Search results

  1. E

    Koujo Tensei: Densetsu no Dai Madoushi (♂), Hime Kishi to Narite Densetsu no Reijou Kishidan o Tsukuri Musou Suru

    Hm, pretty good, I rate it 7.5 / 10, rounded up to 8 for now. The main nerd character got reincarnated as a princess, and with that tip-top body... aspires to become a musclebrain warrior. Yeah, that's fairly novel. So far, there's no RPG-type status windows. I appreciate that, these manga...
  2. E

    Yoku Wakaranai Keredo Isekai ni Tensei Shiteita You Desu - Vol. 23 Ch. 109

    Hmmmmm... I mean, it's mostly peaceful, and just wants people from killing its kin, so it feels like people could just accept its presence and adjust their economic activity, and things would be OK. Like, maybe having a giant magical turtle around makes more magical herbs grow or something?
  3. E

    Ruri Dragon

    Good manga, 9/10. One of few mangas I bother reading off-site. It's interesting how the MC gains unpredictable dragon powers... and then that simply becomes the trigger to socialize and get along more with her classmates. They are some of the most realistic - though chill - classmates I've...
  4. E

    Yama, Kaimashita ~Isekai Gurashi mo Warukunai~

    Pretty decent slice-of-life base-building, I rate it as 7.5, rounded down for now. It's cool and all, watching a mountain region be developed, but because she brute-forces every problem with Saintess power and her reality-bending tablet, there's nothing really relevant or interesting about it...
  5. E

    Kizetsu Yuusha to Ansatsu Hime

    This is good, actually! I give it 9/10. I was worried at first that the author would keep the plot in a permanent status quo and the premise would wear thin, but things are actually progressing. Chapter 33-34 were especially good. Memorable characters, nice humor, a novel plot, AND character...
  6. E

    Saikyou Onna Shishou-tachi ga Ikusei Houshin o Megutte Shuraba - Vol. 9 Ch. 58 - On A Night When The Stars Fall

    I'm very meh about his party, honestly. Isn't it mostly people who tried to do horrible things to Cross, but then joined the winning side when they failed? I feel like the "would do horrible things" part ought to disqualify them from being part of the good guys...
  7. E

    Isekai Craft Gurashi: Jiyuu Kimama na Seisan Shoku no Honobono Slow Life - Vol. 2 Ch. 10.1

    I mean, if there can be half-orcs, they're a fairly closely related species. Though some settings have half-dragons running around, so... Dragons feel a bit like whales to me; someone eating it for enjoyment isn't necessarily a psychopath who would happily chop me up next, but I'd certainly...
  8. E

    Saikyou no Shokugyou wa Yuusha Demo Kenja Demo Naku Kanteishi (Kari) Rashii Desu yo?

    I keep dropping this, coming back a year later and starting over. Now I arrived at the 'let's be a slave owner!' arc again, and I'm feeling the resounding sense of 'meh' that means soon I'll leave this manga in a 'look at this later' tab and forget about it for another year. Anyway, I rate...
  9. E

    Ura Kagyou Tensei ~Moto Gokudou ga Kazoku no Tame ni Ryouchi Hatten Sasemasu ga Nani ka?~

    So far, this is acceptable. 7/10, your average rudeus-like. It has the potential for more... if the author steps up. See, the author hasn't screwed up in any major way yet, but that only gets you to 7 in my rating system. To get higher, the manga needs to actually be memorable, through good...
  10. E

    Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality - Ch. 1 - A Day of Very Low Probability

    Oh hey, nice! HPMoR was pretty damn good, so this could be fun :)
  11. E

    Mahou Shoujo × Haiboku Saiban

    This is some rancid world-building. Like, this is the kind of setting where the same evil god created Monsters, Magical Girls and the Magical Girl Justice System, specifically so they could hand out fates worse than death to pretty girls for the lulz. This could actually be the foundation for a...
  12. E

    Dappou Tamer no Nariagari Boukentan: S-Rank Bishoujo Boukensha ga Ore no Juuma ni Natteimasu THE COMIC

    I rate this as 6.5/10, rounded up. The art is OK, I guess the world seems OK, but the main problem is story-wise. Everything the MC gets comes to him out of nowhere, entirely undeserved. He basically doesn't make a single decision; the bubbly catgirl is the de facto brains of the party, he is...
  13. E

    Umarekawatta "Kensei" wa Raku wo Shitai

    I rate this 7.5/10, rounded down. The art is OK, but Mahou Sensei Negima is just so much better at the 'kid teacher undercover at academy' thing. The secret is that action sequences are boring. Dramatic posing and cliché speeches are boring. Do you know how many times I've seen mysterious...
  14. E

    Murabito Tensei - Saikyou no Slow Life

    Hmmm. 5/10. I see stories like this sometimes, but there's not a good word yet for the particular quality. Hm. "Trope-based physics", I guess. Or "Plot stylization". People in this manga behave as caricatures; there are limited modes of interaction, such as the Tsumommi/boke-routine, and...
  15. E

    Monster Musume no Iru Nichijou - Vol. 20 Ch. 91

    Once the MC finally gets his matrimony on, I figure Rachnera needs to be the main wife, Centorea as #2 because she'd be a horrible boss but a great second-in-command, and then Miia at #3 acting as the muscle to wrangle the rest. As for Suu and Papi... adopt them, I guess? Originally it was...
  16. E

    Tenseisha wa Seken Shirazu: Tokuten Skill de Slow Life!?

    If he received only non-combat Skills, that'd be halfway interesting (though done before), but this guy also got five elemental mana skills right at start, so... Are we supposed to be surprised when he turns out to be a powerhouse?
  17. E

    Eroi Koto Suru Tame ni Kyonyuu Bishoujo Dorei wo Katta Hazu ga, Oshishou-sama to Shitawa Rete Omotta Toori ni Ikanaku Naru Hanashi - Vol. 4 Ch. 20 - …

    It's nice to see this many people being critical about the whole slavery subplot :) Perfecting slavery enchantments just seems moronic; wouldn't slavery become even more abused than it already is, if it's no longer the case that any decent magician can dissolve a slave seal? Once the updated...
  18. E

    Harem Ou no Isekai Press Manyuuki: Saikyou Musou no Ojisan wa Arayuru Shuzoku o Yome ni suru - Vol. 4 Ch. 14

    I note that other mangas would drag this kind of plot progression out over, like, five chapters or something. Owl saved, final boss set, new quest get!, go to new city, encounter side-quest, solve side-quest. This is admirably good pacing.
  19. E

    Seventh - Vol. 3 Ch. 15.2 - Reward (part2)

    lol, get harem'd, idiot It's kind of novel to have the female love interest be the one pushing for a harem, though of course it would be better IMO if she turns out to be secretly bisexual and digging the harem situation for that reason.
Top