Anta to Osananajimitte dake demo Iyananoni! ~Zekkou kara Hajimaru S-kyuu Bishoujo to no Gakuen Nariagari Seikatsu~ - Ch. 4

Contributor
Joined
Oct 6, 2024
Messages
208
Good job, young man. Ur proof of how important picking the right person can be:chad:
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 30, 2025
Messages
101
I would love this manga if the dude isn't just a Gary Stu. It makes conflicts and issues feel cheap because they can just be solved by his plot armor. And we literally have no indicator that he's secretly this owerpowered hyperintelligent MC this whole time nor have any sensible explanation. What's next, he's gonna hack the entire Youtube backend to manipulate the algorithm so that his Oshi gets viral?

The premise is actually good, but it just doesn't work at all when the MC's that bland, brooding and OP. Remake Your Life anime criticized this trope where him doing everything and solving everything for the people he cared about leads to them being complacent, dependent and leaving no room nor incentive to grow. Leading to a future where all of them, except him, did not succeed.

Though with this manga being based on the light novel and the MC on that light novel is pretty uninteresting, I doubt they're going to change it. But what do I know, I'm just a manga reader. Probably the only reason this gets high ratings is that it's satisfying for the readers to shit on the rich bitch FML without a care for the quality of writing or the plot.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 16, 2020
Messages
101
Gawdam girl settle down
She jumped him at the first possible moment lol
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 20, 2018
Messages
3,387
So, this girl is cuter, prettier, bustier, and has a much personality. Rich girl childhood friend has already lost, and that's without counting the years of abuse.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 10, 2025
Messages
361
hmmmm
Pretty ok story at the moment
Hope it gets more interesting
In my opinion the story would be better if he just does his own thing without managing new idols.

Also seriously, adding being able to beat up a whole force of trained security guard to the list of mc power kind of redundant no?
What’s next, he be able to hack government database (ngl this kinda seems plausible lul )
:lul:
Yeah thats one of the more disappointing aspects of this story in that MC is just super ultra capable and never has to work to be better.

But I will say it is quite cathartic watching rua’s downfall.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 20, 2019
Messages
333
I would love this manga if the dude isn't just a Gary Stu. It makes conflicts and issues feel cheap because they can just be solved by his plot armor. And we literally have no indicator that he's secretly this owerpowered hyperintelligent MC this whole time nor have any sensible explanation. What's next, he's gonna hack the entire Youtube backend to manipulate the algorithm so that his Oshi gets viral?
"literally no indicator"..

Yep, none at all apart from him being established as super human in every regard by showcasing his monstrous strength when breaking the massive table, him being acknowledged as super smart and mature by important people, having exceptional management skills, being well versed in fighting as her main bodyguard etc.
We are only 4 chapters deep, plenty of space for some backstory and reveals.

I do agree that him being THIS op is pretty tricky but I thought Amane was more of a problem being kinda flat and I am unsure where the author is taking this. But it is fun and I enjoy him actually pulling through with the revenge.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 20, 2020
Messages
3,384
I would love this manga if the dude isn't just a Gary Stu. It makes conflicts and issues feel cheap because they can just be solved by his plot armor. And we literally have no indicator that he's secretly this owerpowered hyperintelligent MC this whole time nor have any sensible explanation. What's next, he's gonna hack the entire Youtube backend to manipulate the algorithm so that his Oshi gets viral?

The premise is actually good, but it just doesn't work at all when the MC's that bland, brooding and OP. Remake Your Life anime criticized this trope where him doing everything and solving everything for the people he cared about leads to them being complacent, dependent and leaving no room nor incentive to grow. Leading to a future where all of them, except him, did not succeed.

Though with this manga being based on the light novel and the MC on that light novel is pretty uninteresting, I doubt they're going to change it. But what do I know, I'm just a manga reader. Probably the only reason this gets high ratings is that it's satisfying for the readers to shit on the rich bitch FML without a care for the quality of writing or the plot.
Agreed. I wouldn't be surprised if he was a secret agent next chapter. Also it would be better if the rich girl wasn't so one dimensional as she's just there to be dumped on. No nuance to her character whatsoever. Pretty much this is just a basic wish fulfillment fantasy series.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 10, 2025
Messages
361
I would love this manga if the dude isn't just a Gary Stu. It makes conflicts and issues feel cheap because they can just be solved by his plot armor. And we literally have no indicator that he's secretly this owerpowered hyperintelligent MC this whole time nor have any sensible explanation. What's next, he's gonna hack the entire Youtube backend to manipulate the algorithm so that his Oshi gets viral?

The premise is actually good, but it just doesn't work at all when the MC's that bland, brooding and OP. Remake Your Life anime criticized this trope where him doing everything and solving everything for the people he cared about leads to them being complacent, dependent and leaving no room nor incentive to grow. Leading to a future where all of them, except him, did not succeed.

Though with this manga being based on the light novel and the MC on that light novel is pretty uninteresting, I doubt they're going to change it. But what do I know, I'm just a manga reader. Probably the only reason this gets high ratings is that it's satisfying for the readers to shit on the rich bitch FML without a care for the quality of writing or the plot.
Yeah I see what you mean. Tbh this is “a kicked out of the hero’s party” with a different coat of paint to seem fresh and new.

“Rua” is the typical irredeemable hero who everyone just adores but is actually really incompetent now that protag has left and ends up hated by everyone.

“MC” is typical leaves hero’s party and realizes he’s actually super OP and the hero was only holding him back.

“Amane” is one of the token girls who are helped by the kind MC and falls for him eventually ending up in MC’s harem.

Replace defeating the demon lord with making a successful idol group and you have the full package.

Tbh I hope it isn’t just this and actually shakes up the character interactions but the story really feels like its heading into a bland harem where Rua just pouts for several chapters before either A. Her life is ruined or B. She finally breaks down and is accepted into MC’s harem. (The story seems like its going towards option A)
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 13, 2025
Messages
608
The first step for his revenge :chad:

Curious to see how low he will bring Piggy down !!
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 1, 2019
Messages
122
Yeah... let's just stop the manga right here, and forget about the other 3 girls in the manga cover, Amane is more than enough and Kazuma better end up with her.
Yup, the story can handle one more chapter as an epilogue and then I fear it will just be downhill from there. Also, the teenager taking on an army of adult thugs without breaking a sweat shouldn't be handwaved, that was just som bad writing.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 29, 2018
Messages
198
Rofl, I honestly can't help but feel kinda bad for the rich girl. She's emotionally stunted and damaged from her upbringing in her own way (not that it isn't also her fault what's going on).

She was stuck in kindergarten bullying her crush because she was so emotionally immature, and a more mature acting girl pounced, f.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 8, 2023
Messages
1,184
Also seriously, adding being able to beat up a whole force of trained security guard to the list of mc power kind of redundant no?
What’s next, he be able to hack government database (ngl this kinda seems plausible lul )
:lul:
I mean... the author did glaze him so hard when having Rua's family talk about him. Stuff like how he was meant to be her husband and therefore trained to be able to protect her, how the guy was actively pretending to be average as to not overshadow Rua. That if he were to get serious he could easily be topping the charts with his grade and disrupt the country, maybe even the world.

So if a chapter comes around where he has to hack something I won't at all be surprised.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top