Search results

She says that because he's been consistently misinterpreting reasons for her decisions. The first "he doesn't know anything" happens back in ch. 26, where he asks if she wants to go somewhere and she says she is fine like this - and he likely thinks she is being lazy (as proven by his "You're...

It was hypothetical and it did describe the "present state" of their relationship - which is "she ghosted him and they basically broke up". That's why she uses "would". They are not contradicting her thoughts there. My point about chapter 30 always was that she is not being regretful about him...

Sorry. But it kinda feels like saying "if there's even a trace of ambiguity, I'm going to treat it in my favor". Which is a valid approach, just makes it even more difficult to find a middle ground. Because I definitely don't find it consistent with the story, same about the art supporting it...

I thought we leave such cases as ambigous because I think it's kinda always the case when portraying a couple in the middle of the crowd - all focus is on them, while other people are there just as a background. As for the second thing, Maruto just expressed that these extra chapters (+the...

Well, there's no subjunctive in the manga version. Should we write this point off because of an ambiguous translation? If he's with her for sex, why is he still insisting on going to the movie? When did Yuu ever say anything about anyone being serious or not serious? We basically never saw him...

Where does it say he wasn't? Your argument revolves around your own intepretation of what she was saying back in 29 (even though she was simply responding to his "Next week there's a fireworks festival! ...oh, wait. There's no way you'd wade into a crazy crowd like that."), and even in this...

The initial translation (I mean your Ru -> En) was pretty accurate I'd say. It says "At this pace she's gonna break up with the guy". They likely went for this TL because the original had where orange is otoko = guy.

And you know she's dead serious how? Quotes? I thought he's still with her for sex? This chapter. I thought he's with her for sex?

I hope you realize there's no beating this kind of "argument". No matter what he does, no matter how much effort he puts in it, you can always just go "she probably thinks he's trying to play the role of a decent dude". You ignore how she keeps thinking of him as kind and naive, you ignore that...

Doing the right thing again, yeah. She wants the truth and doesn't want her love life to be full of lies. I mean, when I say goody two-shoes, I mean it as a character who is virtuous in every aspect, not just in some specific situation, a character who always does the right thing.

She says "I can make it up to you", which indicates him buying the tickets. That's exactly why I said 2000 yen - which is an average movie ticket cost. So does she think he is that greedy that he values those 2000 yen and, okay, some 30 minutes of time over sex? Did she talk to him in 13.5...

Sure thing. Even if she didn't intend to betray Hikari, she still knew it would be a betrayal to kiss Yuu there. I mean, sure, but that just adds another point to her goody two-shoes account. She can never do a wrong thing. Even when faced with betrayal by her best friend, she goes for a...

He bought the tickets, so I'd say it's pretty clear who organized it. And she is the one who ends up unwilling to go. Yuu's attitude directly speaks of him prioritizing watching a movie over going to the hotel. So either she thinks he is so so so greedy that he values 2000 yen over sex or there...

There's no "bait" at the start. Forget what Yami said, it's normal to accuse of betrayal before your conversation even begins. Betrayal without malice is still a betrayal. So he does understand that she likes him? Because obviously it's trying to close the door, she says her farewell after...

But what about sex that he is supposed to be craving yet chooses watching a movie over? I thought this was supposed to be worrying her according to you. What is "it"? I'm not sure why you're being so stubborn about it. Your old idea was something like this: "After one half-assed atttempt to...

It's irrelevant what Yami wants. I'm saying it's natural to accuse your best friend of betrayal after the actual betrayal. That's what I thought: But her thoughts from 44 don't support this idea at all, and she's still just simply worried about Yami. Did she good bye kiss him simply out of...

How does it even work? She thinks he only wants sex, but when he refuses to go have sex, it's only because he paid for tickets, i.e. he actually wants sex but is so greedy that 2000 yen for movie tickets are more valuable than sex? No, that's not my point. My point is that she doesn't need to...

When Hikari went to meet her in the classroom, she didn't; at the very least she didn't throw a single accusation and was more keen on defending Yami than she herself did. It would be equally baffling if they didn't meet and didn't have that whole conversation. After that, I'd say it's not that...

I am not sure how this correlates with the chapter where Yuu is explicitly trying to get Yami to watch a movie instead of going to the hotel. I thought this should be a surefire way to prove that Yami wasn't worried about that, but apparently not. I think that's just the aspect you singled out...

Because betrayal hurts much more. And as I said already, I think for Yuu that meeting is much more "mixed feelings" territory than "terrible experience". Umm, what threw a wrench is the fact that he was hiding the relationship and then the truth came to light after he tried to lie about it...