Search results

  1. C

    742517

    @Liar Art doesn't imply that anything goes. The author's mistakes here are not intentional, so we are not talking about him intentionally distorting his characters to achieve some artistic goal - it's just lack of skill/practice. Arguing that this is a positive aspect is ridiculous. Granted...
  2. C

    742517

    @WarFirel This is not an opinion, it is a fact. Consult an anatomy book/an actual artist to see all perspective, proportion, and anatomical mistakes the artists makes. Anatomy, proportions and perspective are not subjective notions, so as much as you frame it as an opinion, it is not.
  3. C

    742517

    @WarFirel That is not an opinion, that's a fact. The author cannot handle proportions, anatomy, or perspective. None of the pages you mentioned have anything impressive in them, while all contain mistakes.
  4. C

    742517

    @WarFirel Are you joking right now? The art is terrible. I still wonder how the author didn't manage to improve much over the course of 123 chapters.
  5. C

    Ura Account Joshi - Vol. 1 Ch. 2 - Case 2: Kuramoto Satsuki (Middle)

    @obsidianpassion I disagree that the emphasis here was simply about an unfortunate incident. This "incident" was a direct result of her partner not really caring about her. What we saw was a naive girl that got taken advantage of. She was deluding herself to the very end that she was "so...
  6. C

    Hazure Skill "Kage ga Usui" o Motsu Guild Shokuin ga, Jitsuha Densetsu no Ansatsusha

    "Poser" - the manga. 90% of the time we have the MC flexing. It's just stupid.
  7. C

    Inaka ni Sundeiru to Kou iu Koto Nai?? - Oneshot

    I don't mind, I found this thanks to your TL. The TL is worse than in the other version though.
  8. C

    Shibito no Koe wo Kiku ga Yoi - Vol. 11 Ch. 69 - To Touch a Ghost

    @Freestyle You have an issue with a 15yo having sex with a ghost? I see you are not a man of culture.
  9. C

    Shibito no Koe wo Kiku ga Yoi - Vol. 11 Ch. 69 - To Touch a Ghost

    He should have used this opportunity though.
  10. C

    I Have a Happy Dream - Oneshot

    @gomichandesu The issue here is that you are taking a metaphorical and psychological experience, and trying to read into it literally, while adding interpretations not evident from the original text. There is no indicator for suffering, nor a sign that this was anything beyond a metaphorical...
  11. C

    I Have a Happy Dream - Oneshot

    @gomichandesu It was not suffering that kept him from dying, it was life support, so there's no reason to believe this symbolized suffering. His inability to cross the river, caused by the storm, was clearly symbolizing his inability to die. The river is either a reference to the Sanzu river or...
  12. C

    Ura Account Joshi - Vol. 1 Ch. 1 - Case 1: Kuramoto Satsuki (Start)

    @megumon I don't have any issue with you evaluating the manga as garbage or stupid. I have an issue with you acting as if the group is doing somebody a disservice, and in general the entitled attitude that comes off from your comments when it concerns what the group "should" scanlate.
  13. C

    Ura Account Joshi - Vol. 1 Ch. 1 - Case 1: Kuramoto Satsuki (Start)

    @megumon You make it sound as if it were a crime, while it is the opposite. The scanlators use their free time in order to bring this to others, I believe that any hint at "reprimanding" them, even if motivated by reasons such as the manga being "objectively" bad is unwarranted. And clearly...
  14. C

    Yume no Tsudzuki

    Taking regular breaks and having physical exercise make you more productive anyways.
  15. C

    Anata no Kage wo Ou

    Cheap. Unimaginative. Low-effort.
  16. C

    I Have a Happy Dream - Oneshot

    @shrot1234 The problem is that you can't know that. Said person may have come out of comma after some time. There was also no sign that they were in "constant suffering".
  17. C

    Dekinai-ko - Oneshot

    @PowerNine I think that the issue is that at their core they ultimately are pretentious spiels. The whole thing relies on the readers' emitional reactions overwhelming and suspending their critical faculties - what you refer to as "relate to what the hell he's on about". If anything these...
  18. C

    Ura Account Joshi - Vol. 1 Ch. 2 - Case 2: Kuramoto Satsuki (Middle)

    @Tamerlane They met at a public place initially. Whether she had met him online or irl is irrelevant to her decision to go to his house - this was a product of her naivete. I'll reiterate - there's nothing wrong with meeting someone you met online, in a public place. The issue here was not her...
  19. C

    I Have a Happy Dream - Oneshot

    @shrot1234 How is being dead equivalent to being in a better place?
  20. C

    Ura Account Joshi - Vol. 1 Ch. 2 - Case 2: Kuramoto Satsuki (Middle)

    @Tamerlane @kazu19 You have never been on a date with someone you first met online? I am sorry to disappoint you, but not everyone you meet online is a serial killer/psychopath - at most you have a higher chance of meeting manchildren and socially awkward people. You can get...
Top