Eiyuu to Majo no Tensei Romcom - Ch. 34

[Hikarie]

welp the story is turned into a generic romance so that's why it got axed I guess, it got me curious when they introduced a hero and witch being reincarnated into another world but the author barely touches that and it turns into a typical school romance, like what is the point of introducing them as an isekai character if all we see is them living a normal school life and I think Finn is the one who is supposed to get the fantasy stuff going but she barely have any appearance.

 

[Lucas852m]

This shit was so ass

 

[Zhangar]

MEDIOCRE

 

[Schmucklet]

Really liked the idea, was disappointed to see it it become reincarnated girl of the week, and along came axe-kun.

It's triggering my writer's senses and making me wish I was besties with an artist, because I'd do it right, I'd do it my way, with hookers and blackjack, connecting all the dots, sorting out all the luggage from the past lives, and ending with a relaxed happy "and they were real sweet with each other ever after". /rant

 

[Telesto44]

I would have taken a generic romance, instead this devolved into harem slop where the main girl is the one we get the least.

 

[S0LUS]

I thought this was supposed to be a rom-com
the rom was shit and the com was nowhere to be found
series got 3x the chapter count it deserved and i feel bad for the artist to have a poorly-rated trainwreck like this as their first(?)/only(?)* published manga when the art was the only redeeming factor in the end lmao

*at least according to what's been put on mangadex, idk; imo it's almost worse if they've done more & this was the only series any scanlator decided was worthy of picking up, lol- like they deliberately only choose terrible stories to draw & this was the least terrible one so far or something

 

[Cirrius]

Feels like it was axed but, thx for the journey, see you in the other panel guys 👋👋

 

[SpiffSpeaks]

That was...disappointing.
Personally I feel it was trying too hard to be a romantic comedy rather than just being a romance.
Still, we at least got an ending so that's better than getting smacked the face with a trout.

---

Thanks for all the chapters and hard work.

 

[dcdfvr]

A mess that is all

 

[aka_randomhero]

This is how I feel. Man was the beginning fun but kind of fell asleep on itself real quick.
View attachment 41994

Ahh a Chris broad fan. I see you are person of great culture

 

[Reisen]

It is a light novel adaptation however the light novel ended at volume 2, you can even read it here.

I know it's an adaptation, I was talking about if it's or not a manga that was made just to promote the novel.

 

[ClothoBuer]

What an absolute garbage bag of an ending. The art kept the series interesting but I will not miss reading this at all.

 

[AzrefReza]

What a gigantic pile of crap…

 

[ArroganzSensei]

 

[breadhub]

cool axe
made the manga a 4/10
bye

eh it was a 4/10 the entire time, the ending only made it 3/10

 

[kngpjn]

Very sad. The premise is really good at the start. I really waiting for the new chapter. But somehow it got lost the direction at the middle. And then I was found out that the manga plot going into another direction from the novel. I was like, "damn this is s h i t". But anyway, thanks for translating until the end. I will give this manga 10/10 for the first half and 5/10 for second half.

 

[legendaryswordsman]

Huh, what? Can someone tell me what was suppose to happen before this got axed

Yeah same here it felt like a rushed ending even the chapter felt short

 

[legendaryswordsman]

That was basically more than 4 chapters crammed into 1 & called an ending but it lacked any satisfaction to it... I see this is an adaption but if this is how to promote the source material, then failed in all aspects. Hope the artist manages to find something new to draw since they deserve better than this. Thanks for translating this to completion.

It definitely lacks satisfaction, how different is the novel end part

 

[legendaryswordsman]

cool axe
made the manga a 4/10
bye

I think the first half of the series was very good but after it got to the point where he chose the main girl which we all knew he would he got very boring and seemed to rush towards end

 

[legendaryswordsman]

No surprise it was axed, it has an interesting start but fell off quick.
I stopped reading in the first 15 chapters and I'm glad I did since judging by this last chapter it definitely didn't get any better

I loved the first half the 2nd half I don't know felt forced, not earned and a bit to predictable