I'm positive that he'd agree even more if he found out that Ichika's Dad was also the person doing those riddles, but I also think he would not be able to keep that secret for long
I was thinking that something happened that made him have to follow the Church Knight Order. Maybe they had some type of leverage or cure to him that forced him to join their ranks.
Actually it would be even funnier. Imagine the guy's just drinking his loneliness away and when he opens the door an 8 ft tall Amazonian is there saying "I'm 18 now, Sensei. You know what that means."
Baby fluff ball wouldn't know that his master is in love, FMC is intentionally ignoring the possibility of him having a crush on her, all while there are large signs and flags showing the obvious
This reminds me of when I tried to hide the F I had on my report card. I tried saying I lost it, but the teacher had already called, sent an email of my report card, and also had copies. I couldn't hide anything
Honestly, she was not thinking anything through in the slightest, especially with her mind hard set on thinking everyone and everything is just part of the story and she has no effect on things even after DRASTICALLY changing the story