Cosmograph - Ch. 1 - A Slave Boy

Fed-Kun's army
Joined
Jun 14, 2024
Messages
34
FIRST SILVER MOUNTAIN AND NOW COSMOGRAPH? ARE YOU A MAGIC GENIUS FULFILLING MY WISHES?

I will happily follow both, thank you for translating this, i have high hopes for this new manga of the same author of Last Karte, it surprised me nobody picked this sooner, but now im happy the one who picked is the same who does an amazing work with another of my favorites (Silver Mountain)
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Mar 17, 2026
Messages
2,858
This is pretty good, hope this won't get axed and hoping to see more chapters, although I doubt it will have long before the axe.. :nyoron:
Real talk, how accurate and updated is a map in past is truly a status symbol, a GOOD ROYAL cartographer back then was as IMPORTANT as a ROYAL, answering to the king as he is vital to any kingdom.
That he is seen as below a mere travelling priest probably is the only off part on this, as a travelling priest is only as important as a peasant. Honestly rather than accompanied by priest, it makes more sense if there are 1-2 medical personnels/apprentice (doctor was rare so issuing travelling doctor can be a problem) to go with him.
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Jun 18, 2026
Messages
1,320
The "kid" is not wrong at being suspicious, some aprentices had another "duty" with their love.. i mean "masters"
 
Group Leader
Joined
Jan 6, 2019
Messages
131
The writing's kinda clumsy, but the art is freaking awesome.
I think I get what you mean. I felt the same way. It's not bad by any means, it's just really not subtle sometimes. Both in the things it's saying and the way it's put together.

It somehow feels "rushed" in spots despite being so ginormous, but I don't hold that against it cuz it truly covered an insane amount of stuff for a chapter 1. There's just no great flow from one thing to the next so you can kinda see the inner workings of the writing and it feels a little bit less polished, I guess, even if it was probably an intentional (page-saving?) choice to do that.

That said, I'm really enamored with not only the art and the expressiveness of the characters, but with the insane amount of words the author manages to fit on each page (tho it makes more work for me lol) and the varied topics discussed. The suuuper fast pace of the dialogue and how the topic can just swing all over, with random asides to address something or as character moments ("why are you so big!?")... that part is what really stood out to me as a skill of the author's
 
Dex-chan lover
Joined
Feb 17, 2024
Messages
2,026
covered an insane amount of stuff for a chapter 1
Yeah, that's a lot. You could make a whole volume out of these events. You could spend several chapters exploring the island, and defending it. Reminds me of these European Donald Duck comics that had this half-serious fantasy or sci-fi setting with wacky pacing and great art, but those were standalone oneshots.
A whole bunch of little things didn't make sense to me. Like why does this kid act like a grizzled 50-year-old sea dog who's seen everything and got sick of everything? How come he's so smart, especially about stuff like tactics? Why would pirates occupy this tiny island (main commodity - apples) and attack it with such inferior numbers and zero intel? It's like an age-of-sail setting but there aren't any guns, huh. Killing the captain raises morale rather than cause panic?
It's just slightly off in many weird ways.
 
Group Leader
Joined
Jul 7, 2018
Messages
82
Good start, confident at the very least the author can put forward some super beautiful and varied locales to explore with the concept of creating and filling out maps.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top