Imasara desuga, Osananajimi o Suki ni Natteshimaimashita - Ch. 50 - Six Hours, Just The Two Of Them (First Half)

[MarcoMook]

Its funny seeing people so up in arms and vitriolic about a girl who kissed her best friend's crush at a school festival. Like thats such high school drama shit Im shocked people take it so seriously. I can understand why the characters take it seriously cuz theyre high schoolers but I feel like for all their whining about being terrible awful people everyone in this Manga is just guilty of being 17.

The character is written well enough where they strike a very frustrated cord with some people. For example, I know a person that had a rough upbringing, acted like a friend as they got better, then acted like a total asshole out of left field. I forgive this person, thinking it was just bad decision making, and they did it again. It strikes a cord and I imagine other people here feel the same way. And regarding the "people take it so seriously", yes, people tend to get invested in stories they're reading. Heaven forbid you're into the story you're reading.

As I said, all that illegal teenage sex in love hotels messed with their heads.

You're more obsessed with the underaged sex aspect than anyone else here, and it's getting creepy.

 

[Greinhmorf]

Who the fuck is Ned? (Typo on page 5)

Probably a misspelling mistake while writing the word "end"

 

[peortega1]

Is it normal 17yo behaviour to try and get a classmate raped by a client?

That moment just proves Yami's irresponsibility. She genuinely believed she could easily scare the customer off and that it would be nothing more than a "prank." She got lucky, but she played with fire. Again.

You're more obsessed with the underaged sex aspect than anyone else here, and it's getting creepy.

As I said, I can easily understand if you find Yami's character unlikeable or disagreeable. That's fine. But given the way she's being discussed here, and also Yuu, for what was nothing more than a typical teenage romance, the only explanation I can find is precisely that. Teenage sex, and even more so in love hotels —that is, violating the Japanese laws.
Because outside of that context, there's no reason for so much hatred towards both characters, Yuu and Yami, when they haven't even committed formal infidelity.
Even more so seeing how harshly Yuu is judged here for the mere fact of having tried to date another girl to get over the fact that Hikari friend-zoned him. We can argue endlessly about whether he was more or less passive, but the basic facts are undeniable because Hikari herself confirmed them. She didn't see Yuu as a boy during the first-year of high school. Period.
Although, well, with him it does apply that you don't like the role reversal-female domination or seeing Yuu act literally like the girl in the relationship who is pegged by Yami

 

[MarcoMook]

As I said, I can easily understand if you find Yami's character unlikeable or disagreeable. That's fine. But given the way she's being discussed here, and also Yuu, for what was nothing more than a typical teenage romance, the only explanation I can find is precisely that. Teenage sex, and even more so in love hotels —that is, violating the Japanese laws . . . Although, well, with him it does apply that you don't like the role reversal-female domination or seeing Yuu act literally like the girl in the relationship who is pegged by Yami

It's like you refuse to believe people can dislike a person for acting horribly towards other people.

And again, your examples and beliefs revolve around underage sex, you mentioned NTR earlier, and now you're talking about Yuu being effeminate and being pegged. This level of projection is fucking weird.

 

[peortega1]

It's like you refuse to believe people can dislike a person for acting horribly towards other people.

False. I'm saying it's fine if you dislike Yami and she really has done bad things and she really needs therapy. But that's no reason to talk about her in such harsh terms. Anyone would think Yami killed or raped someone, judging by the terms everyone here uses to refer to her. Like I said, it's fine if you don't like Yami, but to call her, for example, "trash"...
Again, as @Yotomoe said it:

Its funny seeing people so up in arms and vitriolic about a girl who kissed her best friend's crush at a school festival. Like thats such high school drama shit Im shocked people take it so seriously. I can understand why the characters take it seriously cuz theyre high schoolers but I feel like for all their whining about being terrible awful people everyone in this Manga is just guilty of being 17.

Mangadex is about to start celebrating if Yami decides to attempt suicide.

And again, your examples and beliefs revolve around underage sex

That's why, I repeat, I'm returning to the topic of teenage sex, because I can't think of any other explanation for such harsh terms used against Yami and especially Yuu, and for everyone here hoping that Hikari will never speak to Yuu again in her life.
As I said, I have the feeling that if Yami and Yuu's relationship had been the typical teenage romance of holding hands and kissing on dates (which is probably what Hikari thought about Yuu's relationship with his ex-girlfriend, by the way), people here wouldn't be complaining nearly as much about them.

you mentioned NTR earlier, and now you're talking about Yuu being effeminate and being pegged. This level of projection is fucking weird.

I only mentioned NTR because everyone here has been repeating that label over and over again. Or are you going to say I made it up? That's why I talked about when the same author of this work has actually created true NTR works (White Album 2 Coda Normal End) and compared them to Imasara.
Regarding Yuu, it's obvious I'm being sarcastic, Sheldon. But I did say that his relationship with Yami is based on role reversal, that this is important to understand their bond (and yes, that's where that weird chapter where Yami and Hikari cross-dress as men comes from; Maruto has been anything but subtle), and that's why Yuu's character is so disliked here, because of his passive and submissive personality (which, again, isn't a bad thing; it's fine if you don't like it, but it's not inherently bad). This is why many here label him as effeminate (and I have verbatim comments to prove it), even though he isn't.

 

[AzrefReza]

“She hot, though…”

 

[EchoGirl]

@vipguy64 page 10, don't think it needs "a" before scum versus saying 'a scumbag'

wonder how hikari's feeling, assuming she knows Yuu's meeting her, considering Christmas is basically a 'couples day' or so in JP

Someone should post it on twitter, @ the writer and see how they react

 

[vipguy64]

@vipguy64 page 10, don't think it needs "a" before scum versus saying 'a scumbag'

wonder how hikari's feeling, assuming she knows Yuu's meeting her, considering Christmas is basically a 'couples day' or so in JP



Someone should post it on twitter, @ the writer and see how they react

https://forums.mangadex.org/threads...-two-of-them-first-half.2662044/post-30251370

 

[John_Smith10]

"Getting shitty about him having an ex" is an interesting way to describe being rightfully angry when the guy who tells you he's always loved you was making out with said ex an hour earlier. And even if Yami initiated the kiss he certainly didn't resist in the slightest and was literally the one clinging to her trying to get her new contact info while Yami was the one trying to end things properly, ironically. Plus, if the ex was some random girl it might be "none of her business," but if it's her best friend it becomes a bit more relevant to her.

Also saying Yuu is the one who had courage is kinda insane when he didn't confess or even do anything for YEARS (even if at the time he had no shot he absolutely could have been less passive) while Hikari was going to confess that day, only a few months at most after developing feelings. And the only reason Yuu did confess is that they had pretty much confirmed their feelings already and he was sure to get a positive response (until Hikari saw him making out with someone else and then act like absolutely nothing happened).

Yami and Yuu defenders have to bend reality to justify their oshis being dogshit characters

 

[John_Smith10]

So even after confessing to Hikari, he's STILL wishy wishy?

Lol.
Lmao, even.

He and Yami are garbage in every sense of the word.

I'd say they deserve each other, but watching them be happy after all of this makes me want to vomit.

Hikari would be better off without this gutter trash of a childhood friend/crush and friend.

With loved ones like that, who needs enemies?

 

[peortega1]

So even after confessing to Hikari, he's STILL wishy wishy?
Lol. Lmao, even.
He and Yami are garbage in every sense of the word.
I'd say they deserve each other, but watching them be happy after all of this makes me want to vomit.
Hikari would be better off without this gutter trash of a childhood friend/crush and friend.

Without her, this re-meeting never would have happened. So, Hikari is precisely who wants see this. Anyway, we don´t know about the current relationship of Yuu and Hikari in this moment.
The polycule route is more probable than ever.
PD. And of course, as everyone said here, Yuu was securely writing to Hikari about the encounter while he was talking with Yami.
PD2. The boy can take decisions and admit he still has feelings for Yami even if he chooses Hikari over her in this moment. This scenary doesn´t make him "wishy wishy".