migration of monsters hasn't overcome their ingrained pacifistic tendencies. Rather they have created a reactionary centralized force that can respond on an ass needed basis.

Is it the smart way to handle the situation? Not at all. It's only how this culture of less war like people would handle the situation.
But how are you going to set up those "barriers and chokepoints"? It's not like they are going to always be attacked from one direction, the settlement is surrounded by wilderness, mostly forest. The actual medieval solution to this is building a fortress. :dogkek:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Oct 12, 2023
Messages
543
The problem here is that this is a lot of work and you'd need to know exactly where to set this up well in advance, or it could easily become a double-edged sword. Notice that they only knew a day or so in advance where exactly to meet the advancing goblins and picked a spot far enough from the village so that stragglers don't just break through and immediately attack it. As for defense, no it could at most be an impediment, hopefully to the attackers only.


What kind of "finance-free" options would that be? Even if they use timber, it's going to require more of it than the entire village can supply. Same for labour and someone needs to know what they are doing. You can't just build a simple wall or palisade and call it a day - that's useless for such a scenario. Fortifications WILL be breached when stormed with overwhelming numbers, their job is to allow the defenders to do a lot of damage to the enemy force with relative safety and hopefully keep them at bay. They are going to need places to shoot from with good cover and as previously pointed out, a lot of men to take those positions and swap out with others. So other than building and maintaining this kind of extensive system, you'd be turning most, if not all the village residents into a standing garrison if you don't provide you own - even if you ignore the difficulty of training and supplying them with weapons and provisions, who's going to run the village? It's not a weekend job. If it were, every medieval village would "protect what's theirs" this way, since they all faced the threat of raids from either bandits, mercenary bands or enemy armies.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top