Kyokuhoku no Geroy ~8-gatsu 17-nichi no Kaisen~ - Ch. 16 - Reconnaissance

Aggregator gang
Joined
Dec 7, 2023
Messages
32
I always have the same problem with most manga about Japan (or USSR) in WWII - Imperial army is displayed as those hard-boiled, philosophical guys who just want to serve their country and go back home to their parents and their sweetheart. I'm not saying every ch. should start with the MC saying "what we did in Nanking was bad, sorry", but they were the far East equivalent of Wermaht after all, not some good guys.
 
Active member
Joined
Jul 14, 2025
Messages
19
I always have the same problem with most manga about Japan (or USSR) in WWII - Imperial army is displayed as those hard-boiled, philosophical guys who just want to serve their country and go back home to their parents and their sweetheart. I'm not saying every ch. should start with the MC saying "what we did in Nanking was bad, sorry", but they were the far East equivalent of Wermaht after all, not some good guys.
While this is true, in my opinion there should still be some consideration of the topic/characters specifics of the story. Especially here, where you are intentionally dealing with (mostly) 16-19 y/o who truly have never seen any sort of combat, tucked away at the far most reaches of Japan, fighting a war that is post all the horrors that Japan committed in WWII and before.

That's not to acquit the Mangaka of any wrong-doing/propaganda, there are clear elements of it in the story and the way it is presented. But it's also, for a Japanese manga, does tackle the for-lack-of-a-better-word brainwashing that Imperial Japan did to it's citizens pretty well. And it doesn't glorify it, in my opinion, but tells you the story of those that were afflicted by it from their world-shattering perspective.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top