Genkaigoe no Skill wa, Tenseisha ni Shika Atsukaenai - Over Limit Skill Holder - Ch. 47

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 6, 2019
Messages
3,248
so she's not actually mute just enchanted/cursed to be mute so she doesn't breathe fire? i get sending her away from the forest but why mute her after that? she should have had a tutor sent with her and then spent her time abroad mastering her voice magic so she doesn't burn the forest then return
 
Contributor
Joined
Feb 4, 2019
Messages
9,450
so she's not actually mute just enchanted/cursed to be mute so she doesn't breathe fire? i get sending her away from the forest but why mute her after that? she should have had a tutor sent with her and then spent her time abroad mastering her voice magic so she doesn't burn the forest then return

Her family are proud idiots who couldn't be assed to look for help outside of their forest in order to not appear weak.

It's not just breathing fire, any sound she would have made would have generated a overpowered magic fireball instantly. Imagine if she had a sneezing fit and burned down an entire city in seconds.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Nov 13, 2018
Messages
4,208
PeNLjIu.gif


The princess practically has the same issue as the witch girl from goblin slayer, its why the witch barely talks or talks after calculating every single word slowly because just her words alone could manifest a spell if she didn't pay attention
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 1, 2023
Messages
125
so she's not actually mute just enchanted/cursed to be mute so she doesn't breathe fire? i get sending her away from the forest but why mute her after that? she should have had a tutor sent with her and then spent her time abroad mastering her voice magic so she doesn't burn the forest then return
Like Reiji thinks at the end of the chapter, she'd probably need a Mana Control skill orb, and won't be able to just do it on her own.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
3,172
so she's not actually mute just enchanted/cursed to be mute so she doesn't breathe fire? i get sending her away from the forest but why mute her after that? she should have had a tutor sent with her and then spent her time abroad mastering her voice magic so she doesn't burn the forest then return
Think about how Disney princesses magically make animals appear, or have musical notes just pop up to let you know how musical their voices are, and replace that with Fire. Fire just wants to flow with her voice.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Apr 26, 2018
Messages
5,796
Thank u always for ur great work...
^^...

"It's the foooking taxes, mate"...
:dogkek:

Fire element elf, that's quite a lore a by itself, too bad those conservatif one r only seeing it as a problem...
(OωO`)...
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
4,554
so she's not actually mute just enchanted/cursed to be mute so she doesn't breathe fire? i get sending her away from the forest but why mute her after that? she should have had a tutor sent with her and then spent her time abroad mastering her voice magic so she doesn't burn the forest then return
It's not just that. If her fire abilities are known she becomes the greatest symbol of destruction for the elven forest. Even if she herself cannot control her power, getting her bloodline would be a juicy political piece for creating a counter-government elven organization.

So they shipped her off to an anti-magic country that is biologically very different in appearance to reduce the possibility that anyone would be interested in her at all.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jan 19, 2018
Messages
380
so she's not actually mute just enchanted/cursed to be mute so she doesn't breathe fire? i get sending her away from the forest but why mute her after that? she should have had a tutor sent with her and then spent her time abroad mastering her voice magic so she doesn't burn the forest then return
Simple shame. Page 3 literally spells out, that their voice is their life.

She's a high elf, imbued with an uncontrollable Forest consuming Fire power. They specifically mention that it would bring shame to the Royal Family, that they would birth someone that would be so destructive to their forests. The fact that she was even born, is a stain on the lineage of the royal family. A Cursed Royal Family, threatens the basis for their rule. Whoops, now everything is political. Someone with power(I'm guessing the King), chastises her (page 2), because even releasing tears might cause a conflagration and burn down their kingdom.

You don't train that away, you hide it in a tower away from the eyes of the populace. Even looking for someone to train/tutor her in the act, risks their terrible secret being revealed. In the event she is selfish enough to unleash it in a foreign land, they have deniability that she died through no fault of her lineage.


Without more details, they might possibly have accepted it if it was air, water, or earth. But without knowing more about the Voice part of their society, even that could be "fatal" to their political power. Perhaps even training the voice, is considered a taboo.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 20, 2024
Messages
732
Every good Isekai needs an elf waifu. Here she comes!

And MC is kinda like her in that he's older and more mature than he looks(being reincarnated).
so she's not actually mute just enchanted/cursed to be mute so she doesn't breathe fire? i get sending her away from the forest but why mute her after that? she should have had a tutor sent with her and then spent her time abroad mastering her voice magic so she doesn't burn the forest then return
Yeah it's a dumb plot contrivance. Couldn't the elves have just gotten her the right skill orb and a magic tutor? They should've known what Reiji figured out.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top