Mimi - Ch. 259 - Interpretation.

Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 28, 2023
Messages
226
I don't have enough info to make a moral jugement regarding the alagory you and this chapter referenced. I'm not sure what fairnece truly is. That being said what you originaly said sounded a lot like communism (but not socialism), heck it sounded like the borg's philosophy. I believe communism is wrong and borg philosophy is evil.
That is.....sure a lot to chew on. I truly think you misunderstood my meaning so far that you quite literally ended up in space.

So let me try it a different way. Lets say you give two people 100 dollars. One is a trust fund baby and the other is a baby of a single parent. You have given them the same starting point. Aka the one box for each.

The trust fund baby is able to pocket that money because their parents buy them anything. Later they use their parents connections to invest it. They use this as a spring board to start accruing their own wealth, in addition to their generational wealth.

The baby of the single mother holds onto theirs because they know how much their parent might be struggling. They slowly use it to pay for their school supplies or something. They have no fallback and no way to meaningfully invest it. So it dries up quickly and thats the end of it.

This scenario is the fence.

The idea of equality here is correct because both kids received equal money. They have been given the same "chance". But anyone knows that life isnt that simple. And context and upbringing and everything plays a huge role.

So for this to be fair: maybe you give the single parent child more to start with. Or dont give the trust fund baby any because they dont need it. There are ways to be fair that consider more than just "equality". The idea is that both kids are able to end up at the same place. That is seeing the baseball game.

And im going to stop the logical fallacy now before you say it: in this example, the single mother is in poverty. This is not always true and not true of all single mothers.

How on earth you got klingons and fucking dictatorship from that is beyond me and I literally cannot help you if you have made it to that point and still think thats what im trying to say.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 25, 2023
Messages
692
That is.....sure a lot to chew on. I truly think you misunderstood my meaning so far that you quite literally ended up in space.

So let me try it a different way. Lets say you give two people 100 dollars. One is a trust fund baby and the other is a baby of a single parent. You have given them the same starting point. Aka the one box for each.

The trust fund baby is able to pocket that money because their parents buy them anything. Later they use their parents connections to invest it. They use this as a spring board to start accruing their own wealth, in addition to their generational wealth.

The baby of the single mother holds onto theirs because they know how much their parent might be struggling. They slowly use it to pay for their school supplies or something. They have no fallback and no way to meaningfully invest it. So it dries up quickly and thats the end of it.

This scenario is the fence.

The idea of equality here is correct because both kids received equal money. They have been given the same "chance". But anyone knows that life isnt that simple. And context and upbringing and everything plays a huge role.

So for this to be fair: maybe you give the single parent child more to start with. Or dont give the trust fund baby any because they dont need it. There are ways to be fair that consider more than just "equality". The idea is that both kids are able to end up at the same place. That is seeing the baseball game.

And im going to stop the logical fallacy now before you say it: in this example, the single mother is in poverty. This is not always true and not true of all single mothers.

How on earth you got klingons and fucking dictatorship from that is beyond me and I literally cannot help you if you have made it to that point and still think thats what im trying to say.
"Fairness and humanitarianism means everyone ends at the same spot." In communism everybody earns the same no matter how much they deserve or need. Now that I think about what you originally said is kinda the opposite of communism.

Borg philosophy is about acquiring all technology and turning everyone homologous. Turing everyone into the same equal beings.

I see what your saying and I like your analogy more. That being said wouldn't a better solution be to pay for the poor kids expense then give both children the 100 dollars?
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 28, 2023
Messages
226
"Fairness and humanitarianism means everyone ends at the same spot." In communism everybody earns the same no matter how much they deserve or need. Now that I think about what you originally said is kinda the opposite of communism.

Borg philosophy is about acquiring all technology and turning everyone homologous. Turing everyone into the same equal beings.

I see what your saying and I like your analogy more. That being said wouldn't a better solution be to pay for the poor kids expense then give both children the 100 dollars?
Absolutely. Thats socialism. Skimming the top of the ultra wealthy to care for the destitute. Absolutely would be a better solution, but we are....sadly very far from that at this current point.

Another analogy comes straight from The Moon on a Rainy Night. She is hard of hearing, and partially focuses on reading lips. Her teacher confronts her about it and she says "its not a big deal. I just take notes from others during the time you turn away and I cant see your lips." He in turn teaches her the difference in equality versus fairness. Equality is everyone taking the same class. Fairness is everyone getting a chance to learn the same amount. So he starts making a point to not speak when he is facing the board and not the class. God I love that series, as someone else who has hearing issues
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 29, 2024
Messages
2,430
That is.....sure a lot to chew on. I truly think you misunderstood my meaning so far that you quite literally ended up in space.

So let me try it a different way. Lets say you give two people 100 dollars. One is a trust fund baby and the other is a baby of a single parent. You have given them the same starting point. Aka the one box for each.

The trust fund baby is able to pocket that money because their parents buy them anything. Later they use their parents connections to invest it. They use this as a spring board to start accruing their own wealth, in addition to their generational wealth.

The baby of the single mother holds onto theirs because they know how much their parent might be struggling. They slowly use it to pay for their school supplies or something. They have no fallback and no way to meaningfully invest it. So it dries up quickly and thats the end of it.

This scenario is the fence.

The idea of equality here is correct because both kids received equal money. They have been given the same "chance". But anyone knows that life isnt that simple. And context and upbringing and everything plays a huge role.

So for this to be fair: maybe you give the single parent child more to start with. Or dont give the trust fund baby any because they dont need it. There are ways to be fair that consider more than just "equality". The idea is that both kids are able to end up at the same place. That is seeing the baseball game.

And im going to stop the logical fallacy now before you say it: in this example, the single mother is in poverty. This is not always true and not true of all single mothers.

How on earth you got klingons and fucking dictatorship from that is beyond me and I literally cannot help you if you have made it to that point and still think thats what im trying to say.
Maybe the short kid should get his own box, no one DESERVES anything to be FREELY given to them.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 12, 2019
Messages
1,280
The whole idea is that equality doesnt stop anything. You cant just give people "equal chance" if their situations are so skewed. Thats how you get poverty and billionaires. True fairness would be getting the shorted person more boxes so they both end up at same heigh
Equality is in quotations in the original poster because equality was never truly obtained in that scenario.
Yes, for there to be equality the shorter side would need one more box.
You can't give everyone "a box" and said you solved an equality problem, you gave everyone a push when some start better off than others.
Let's say everyone can get this one job, as long as they pass an exam. It's the same opportunity for everyone, rich and poor, right?
Well, not exactly, because the rich would have better education. A poor guy growing up would be having to manage time between studying, working some part time to help his family, taking care of siblings, having worst nutrition, stressing over neighborhood violence, going to an overall worst school that receives less funds, etc.
So in the end, the oportunity "for everyone" is just really skewed towards people who already hold and advantage.
I don't have enough info to make a moral jugement regarding the alagory you and this chapter referenced. I'm not sure what fairnece truly is. That being said what you originaly said sounded a lot like communism (but not socialism), heck it sounded like the borg's philosophy. I believe communism is wrong and borg philosophy is evil.
It's neither, what's being discussed here is basic social democracy, center-left stuff.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Sep 12, 2019
Messages
1,280
In communism everybody earns the same no matter how much they deserve or need.
"To each according to his ability; to each according to his need" is one of the most well known communist slogan.

Just explaining the basics because you seem to be misunderstanding communism:
The whole idea behind communism is that you don't have access to all the value you produce as a worker, because the burgeoise need their cut.
So if the workforce had ownership of the means of production i.e the people as a group are the owners of the factories, land, machinery and natural resources, then we can produce stuff we actually need in a number we actually consume instead of overproducing and overworking for corporate profit.
 
Joined
Jun 10, 2020
Messages
5
Since it's started some spirited discussion, here's the origin of the shit meme referenced.
Or not having a fence there in the first place.
:pepehmm:
Educators stealing this meme in the past ten years generally add extra boxes to delineate between reality, equality, equity, and justice, with justice being removing the fence entirely - with no systemic barrier in place, you don't have to keep addressing the problem with each new short king who walks by.
For the people tackling this joke panel like it's their first time ever thinking about this topic in their entire life I encourage you to try giving a listen to Rush's song "The Trees," 1978, which tackles the issue in a more holistic way. (Keep in mind that maples grow better with filtered light, and sunscald is a common problem in hotter climates...)
Nothing is without a cost. The boxes aren't proportionate, what do you do if it's not an equal number of tall kids to steal boxes from and short kids to give them to, the fence is the only thing keeping the ballfield open, fiddling with the boxes undermines the efforts of the people in the middle, etc. etc. Most importantly, if you pass out the boxes equanimously you lose your excuse to alleyoop the short kid over the fence and run away laughing.
 
Last edited:
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Aug 31, 2025
Messages
1,489
Since it's started some spirited discussion, here's the origin of the shit meme referenced.

Educators stealing this meme in the past ten years generally add extra boxes to delineate between reality, equality, equity, and justice, with justice being removing the fence entirely - with no systemic barrier in place, you don't have to keep addressing the problem with each new short king who walks by.
For the people tackling this joke panel like it's their first time ever thinking about this topic in their entire life I encourage you to try giving a listen to Rush's song "The Trees," 1978, which tackles the issue in a more holistic way. (Keep in mind that maples grow better with filtered light, and sunscald is a common problem in hotter climates...)
Nothing is without a cost. The boxes aren't proportionate, what do you do if it's not an equal number of tall kids to steal boxes from and short kids to give them to, the fence is the only thing keeping the ballfield open, fiddling with the boxes undermines the efforts of the people in the middle, etc. etc. Most importantly, if you pass out the boxes equanimously you lose your excuse to alleyoop the short kid over the fence and run away laughing.
It’s the limit of every metaphor: it’s an oversimplification of a complex problem. Doesn’t mean it isn’t a good starting point.

We can discuss agricultural policy for hours, debating whether everyone should be given equal opportunities and then free competition gets to weed out the ineffective farmers, or if competition against farmers from a country where the cost of living is a tenth of yours is actually fair, or if certain types of farmers should be subsidized to ease out unfair competition, and then on what criteria and to what level, and that’s basically the Common Agricultural Policy all over again, and we haven’t even spoken of the rights of non-owning agricultural workers and the abuse of immigration in agriculture as a mean of social dumping, etc.

Or we can remember that in some societies, one couldn’t have property of more land than what they could farm themselves. That’s felling the fence. It’s not a perfect solution, and maybe it has more drawbacks than advantages. But it’s never a bad idea to at least study the fence-felling solution to a problem.
:thumbsup:

But I agree that your last sentence is the most important and truest of this whole debate.
:kek:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top